Subscribe to The Spectator

Friday 10 February 2012

Latest issue

Buy the current issue

Jobs at Telegraph

Thursday, 14th January 2010

Labour put "guarantees" at the heart of their campaign

Peter Hoskin 10:50am

Does Gordon Brown look like the kind of guy who can keep a promise?  Because that's the main question which stands in the way of Labour's election strategy, if Andrew Grice's revelations in the Indpendent are anything to go by.  According to Grice, Labour are going to repeat their trick from 1997, and focus on five or so pledges – what Downing St now calls "guarantees" – during their election campaign.  It's not certain what they'll be yet, but Grice reports that Labour MPs are being instructed to concentrate on the following policies in their constituencies:

-- Training or further education will be provided for all school-leavers and a job or training for jobless young adults.

-- Suspected cancer patients will receive their diagnosis within one week.

-- The elderly and most vulnerable will receive free personal care.

-- Families responsible for antisocial behaviour will face tough action.

-- The national deficit will be halved in four years through tax rises, spending cuts and growth.

As was pointed out at the time Brown first started making these guarantees, they're a lot more problematic than they first sound.  For instance, just who's going to enforce them?  And what happens if they're not met?  Couldn't they inspire a bureaucratic nightmare when people start claiming for things the government says they're entitled to, but which they haven't delivered?  There's plenty of room for the Tories to point out how messy Brown's little promises could get.

Of course, this wouldn't be Brown's premiership without a negative aspect to the campaign.  Grice reports that those pledges will sit alongside a set of "accusations" against the Tories:

"They will also attempt to contrast the pledges by levelling five accusations at David Cameron – that the Tories would cut schools funding, scrap the cancer promise, preside over a social care 'lottery', reduce police numbers and axe Sure Start schemes."
Most of which, particularly the first, suggest that Brown is still eager to drag the national debate about our fiscal crisis – a debate we desperately need – to the level of good investment versus nasty cuts.  And that in spite of the deficit reduction guarantee above.  Yep, it's going to be a very long election campaign, indeed.

Filed under: Conservatives (2077 more articles) , Election 2010 (599 more articles) , Gordon Brown (906 more articles) , Guarantees (1 more articles) , Labour (2015 more articles) , UK politics (4911 more articles)

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Alex Massie | Melanie Phillips | Faith Based | Cappuccino Culture

Actions: Email to a friend  |   Permalink   |   Comments (37) | Subscribe

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments Post comment

Number7

January 14th, 2010 11:32am Report this comment

Does anybody his manifesto promise of a referendum on the EU Constitution?

All he and his troops can do is lie through their teeth.

Billy Blofeld

January 14th, 2010 11:50am Report this comment

I Gordon Brown guarantee that I will end boom and bust.

AGM

January 14th, 2010 12:01pm Report this comment

I would NOT believe Brown if he told me today was Thursday - his track record is so bad. Even his comments about Dave having been airbrushed on the posters turns out to be FALSE. Can he say nothing that is truthful!

Hawkeye

January 14th, 2010 12:06pm Report this comment

Can we have a speech bubble on that picture of Gordon? "This bit here's mine.....all mine"

strapworld

January 14th, 2010 12:11pm Report this comment

Like his recent guarantee that we would not run out of road salt!

That we would be the first country out of recession.

That he ended boom and bust.

That we would have a referendum on the EU Constitution.

That he would provide whatever the troops wanted (When he knew he had stopped them getting the helicopters they urgently required!)

That he would ensure Army training would not be cut..IT HAS!

Britain is safe under Labour IT CERTAINLY IS NOT!

I am sure you could think of more guarantee's this incompetent liar has proved to be a renegade

Grumpy Optimist

January 14th, 2010 12:15pm Report this comment

The only way to counter this is by redicule and metaphor. Gordon just can't stop making promises you know he can't keep. He's incontinent. He is like the wife beater who promises to stop - for the umpteenth time. You know he won't. Or the alcoholic who promises to stop - but pleads for one more night out on the town. Or the dieter who promises to lose weight and then goes straight back to the fridge. Or maybe you say that we would only trust Labour if they had an operation first to tie up their gut. But we fear that the operation might kill them.

