Subscribe to The Spectator

Thursday 23 February 2012

Art

Theatre

Bookshelf

Screen

Turntable

SPOTIFY SUNDAY: Salvation Song

Archbishop Cranmer

This week's Spotify Sunday playlist has been selected by Archbishop Cranmer, whose blog on religion and politics is no doubt familiar to many readers of this website. We're grateful to him for contributing to the Spectator Arts Blog.

There is nothing which invigorates His Grace’s ashes more than the old battles of Church and State; the interminable clash of the sacred with the profane; the divine disapproval of all the deceits of the world, the flesh, and the devil. And so his mind and spirit (and blog) are perpetually preoccupied with that place where religion meets politics and politics becomes secular religion. Or, as Sir Humphrey might say, where the bishop’s religio-political agendas fuse with the politician’s politico-religious objectives.

This Playlist is unashamedly catholic and (chronologically) representative of His Grace’s favourite music on the theme of Salvation, both temporal and spiritual: pieces that give a taste of heaven and occasionally a glimpse of hell. They speak to his mind, excite his body and feed his soul. He hopes very much that they feeds yours, too.
 
Tallis: Spem In Alium
(Mark Brown, 1986, Pro Cantione Antiqua)

This 40-part motet from His Grace’s contemporary has never been surpassed in its magisterial angelic polyphony. The text is taken from a response in the Sarum Rite which so influenced Anglican Liturgy and His Grace’s Book of Common Prayer: Spem in alium nunquam habui praeter in te Deus Israel – ‘I have never put my hope in any other but in You, O God of Israel’. It is like a great choral Shema, beginning with one solitary voice, building gradually through the other voices as each choir in turn echoes the original cry to the Almighty, reaching a climactic crescendo as all 40 voices enter simultaneously, and then reverse the process. It is a magnificent liturgy of call and response: God is in the silences as well as the sound.

Bach: ‘Sanctus’ from Mass in B minor
(Karl Richter, 1961, The Munich Bach Orchestra & Choir)
 
O, the colossal glory of this great cry of ‘Holy, Holy, Holy!’ If you have never been fortunate to witness the angelic host singing their praises to God, this is a close as it gets. Some prissy people don’t like ‘big Bach’, but Richter was a master at evoking the Baroque drama of power and profundity. Here is no space for mediocrity: he conducts with forensic precision, such that you can hear the angels swirling around the heavens to the rapture of Bach’s ecstasy. The violins are splendid in their divine majesty; the trumpets are as crystal as springs of living water; and the timpani are thunderous in their praise. Please do not die before you have given ear to this sacred glimpse of paradise.

Handel: ‘I know that my Redeemer liveth’ from Messiah
(soloist Elly Ameling; Sir Neville Marriner, 1976, The Academy & Chorus of St Martin-in-the-Field)

If one were forced to choose one moment from Handel’s interpretation of God’s plan of salvation, you might expect the glorious ‘For Unto Us’ or the incomparable ‘Hallelujah Chorus’. But this sublime air for soprano is salvation in a whisper. The text derives from the Book of Job, which is where Scripture meets Shakespeare. Abandoned in trauma, alone with his suffering and bereavement, Job had the faith to believe and declare that God was still in control. He did not understand how or why, but he knew that his Redeemer lived. Life is replete with tragedy and sorrow, and this music offers hope; our only hope.

Mozart: Adagio from Serenade No10 in B Flat “Gran Partita” K.361
(Sir Neville Marriner, 1984, The Academy of St Martin-in-the-Field)

In the (fictional) words of Salieri: “On the page it looked nothing. The beginning simple, almost comic. Just a pulse – bassoons and basset horns – like a rusty squeezebox. Then suddenly – high above it – an oboe, a single note, hanging there unwavering, till a clarinet took over and sweetened it into a phrase of such delight! This was no composition by a performing monkey! This was a music I'd never heard. Filled with such longing, such unfulfillable longing, it had me trembling. It seemed to me that I was hearing the very voice of God.” It is indeed unbearably beautiful, and cannot but persuade one of the existence of God.

