Even doctors of the Catholic church do not escape Tariq Ali’s contumely. The great St Teresa is (bizarrely) brought in to the brew, in passing, in the context of what the author describes as the ‘hallucinatory impact’ of faith. The author appears to be dogmatically anti-religion, prepared to be sympathetic to belief only when it whittles away at a greater faith (so the arguably heretical Ahmediyyas get a much better hearing than mainstream Islam).
Tariq Ali’s universal cynicism might have been oppressive, but in fact his narrative is funny and gossipy, the high points being his own encounters with key players, including Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Benazir and Indira Gandhi. He believes that the country’s satirists, writers and poets serve as Pakistan’s collective conscience and uses writers and poets such as Faiz Ahmed Faiz, Sahir Ludhianvi, Habib Jalib and Ustad Daman to provide the moral compass for his wanderings.
Political turbulence has revived interest in stories from an earlier period of Muslim in the region, Ali says. He relates a 16th-century story that — with some modifications — sums up life in today’s Pakistan with painful accuracy. A man is seriously dissatisfied with a junior magistrate’s decision. The latter, irritated, taunts him to appeal to a senior judge.The man replies, ‘But he’s your brother, he won’t listen to me’. The magistrate says, ‘Go to the mufti’. The man replies, ‘But he’s your uncle’. The magistrate says, ‘Go to the minister’. The man replies, ‘He’s your grandfather’. The magistrate says, ‘Go to the King’. The man replies, ‘Your niece is engaged to him’. The magistrate, livid with anger, says, ‘Go to Hell then’. The man replies, ‘That’s where your esteemed father reigns. He’ll see to it that I get no satisfaction there.’
The government, the political parties, the civil service, the mullahs and the army all have reason to be angry with Tariq Ali and The Duel will outrage as many in Washington as in Islamabad. But Americans should read it for its explanation of why so many in Pakistan hate the US, blaming it for the dire situation in which they now find themselves.
In fact this sprightly romp should be read by anyone who wants real insights into Pakistan. It is as good a primer on Pakistani politics as you will find, with the caveats that it is not the whole story, it is not always accurate and Ali’s prejudices are his own.





Comments
ritalove
April 10th, 2009 11:43amMy new friend ,
i am well pleased to contact you after going through your
profile on my search for genuine relationship at(www.spectator.co.uk) i will
like to be your good friend, please contact me with this
idd (ritakhal54@yahoo.co.uk) i am waiting for your reply soon,
rita
Report this comment
S.M. Stirling
January 15th, 2009 4:31amAs my mother once told me, if you make excuses for failure, all you'll ever get is failure, and excuses.
Pakistan has been wrecking itself for 60 years by trying to engage in a strategic competition with a power than outweighs it by at least 8 to 1 -- and that's India, not the US.
The solution? Give up. Admit that India (and hence, Hindus) will dominate the subcontinent. Stop trying to rival, or inconvenience, or undermine India; give up all dreams of acquiring Kashmir; walk small; cultivate one's own garden.
India is modernizing more successfully than Pakistan. And for -that- defeat, Pakistan has only itself to blame.
Report this comment