Billy Blofeld

January 14th, 2010 12:23pm Report this comment

P.S. Nice picture of Gordon in Weather-Girl mode.

se1man

January 14th, 2010 12:26pm Report this comment

Is he doing a weather forecast?

Nicholas

January 14th, 2010 12:26pm Report this comment

Number one rings a bell. Haven't we seen that one before - oh, about 13 years ago?

wrinkled weasel

January 14th, 2010 12:34pm Report this comment

So, OK, nobody on here believes it. But HIGNFY! People who vote Labour, and who always have and who always will because their dad did, will. Not only that, the 4 million public sector workers, who have had their jobs created under Labour will. As will the people on benefits who have nothing to lose but their cushy little ride. Or the thousands of failed asylum seekers - at least 20,000 Somalis come under this tag alone, in BRISTOL!

There used to be a thing called Gerrymandering. It seems to have had a renaissance under New Labour.

You don't need to convince the growing number of elderly people who have seen their savings and pensions disappear - they may be fooled by the nice man at the door who just wants to check their biscuit tin, but they are not stupid enough to believe Gordon Brown.

They can say what they like. It is not about promises, because we know they are broken; Lying is the default for Labour. What is really going on is the kind of nasty, dirty trickery they are currently resorting to:

http://order-order.com/2010/01/14/exclusive-labour-faked-cameron-airbrushing/

What puzzles me is why they did not try to make him look more Jewish, while they were at it.

Alan Douglas

January 14th, 2010 12:35pm Report this comment

I'd settle for a Gordon Brown guarantee to actually ANSWER ANY opposition Q at PMQs. But I'm not holding my breath.

Alan Douglas

Michael Booth

January 14th, 2010 12:38pm Report this comment

ha ha ha ha
guarantees from Gordon Brown? Ha ha ha

Time we gave him a guarantee - a sound thrashing at the ballot box and a seat in the dock for crimes against the British people...

charles hercock

January 14th, 2010 12:42pm Report this comment

Guarantee 2 not affordable if guarantee 5 is met.Get real Gordon.Your credibility gap is widening

NickW

January 14th, 2010 12:50pm Report this comment

Someone has Blair's pledgecard from 1997.

Fail on all of them.

Just remind everybody how well labour keeps its word.

oldtimer

January 14th, 2010 12:55pm Report this comment

"Guarantee" is an anagram for "urea agent". Urea has a nasty smell to it, unsurprisingly as it is a compound found in the urine of mammals. Sounds very appropriate for a Labour party manifesto.

NickW

January 14th, 2010 12:57pm Report this comment

Here is a Tony Blair election pledge, aka.guarantee.

We will set tough rules for government spending and borrowing and ensure low inflation and strengthen the economy so that interest rates are as low as possible to make all families better off.

I am sure that Brown's promises are equally worthless.

Yam Yam

January 14th, 2010 1:03pm Report this comment

A man whose government is in debt to the tune of £759 billion is not in a position to guarantee anything.

welshy

January 14th, 2010 1:07pm Report this comment

This strikes me as a tactical mistake - brown and his party do not have the trust / likeable factor to pull this off.

Besides that, it is an opposition tactic - because people cannot ask the opposition:

what pledges to get in power last time have you broken? e.g. eu vote is a clear issue any numpty can understand

why have you not already done it in a decade in power?

The longer labour goes on like this, the better for the tories - more iraq inquiry, more infighting, more time for double dip recession, another budget, more time for gilts market to force cuts debate, more of unwanted brown (does every paper now hate him!?). You do have to wonder why labour mps in marginal seats are not trying to do something about this!? Are they really this much like lemmings walking off a cliff?

Tankus

January 14th, 2010 1:08pm Report this comment

just noise for a headline

Alexander Pelling

January 14th, 2010 1:11pm Report this comment

Brown's 'guarantees' are sure to go the same way as his 'golden rule': when the going gets tough he will either redefine them or ignore them altogether. This country doesn't need grandiose, unenforceable 'guarantees': it needs quiet, competent government.

Dennis Churchill

January 14th, 2010 1:13pm Report this comment

Surely not even our political class are so removed from reality they would leave the opposition with such an open goal? No one believes anything any British politiciansays.Referendum guarantees, Weapons of Mass Destruction, Tough on crime, control immigration...

logdon

January 14th, 2010 1:16pm Report this comment

Caption

Let's not talk about this bit. All I'm interested in, even though I was never elected in that country is that huge swathe of lab rat tax donators in England.