Beethoven: ‘Credo’ from Missa Solemnis in D major, Op. 123
(Sir Georg Solti, 1978, Chicago Symphony Orchestra & Choir)

From the tortured and tormented soul of nature’s greatest comes the superlative and almost unperformable sacred masterpiece of all. Cut off from the world by his deafness, Beethoven pushes the limits of human endurance to grapple with the meaning of earthly and divine existence. This Credo begins with Chalcedon the opera: we race through an allegro of hypostatic union, consubstantiation and homoousion; pause in adagio and andante for the Incarnation; move to a sublime adagio espressivo for the crucifixion; and just when the world ends, in a silence that seems to last an eternity, we have an earth-shattering allegro declaring ‘Et resurrexit tertia die secundum Scripturas’ with a voice that could break the cedars of Lebanon: the angelic host joins with the heavenly spheres and even the stones cry out ‘He is Risen!’ Hallelujah! The Ascension is a dizzying allegro molto, through the Last Trumpet and the Day of Judgment. And then we return to an allegro ma non troppo for a bit more theology: the filioque clause and the life of the world to come, set to some of the most exalted themes. Beethoven may have been deaf to earthly sounds, but in this magnum opus he heard the Voice of God.

Fauré: ‘In Paradisum’ from Requiem
(Sir David Willcocks, King’s College Cambridge)

If this is playing in heaven when His Grace approaches St Peter, all will be well forever and ever. Fauré said: "It has been said that my Requiem does not express the fear of death, and somebody called it a lullaby of death. But that is how I see death - as a happy deliverance, an aspiration to happiness above rather than as a painful experience." In its serenity is the peace that passes understanding. Here we find the very heart of God the Comforter, the Wonderful Counsellor, the Prince of Peace: ‘May angels lead you into Paradise ... may you have eternal rest.’

Mahler: ‘Aufersteh’n’ (‘Rise Again’) from Symphony No2 “Resurrection”
(Leonard Bernstein, 1988, New York Philharmonic & Westminster Choir)

This epic symphony is more than music: it is primordial cosmology fused with ethereal nebulae condensed into a myriad of infinitely-dense extragalactic black dots woven into the fabric of five endless horizontal lines separated by four infinite spaces. The Resurrection emerges out of the Primeval light, yet it is lighter than light. The orchestra is more glorious than the morning sun and the choir’s whispered entrance more wonderful the dews of peace. It cannot be contained by sounding brass and tinkling cymbal: it has an epic climax that seems to go on for an eternity of overwhelming grandeur. If one were to condense all the emotions of life into a nutshell, and then ask the Seraphim to carry it to the Throne of Grace, you would reach the ecstasy of salvation. It is an Event.
 
Genesis: Supper’s Ready
(from the album ‘Seconds Out’, Live, Paris 1976)
 
A leap, but this is not just ‘rock’ music: it is the Last Days, the End of Time, from the Lord’s Supper to the Parousia. It is pure musical impressionism. From a couple watching television to a man carrying a cross, this mini-oratorio seems to run from Genesis and surges to Revelation; from acoustic to electric, from major to minor; from serenity to apocalypse. It is a reminder that even the eternally damned in the fires of hell cannot escape the presence of God. The struggle is between good and evil, the tension lies between damnation and salvation, and ‘666 is no longer alone, // He’s getting out the marrow in your back bone’. The trauma is intense, but we move with melodic glory through lyrical complexity from Seven Trumpets to the Second Coming and then on to the New Jerusalem. Inspired genius, appropriately written and composed by Gabriel.

Jon & Vangelis: ‘Horizon’ from Private Collection

With a voice of audible silk, Jon Anderson sings of the rings of confusion, to sacrifice, to enlighten like a Shakespearean play. Our earthly flesh is folly: our pushing, pulling, twisting and turning are devoid of reason. But there is a guiding light which transcends everything: a jewel of life that heralds a new dawn. Divine Nature brings peace, and that peace will surely come (we are told 17 times). An unbearable suspended chord of tension builds to an orgasm of the everlasting dream:

I just can't help but believe in life,
All in all I just can't help but believe there is a way
For us to give, A way for us to live
A way for us, A way for us.

