WEB EXCLUSIVE: Time to leave?
Lloyd Evans 10:56am
The Spectator’s summer debating season ended with a strident appeal. ‘Too
late to save Britain. It’s time to leave’. Proposing the motion, Rod Liddle claimed to have mis-read his invitation. ‘I thought this was a foregone conclusion and we’d come
here to arrange the tickets.’ Surging immigration, he said, was ruining the education system and our love lives. ‘By 2029 no one will be having sex, we’ll be so crowded
out.’ The recent election had proved nothing but democracy’s impotence. ‘The poverty gap keeps widening, financiers still get bonuses and schools support Lesbian Gay and
Trans-gender History Month.’ Soon he predicted that the definition of disability ‘will cover everyone except Ray Mears.’ He finished with a cheery valediction. ‘Get the hell
out!’
Bonnie Greer, opposing the motion, seems to have turned into Britain’s Nelson Mandela. She only has to show up and everyone applauds. Enthusing about our eccentricity she quoted JG Ballard.
‘When you go to England you realise Alice in Wonderland is a documentary.’ She hailed our habit of laughing at authority and she claimed to admire our press: ‘still free and still
rude’. A proud British subject, she’s so loyal that she uses her UK passport ‘much more often than my American passport.’
Catherine Ayer, the London bureau chief for Time, felt miserable about this country and about everywhere else. Her high hopes of British society had been dashed. Our tolerance, humour, resilience
and openness had gone, she said, and we’d become a ‘sclerotic society’ which ‘wears its history heavily’. Defeat-management is our best course. ‘If Britain
recognizes its limitations it may be able to use its resources more wisely.’ She was sorry that Obama’s optimism hadn’t crossed the Atlantic and she rated the Coalition’s
prospects at a big fat zero. On a cheerier note she felt her pessimism suited our culture perfectly. ‘No one does grey and miserable as convincingly as the Brits.’
Tristram Hunt had trouble concealing his delight at having been elected as MP for Stoke. He invited us to join him on an inter-city jaunt from the midlands to Glasgow as he mused on the
‘welcome signifiers’ of British history. His starting point, Stoke, was the cradle of the industrial revolution. In Manchester he witnessed the birthplace of scientific socialism,
feminism and vegetarianism. On the Clyde he saw how the wealth of empire had enriched the magnificent west end of Glasgow. The glory of our country today, he said paradoxically, is that ‘we
have no purpose in life.’ We are free from evangelism. We don’t need to spread democracy, pursue happiness or amplify the virtues of liberty, equality and fraternity. We can do those
things if we like, but there’s no obligation. ‘This is liberating.’
David Selbourne, a man of the left evidently appalled by the left, offered an alarming vision of Britain as a nation in moral decline. Social cohesion had once been rooted in the work ethic and
respect for public service but these values had been eroded by ‘a surfeit of rights’. John Prescott’s conversion to the virtues of aristocracy sickened him. ‘The phrase
“my Lord Prescott,” makes my stomach sink and my gorge rise.’ Of the Big Society he said, ‘No idea so vacuous has appeared in the history of political thought.’
He quoted Burke’s assertion that ‘liberty cannot exist without order and virtue.’ Daniel Hannan, closing for the opposition, agreed with Selbourne and refined the definition of
liberty as ‘the application of moral judgement.’ He turned Rod Liddle’s point about rising immigration into an endorsement of Britain’s attractiveness. ‘The in-queue
is bigger than the out-queue.’ The crowd endorsed this. The motion was defeated.
Votes:
Before the debate For 74 Against 141 Undecided 74
Dfter the debate For 88 Against 198 Undecided 1



Previous







libertarian
June 25th, 2010 11:37am Report this commentI went to a business conference in London last week. The audience was 400 hi tech entrepreneurs of start up companies. The panel of experts were 6 British entreprenuers/business angles.
They were asked what one piece of advice would they give to anyone trying to start a buiness, raise finance or succeed.
They all gave the same answer
Move to California.
I agree, Britian is no longer a place worth even trying to do business we are a quasi socialist/Keynesian quangrocracy.
The new coalition government intends to keep that the same
michael
June 25th, 2010 11:41am Report this commentwhat is done can be undone.... politicians need to re-engage people not pay them off.
