New Police Mission: DNA-Farming

Tuesday, 24th November 2009

Can this really be true? Apparently and alas unsuprisingly the answer seems to be yes:

Police are routinely arresting people simply to record their DNA profiles on the national database, according to a report published today...
The revelations will fuel the debate about the DNA database, the world’s largest. They are included in a report by the Human Genetics Commission, an independent government advisory body. It criticises the piecemeal development of the database and questions how effective it is in helping the police to investigate and solve crimes.
[...]Professor Montgomery said there was some evidence that people were arrested to retain the DNA information even though they might not have been arrested in other circumstance.
He said that a retired senior police officer told the commission: “It is now the norm to arrest offenders for everything if there is a power to do so. It is apparently understood by serving police officers that one of the reasons . . . is so that DNA can be obtained.” He said that the tradition of only arresting someone when dealing with serious offences had collapsed.

Again, this is an area in which the Tories have spent some time talking a good game. That's easy in opposition. The test will come should they win the election and then find themselves at the mercy of both the police lobby (in England) and their own authoritarian instincts. Away from the public finances, combatting the kind of culture that produces the mentality behind this sort of caper is one of the more, perhaps most, pressing tasks the Conservatives will face.

[Thanks to RF for the tip.]

Filed under: Civil liberties (13 more articles) , Police (20 more articles)

Previous Back to Alex Massie Next

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Melanie Phillips | Coffee House | Faith Based

Actions: Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (5)

Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Post comment

Beefeater

November 24th, 2009 5:44am Report this comment

Take the DNA of every child born in a hospital, of every patient in the NHS system, every immigrant upon entry, as well as upon arrest. That should help the police enormously. The mentality behind such a caper? Catching the right criminal.
Less authoritarian than cameras.
The culture of self-realization has answered the question of identity.

Naomi Muse

November 24th, 2009 8:40am Report this comment

Perhaps we should dig deeper on this one and ask if the police are on commission or have targets for numbers of new dna samples in a week or month?

How far up does this go or is it a back door government target which they are meeting?

Nicholas

November 24th, 2009 12:17pm Report this comment

Might be the result of a secret New Labour/ACPO policy like Neathergate and Operation Brace. It seems the exercise of police powers and the laws governing them (where they exist) are just not getting the parliamentary scrutiny that they should be.