If salvation is about light, love, reason and grace, they meet in the secret heart of this sweet music.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Morricone: ‘On Earth as it is in Heaven’ from The Mission
(London Philharmonic Orchestra, 1986)
 
In The Mission, a film with priest-and-king themes as old as recorded history, Morricone goes to the Holy Mountain. He begins with sacred choral harmonies, segues into the hypnotic rhythm of the Guarani drums, and then infuses Gabriel’s oboe which soars above the hypnotic basso profundo like a Mozartian strain. The three elements compete for supremacy in a perfect fusion of mesmeric earthy rhythm and spiritual harmony. It is one of the most sublime moments in the history of cinematic scores, and perhaps the greatest Academy Award travesty of all time that they failed to award it an Oscar. But that would be an earthly desire: Morricone’s martyrdom is his timeless mission between the valley of conviction and the mountain of conversion – to make the music which saves us from ourselves.

You can listen to the rest of the playlist HERE

ShareThis
Post comment

Comments

January 9th, 2011 7:02pm

TBF

Inspirational. Just what I needed to contemplate on a Sunday evening. Thank you.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 8:16pm

Edward McLaughlin

What a wonderful selection, Your Grace. My little piggy eyes lit up when I saw your beneficent visage there on the front page.

Things is lookin up.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 10:14pm

Jack

A sublime selection Your Grace, I would have included William Byrd's "Mass for 5 voices" and left out the Jon and Vangelis, but your brush is broad: who would have though you so cosmopolitan? Well chosen indeed.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 10:54pm

BenG

This is one of the best Spotify lists ever - and it's not only the catholic(!) selection, it's the prose. His Grace still writes like he did 500 years ago. When the words are as inspirational as the music, there is Art. More please.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 11:08pm

egh

Gosh, Your Grace. I might even start reading the Spectator again if they're raising their standards to include you!
Fascinating collection; brilliant commentary.
[Thanks to Mr. Hoskin, too]

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 11:09pm

Archbishop Cranmer

Mr Jack,

His Grace was indeed traumatised to have to leave out so much (including Byrd), yet somehow he had to span the inspiration of centuries in 10 glimpses of moments. He cannot tell you how awkward was the transition from Mahler to Genesis, and yet he hears the Voice of God in both. Byrd would have been worthy, as would many others. But Vangelis does grapple with profound spiritual themes.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 11:26pm

Zach Johnstone

A delightful selection of music, in particular Beethoven's ‘Credo’ from Missa Solemnis. It's one of many pieces that I listen to repeatedly whenever I have an essay to write (there's something about Beethoven that seems to increase my productivity exponentially...).

This selection has certainly made my Sunday evening.

Report this comment

January 9th, 2011 11:39pm

wrinkled weasel

A wonderful choice of music Your Grace. Sorry to see no Jay-Z in there though.

I'll get me chasuble

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 4:01am

Patrick

You lucky guys. Spotify doesn't work in Kenya so I have to just imagine the sounds

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 8:41am

Tony Falconer

"This epic symphony is more than music: it is primordial cosmology fused with ethereal nebulae condensed into a myriad of infinitely-dense extragalactic black dots woven into the fabric of five endless horizontal lines separated by four infinite spaces."

Superb. His Grace can make the deaf hear, but this is a bit demeaning for him. His insights belong on Coffee House.

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 9:15am

Scott Jordan Harris

What a wonderful selection, and what an extraordinary article. Welcome the The Spectator Arts Blog, Your Grace. We are very glad to have you here.

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 9:54am

Yam Yam

And from the other end of the worship spectrum: Anna Bartlett Warner's simple, but moving children's hymn "Jesus loves me, this I know"...

"Jesus loves me! He will stay,
Close beside me all the way;
Thou hast bled and died for me,
I will henceforth live for Thee."

These words of salvation and trust hold true whether one is eight years-old or eighty.

"Yes, Jesus loves me, the Bible tells me so."

