X

Create an account to continue reading.

Registered readers have access to our blogs and a limited number of magazine articles
For unlimited access to The Spectator, subscribe below

Registered readers have access to our blogs and a limited number of magazine articles

Sign in to continue

Already have an account?

What's my subscriber number?

Subscribe now from £1 a week

Online

Unlimited access to The Spectator including the full archive from 1828

Print

Weekly delivery of the magazine

App

Phone & tablet edition of the magazine

Spectator Club

Subscriber-only offers, events and discounts
 
View subscription offers

Already a subscriber?

or

Subscribe now for unlimited access

ALL FROM JUST £1 A WEEK

View subscription offers

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

Thank you for creating an account – Your subscriber number was not recognised though. To link your subscription visit the My Account page

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

X

Login

Don't have an account? Sign up
X

Subscription expired

Your subscription has expired. Please go to My Account to renew it or view subscription offers.

X

Forgot Password

Please check your email

If the email address you entered is associated with a web account on our system, you will receive an email from us with instructions for resetting your password.

If you don't receive this email, please check your junk mail folder.

X

It's time to subscribe.

You've read all your free Spectator magazine articles for this month.

Subscribe now for unlimited access – from just £1 a week

You've read all your free Spectator magazine articles for this month.

Subscribe now for unlimited access

Online

Unlimited access to The Spectator including the full archive from 1828

Print

Weekly delivery of the magazine

App

Phone & tablet edition of the magazine

Spectator Club

Subscriber-only offers, events and discounts
X

Sign up

What's my subscriber number? Already have an account?

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

Thank you for creating an account – Your subscriber number was not recognised though. To link your subscription visit the My Account page

Thank you for creating your account – To update your details click here to manage your account

X

Your subscriber number is the 8 digit number printed above your name on the address sheet sent with your magazine each week. If you receive it, you’ll also find your subscriber number at the top of our weekly highlights email.

Entering your subscriber number will enable full access to all magazine articles on the site.

If you cannot find your subscriber number then please contact us on customerhelp@subscriptions.spectator.co.uk or call 0330 333 0050. If you’ve only just subscribed, you may not yet have been issued with a subscriber number. In this case you can use the temporary web ID number, included in your email order confirmation.

You can create an account in the meantime and link your subscription at a later time. Simply visit the My Account page, enter your subscriber number in the relevant field and click 'submit changes'.

If you have any difficulties creating an account or logging in please take a look at our FAQs page.

Books

Method in her magic

12 May 2012

5:00 PM

12 May 2012

5:00 PM

Bring Up the Bodies Hilary Mantel

Fourth Estate, pp.411, 20

Bring Up the Bodies, as everybody knows, is the sequel to Wolf Hall, Hilary Mantel’s fictional re-imagining of the life and times of Henry VIII’s most effective servant, Thomas Cromwell. We have long been banging our spoons and forks for it. Speaking for myself, I finished the first with an almost unbearable curiosity to find out what was going to happen next — a strange result, when you think of it, because we all know perfectly well what is going to happen.

Mantel is comprehensive with her sources. Every scene is secured, like a piano key to its hammer, to the corresponding page of the great 21-volume Calendar of State Papers of Henry’s reign. The last book ended with the death of Sir Thomas More, therefore in this one Katherine of Aragon will die; the Boleyn queen will lose two babies, she will be arrested along with her five ‘lovers’ and the king will chop all their heads off. That much we know; of all the episodes in what Mantel has called our ‘national soap opera’ — Tudor history — this is the most often rehearsed.

However, the reason for the continuous re-fashioning of this one story is that nobody knows what actually happened. The fall of Anne Boleyn is one of our history’s curiosities and has always been told with liberal recourse to subjunctives. Her decline was erratic and unpredictable; she was up, down, up again in the months before she died and she fell suddenly, like a tumbling pigeon shot in the heart.