In2minds

January 14th, 2010 1:17pm Report this comment

Labour "guarantees" - I'll swap the lot for a vote on membership of the EU, would they guarantee that? They lied on Lisbon.

Chuck Unsworth

January 14th, 2010 1:37pm Report this comment

Simple enough:

Do you trust this man?

JONNY

January 14th, 2010 1:39pm Report this comment

Seems we're going to need an oyster knife with exceptional cutting edge
to prise this belly-footed Gasterapoda off the rock face.
However be warned. It is stupefying with what obdurate obstinacy the Limpet will cling and adhere.

Robert Williams

January 14th, 2010 1:59pm Report this comment

Brown rattled off a similar list of guarantees at yesterday's PMQs, a pity that Cameron didn't reply along the lines of comments above.

Rhys

January 14th, 2010 2:00pm Report this comment

Brown: "I guarantee....you'd wished you emigrated 3 years ago."

AAE

January 14th, 2010 2:01pm Report this comment

It's time to stop all this manifesto nonsense. With our lives being crippled by taxation and so many freedoms lost by government intervention never forementioned in any manifesto, we should have a proper contract with the government. They would then be bound by contract law and these pledges of wishful thinking and political posturing would stop. It's outrageous that a 700 billion pound economy should be run by total amateurs, and that one half of society which takes all the risks and absorbs all the blows should pay to keep the other half cushioned with benefits to which the first half are not themselves entitled.

toco

January 14th, 2010 2:30pm Report this comment

I wouldn't trust the hapless Brown to sit the right way on the proverbial and having seen him work closely with the disgraced Damian McBride,Charlie Whelan,Derek Draper and Alistair Campbell why should the British electorate.

Marcher Baron

January 14th, 2010 3:22pm Report this comment

Fine words butter no parsnips. His track record is abysmal and that's what we'll judge him on (except for Labour tribalists, of course, who think all the current problems are down to Mrs Thatcher).

Alan Douglas

January 14th, 2010 4:12pm Report this comment

"Would YOU buy a used promise from this Man ?" next to a pic of GB, or even one of Nixon - would anyone know the difference ?

Alan Douglas

Derek

January 14th, 2010 4:19pm Report this comment

Caption.

"...and this is where we will regroup after the election."

Beer Moth

January 14th, 2010 4:52pm Report this comment

Never mind what he looks like, let's just compare what he says with what he does.

As in, for instance, 'British jobs for British people'.

Naomi Muse

January 14th, 2010 5:39pm Report this comment

see1man said: Is he doing a weather forecast?

Nah. He's just covering up Scotland.

Broon is not honest and not able to guarantee anything except that he will be delusional and dishonest.

He has let us all down, big time and has poisoned the civil service too with his pursuit of non-goals such as targets, when the real goals are to provide what we all need and enable business to thrive.

On those he has failed miserably but won't say, 'sorry' except for someone else's misdemeanours.

A man to be derided, in truth.

Michael Booth

January 14th, 2010 6:07pm Report this comment

as was established the other week, no manifesto promise is legally binding

so what's the point?

Frank Leader

January 16th, 2010 9:12am Report this comment

Arthur Daley's Guarantee would Cast Iron compared to any from G Brown.

richardj

January 18th, 2010 4:54pm Report this comment

I suspect that Gordon will became as popular a name as Adolf.

Post comment

Back to top

Cartoons

Tag Cloud

Coffee House archive

sponsored links

Spectator recommends

Spectator classifieds

THE PRESENT FINDER

1,700 Unusual Christmas Presents Request Catalogue 01935 815 195 Quote SPEC10 for 10% discount www.presentfinder.co.uk

OLIVE BRANCH FLORISTS

Pimilco based Florist with online ordering Web: www.olivebranch.net Tel: 020 7630 1868 Fax: 020 7233 8844

RUFFS Bespoke Signet rings

62 Shore Road, Warsash, Southampton, SO31 9FT Telephone: 01489 578867 Web site: www.ruffs.co.uk