Indelible impression

By happy coincidence, all four of 2009’s major composers’ anniversaries link in a continuous chain, illustrating, directly or obliquely, two centuries of English musical life. Purcell, born 350 years ago in 1659 and dying at 36 in 1695, overlapped Handel (b.1685) by a decade; at Handel’s death 250 years ago (1759), Joseph Haydn (b.1732) was already a seasoned musician of 27; 1809, the year of his death 200 years ago aged 77, was also the birthyear of Mendelssohn, who, like Purcell, died all-too-young, at 38, in 1847.

All three great German masters are deeply involved in the fate of English music — Handel through near 50 years’ residence in the capital, Haydn by his two important visits (1791–2; 1794–5), productive of a considerable body of miscellaneous works as well as the celebrated ‘London’ symphonies; Mendelssohn’s conquest was just as complete, also more widespread, culminating in Elijah for Birmingham in 1846; and his idiom held sway here for most of the rest of the century, as Handel’s had the previous.

They encapsulate the old calumny that England is the ‘Land ohne Musik’. Not that there was no music! Just that it was principally foreign. Native compositional prowess in the long years between Purcell’s death and the emergence toward the end of the 19th century of Elgar (‘I knew we had it at last!’ exclaimed Bernard Shaw on first hearing the Enigma Variations in 1899) was simply overwhelmed, despite many a charming wayside bloom — Boyce and Arne, the juvenile genius of Thomas Linley, drowned aged 22 in 1778, the Wesleys father and son, Cipriani Potter (admired by Beethoven), Robert Pearsall with his enchanting partsongs, Sterndale Bennett (friend of Schumann and dedicatee of his études symphoniques); an incomplete list, whose comparative obscurity speaks for itself. (Plainly, Sullivan’s operettas are another thing.)

1 | 2 | 3 Next page

More articles from: Robin Holloway | this section

Print this article

ShareThis

Post comment

Paulo

February 27th, 2009 7:22pm Report this comment

Yes, well. Why not mention Delius? The only English composer I know of from that period. Elgar, of course was German - Oratorios, Symphonies, Concertos etc. Haendel was accepted because the King was German (did'nt speak English, even less than Haendel). Mendelssohn likewise- the consort Albert, don't you know. England is the home of music - its orchestras, its enthusiasm - but much of that is post-war refugee created. I think I exclude Dame Myra Hess.

JohnAnt

March 1st, 2009 12:24am Report this comment

The poet is James Thomson, not Thompson.

Martin Walker

March 13th, 2009 2:54pm Report this comment

I don't think Roberto Gerhard was a "third-rater", and prefer him to Hindemith by a very long chalk.
I think that Robin Holloway is writing off the top of his clever head here.

Post comment