Shocker! Liam Fox is Right!

Tuesday, 17th May 2011

This, Watson, is the salient fact to be gleaned from the stramash over International Development funding. There is nothing especially wrong with aspiring* to spend 0.7% of GDP on overseas aid but it's wrong to legislate to make this a legal requirement. Wrong because government should not try to tie the hands of or otherwise control their successors. Sure, Messrs Blair and Brown may have done this to Dave and the Gang but, as even a cursory acquaintance with the Good Book should remind them, that's no excuse for doing likewise to their own descendents.

Similarly, of course, putting the so-called "Military Covenant" into law is a Bad Idea.If Dr Fox weren't so enthused by his own ill-judged piece of symbolic claptrap he'd have a better case for opposing the similarly ill-judged pieces of claptrap favoured by other departments.

At this point I think I should also make it clear that Dr Fox's lawyers become most upset when anyone suggests his office or people enjoy leaking letters he's sent to the Prime Minister. I make no such claim nor even the tiniest inference that this could have happened on this occasion and want to make it quite plain to the good Doctor and his learned friends that I've not the faintest idea who leaked this letter.

*The politics of this are not difficult. Of course it's ridiculous to spare DFD when other departments are having their budgets cut. Of course foreign aid is unpopular. That's why the policy will endure. It's not considered unpopular enough to cost the Conservatives very many vote but it is believed to be a powerful symbol demonstrating that the Tories really have "changed". This has value even if many of the people most impressed by boosting DFID's budget will never, ever vote Tory. It's not really a policy meant for them either.

Filed under: Britain (738 more articles) , Cameron (227 more articles) , International development (69 more articles) , Liam Fox (135 more articles) , MoD (18 more articles)

Previous Back to Alex Massie Next

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Melanie Phillips | Coffee House | Faith Based

Actions: Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (3)

Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Post comment

Tom B

May 17th, 2011 12:09pm Report this comment

Overseas aid is a racket. Quite apart from the immorality of taking money from taxpayers to pay to people with whom they may have no sympathy, it also distorts and deranges local markets, helps to prop up often venal and corrupt regimes. The late Peter Bauer, a fine economist, debunked the whole structure of government-to-government aid.

Time to scrap it and focus on the core responsibilities of government.