The coup was achieved quickly, efficiently and discreetly. If there were papers, they are destroyed. And sitting at the centre of the conundrum is the question: what role did Thomas Cromwell take in it?


Was he the originator or just the executor of the plot, acting on the King’s instructions?

This is where we look to Mantel. Not for the truth in the literal sense; but for an explanation to bind up the contradictions and fill the empty spaces in the story, to satisfy our objections, to furnish the lost conversations which make sense of the mystery. We know her to be capable of this. In her historical fiction, the rubble of research is ground to a dust so fine that it settles into every phrase, every glance and gesture, so that we seem really to see through eyes that opened on the late 15th century. In Bring Up the Bodies an afternoon moon is ‘mean as a clipped coin’; Cromwell’s cook looks at a ball of dough ‘as if it were the head of the Baptist’. She excels at using what we know to show us what we can’t imagine: the familiar Holbein portrait of Jane Seymour, unamiable in a gable hood, shivers to life in a scene where the entire Seymour clan descend on her with that headgear, to enhance the distinction between their mild daughter and the (unbiddable, French hood-wearing) Boleyn queen.

Even so, she has got her work cut out.  Feats of invention will be especially necessary to flesh out the courtiers who go down with Anne, men with scant traces in the written record who were, if they appeared at all, the most shadowy personages in Wolf Hall. Also, one wonders how on earth she will retain our sympathy for the book’s hero and central consciousness, Cromwell, when he becomes Henry’s most feared subject, principal spymaster and minister with portfolio for exceedingly nasty deeds.  

Bring Up the Bodies succeeds brilliantly in every particle of this: it’s an imaginative achievement to exhaust superlatives. The Boleyn dénoument is managed with such stealth that its bloody outcome seems to creep up on Cromwell himself, and, as in life, it is only looking backward that the start and the finish connect: ‘You reach for the blade but the blood is already shed.’

Historical paradoxes resolve in the contradictions of personality. There are delicious new characters like Lady Rochford, Anne Boleyn’s sister-in-law, for whom malice is as exciting as love. As for the insubstantial courtiers, Anne’s ‘lovers’, Mantel has raised five distinct beings, some from nothing more than scraps of inventoried fabric and lists of offices, and given us their fatal interviews with Cromwell with such realistic detail that one might think she’d shimmered through the Tower walls with a shorthand notebook. If this was really the 16th century, she might be taken as a witch.

But she isn’t a witch or time-traveller, though she could be a genius. There is method in her magic and if this is good enough to stand as a re-telling for all time, it’s because it’s first a telling for our own times. Mantel has understood how many of those qualities which made Cromwell a villain in his own day can be made to appeal to the 21st-century reader. Unlike the 3rd Duke of Norfolk, we like a mushroom man. What looked to the 16th century like a ‘blacksmith’s cur’ can be shown to us as an egalitarian, semi-secular, urban, cosmopolitan rationalist with coal dust in his veins. Add to this the invented aspects — Cromwell as avenger for Wolsey’s fall, Cromwell as domestic libertarian with a large, jolly household of bouncy, independent minded girls and ‘servants from every nation under the sun’ — and you have somebody who feels like an ally in this strange landscape.

Bring Up the Bodies is mediated through a consciousness (Cromwell’s) which anticipates our own values, with the result that the rest of them — the priests, princes, courtiers, ministers, monks and martyrs — seem exasperatingly attached to alien considerations of religion, privilege, patronage, honour and precedence.

This means sympathy for Master Secretary and rather less of it for a ‘silken gentleman’ like Sir Henry Norris, here ‘spider of spiders, black centre of the vast dripping web of court patronage’, even when he’s choosing death over dishonesty. As for Mantel’s Anne, she’s always been a pinched and stony-hearted bitch whom no one could care for. Anyway, I finished the book lost in pleasure and admiration for the mind that made it. I wonder what will happen next.

Subscribe to The Spectator today for a quality of argument not found in any other publication. Get more Spectator for less – just £12 for 12 issues.


Show comments
Close