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 12:35pm

Anabaptist

Most of Crannie's list meets with my approval, and denotes a rare and fine musical taste. I really don't know anything about 'Genesis' or Vangelis, but the rest makes a credible selection.
Not sure about some of the recordings, though. The Mahler performance of choice has to be the Auger/Baker/CBSO/CBSO Chorus/Rattle recording, which rightly eraned a Penguin rosette. I was fortunate enough to take part in that recording. Like Crannie, I too enjoy 'big Bach' so long as it is agile and not dense. Whilst slightly anachronistic, Haydn was inspired to write The Creation partly by his hearing of a performance of Handel's Messiah sung by a choir of over 300 singers in London, so there's nothing Victorian about the practice.

The Mozart performance in the film clip is too slow. The pulse should be alike a heart beat. There is a wonderful rendition of this partita by a male choir in Jane Campion's marvellous film, 'Bright Star'.

The Beethoven Missa Solemnis has a claim to being the greatest piece of choral music ever written.

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 7:04pm

BenG

On the versions chosen, I agree the Mozart is a bit slow, and the Bernstein version very slow indeed. There's no pace in it which you'd expect a resurrection to have! I think the Solti is about right, and the Richter really is a question of taste. He doesn't do it for me - Bach should (IMHO) be smaller. I know it's a mass but you'd never get this lot into your average church. It really is a great list though (now I've listened to it all) and I'm pleased to have been introduced to Jon & Vangelis. Could His Grace do another theme? More 'earthly' perhaps?

Report this comment

January 10th, 2011 10:37pm

TBF

The Bernstein is actually much nearer to what Mahler intented - there's a slow intensity which magnifies the sense of resurrection. I think the Mozart is slower because of YouTube - my Amadeus CD is slightly faster. For a Spectator debut I think His Grace has truly inspired. As other have said, this quality is what we want more of from this blog - please!

Report this comment

January 11th, 2011 8:12am

simon

Your Grace, thanks for doing the playlist for the blog. I'm trying to increase my knowledge and appreciation of classical music and this post has been a big help, as has James Rhodes magnificent piano music.

Music is a very broad church and I hope that you and other Speecie Arts blog readers will come back to sample other more contemporary Spotify Sunday's..The wonder of being alive and what it is to be human can be found just as much in a huge Rock anthem or a massive House tune as it can in a Mozart Symphony, we should celebrate and enjoy them all.

Report this comment

January 11th, 2011 11:09am

Archbishop Cranmer

Mr Simon (Mason),

You say:

"The wonder of being alive and what it is to be human can be found just as much in a huge Rock anthem or a massive House tune as it can in a Mozart Symphony, we should celebrate and enjoy them all."

Surely His Grace has demonstrated knowledge of this? He has not confined himself to the 'Mozart symphony': he included a superlative piece by Genesis. His Grace attempted to walk through five centuries and is rather eclectic in his tastes, yet you appear to confine and caricature him.

Mr BenG,

His Grace can only do upon this blog what he is invited to do. Having been dead for five centuries and having no corporeal presence, the 'earthly' may present challenges.

Report this comment

January 11th, 2011 12:03pm

simon

Your Grace, you misunderstands me (my fault i'm sure) I was making no attempt to confine and caricture you. My point was rather, that I hope now that you have Spotify that you keep coming back every Sunday to broaden your musical horizons with more contemporary fare.. Just as I'm attempting to do with Classical music and Opera, most of which is new to me. Great fun it is too. And that Genesis track wals killer, if a bit Prog for my usual tastes.

Report this comment

Post comment

Back to top

More Articles

Cartoons

Spectator Asks

Britain's overseas aid budget is rising by 36% to £12.6 billion over this parliament. Is this a good use of taxpayers' money?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Don't Know

sponsored links

Spectator recommends

Spectator classifieds

THE PRESENT FINDER

1,700 Unusual Christmas Presents Request Catalogue 01935 815 195 Quote SPEC10 for 10% discount www.presentfinder.co.uk

OLIVE BRANCH FLORISTS

Pimilco based Florist with online ordering Web: www.olivebranch.net Tel: 020 7630 1868 Fax: 020 7233 8844

RUFFS Bespoke Signet rings

62 Shore Road, Warsash, Southampton, SO31 9FT Telephone: 01489 578867 Web site: www.ruffs.co.uk