‘The 20th century was not kind to Pakistan’, Tariq Ali says in the first sentence of his latest book on his native land. The glib opener is a taste of what’s to come. It is both annoying and accurate. The 20th century created Pakistan, after all, and — apart from eight most difficult years since the turn of the millennium — the country has known no other. But Pakistan’s first 50 years certainly were troubled and the knowledge that the emergent nation was badly treated (over the division of assets with its neighbour in 1947 and India’s grabbing of Kashmir) and has been unlucky (with the death of Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the country’s founder in September 1948 and the assassination of Liaquat Ali Khan in 1951) is deep in the nation’s psyche.
The Duel that Tariq Ali talks about is ‘between a US backed politico-military elite and the citizens of the country’. Pakistan’s crucial conflict, he says, is not the struggle against militant extremism that preoccupies Western observers. In his view the real divide is ‘between the majority of the people and their corrupt, uncaring rulers’. Complicity between the country’s elites — civilian and military — and Washington has consistently distanced them from the masses.
Ali believes that Pakistan’s current difficulties are ‘a direct result of doing Washington’s bidding in past decades’ and walks us through the country’s short history to demonstrate how America has backed the military and the feudal political families .
It is a chronicle of unremitting venality, incompetence and opportunism. In this, Ali is even-handed. He despises everybody and no one emerges heroically from his telling; the revered Mr Jinnah, the Quaid-i-Azam himself, is derided.



Comments
ritalove
April 10th, 2009 11:43amMy new friend ,
i am well pleased to contact you after going through your
profile on my search for genuine relationship at(www.spectator.co.uk) i will
like to be your good friend, please contact me with this
idd (ritakhal54@yahoo.co.uk) i am waiting for your reply soon,
rita
Report this comment
S.M. Stirling
January 15th, 2009 4:31amAs my mother once told me, if you make excuses for failure, all you'll ever get is failure, and excuses.
Pakistan has been wrecking itself for 60 years by trying to engage in a strategic competition with a power than outweighs it by at least 8 to 1 -- and that's India, not the US.
The solution? Give up. Admit that India (and hence, Hindus) will dominate the subcontinent. Stop trying to rival, or inconvenience, or undermine India; give up all dreams of acquiring Kashmir; walk small; cultivate one's own garden.
India is modernizing more successfully than Pakistan. And for -that- defeat, Pakistan has only itself to blame.
Report this comment