Nicholas
June 25th, 2010 12:04pm Report this commentBonnie Greer irritates me. A johnny-come-lately American who presumes to speak on behalf of the British and wears her colour in the same manner Diane Abbott does, as the defining aspect of her personality and beliefs.
She typifies modern Britain, full of foreigners who muscle into the public narrative, enjoy the benefits and then slag off the indigenes.
alec spurner
June 25th, 2010 12:09pm Report this commentAre these debates available to download or watch online?
Edward
June 25th, 2010 12:18pm Report this commentTime will tell. I'm in the fortunate position of being able to move to the States if I want to. Give the new Government a couple of years, then we'll see.
If I did move to the States, I doubt it would be California - it's probably one of the least free states in the Union. Texas seems pretty good - there's no state income tax there, for example.
In2minds
June 25th, 2010 12:18pm Report this commentTime to leave? Time to leave the EU that's for sure.
yank
June 25th, 2010 12:30pm Report this commentlibertarian,
Your entrepreneurs and experts are not worth their salt, then. Business is fleeing California in droves. They are in deep, deep trouble. Their state legislature is controlled by a gang of union labor fanatics that would put Gordon Brown in awe, who have put them into a $50B yearly budget deficit, and a structural deficit that would likely match much of the UK's. The state is depopulating, business is leaving, even the Silicon Valley has massive commercial vacancies.
The gravy train in California has run out of coal.
fifer
June 25th, 2010 12:35pm Report this commentSo you've found 6 British entrepeneurs with particularly bad timing and / or understanding of California. The place is basically bankrupt so you'll be moving to somewhere where they'll be looking at massive police and other public sector cutbacks, school closures and there was never a health service anyway.
I'd modify the advice. If you've made it as an entrepeneur and have the money to live in a gated community (or up in wine country), have massive medical insurance and send your kids to private school then, yeah, knock yourself out. But things are going to get a lot worse before they get better.
Gary Williams
June 25th, 2010 12:46pm Report this commentIt was "Catherine Mayer".
One listened in vain for any evidence of why the petulant Tristram Hunt had been invited to speak. The idea that this kid is a Member of Parliament is in equal measures risible and frightening.
He began his litany of one-liner cheap-shots with "this wretched Government", kindly sharing with us his sagacious reflections on a Government that has been in power for only 40 days. Anyone who thinks that a Government (in a democracy) can be judged after its first 40 days is unfit even to pretend that he is an "historian". Hunt proved this point in other ways as the evening wore on.
Augustus
June 25th, 2010 12:56pm Report this commentBrazil might be an idea. Fine beaches!
Tim Carpenter LPUK
June 25th, 2010 1:04pm Report this commentI know this may appear totally lateral, but some of our problems are staring us in the face and can be seen in the image you attach to the article.
Take a look at it. An early Victorian or late Georgian, I believe, 3 storey (or could be four, with mansard) with semi basement brick built house of a style most people hanker after.
Why is such a property run down and surrounded with entropic youth? Planning blight, proximity to ghastly facilities that nobody is free to bulldoze, lack of Rule of Law that would otherwise allow rich and poor to mingle more freely, State-subsidised housing distorting the market?
This asset is going to waste. That is where our wealth leaks away.
Edward
June 25th, 2010 1:48pm Report this comment"The glory of our country today, he said paradoxically, is that ‘we have no purpose in life.’"
A person who has no purpose in life will eventually see no purpose in living.
Britain, collectively, appears to be coming to the same conclusion.
Marcher Baron
June 25th, 2010 3:52pm Report this comment"A proud British subject, [Bonnie Greer]’s so loyal that she uses her UK passport ‘much more often than my American passport.’" Some definition of loyalty - sounds more like a flag of convenience to me.
Craig Strachan
June 25th, 2010 4:06pm Report this commentI'm from Britain and live in California.
I don't recognise Britain as characterised by the Catherine Ayer side of the debate, or California as characterised in some of the comments here.
I was pleasantly surprised to read in last week's Economist that California's deficit, measured by next's year's projected shortfall as a % of this year's state budget, is in fact one of the lowest amongst US states. The absolute numbers are big, but so is California.
And - according to today's Telegraph -Britain has become a nation of savers for the first time in 20 years.
I have no doubt that both Britain and California will be back, better 'n ever, after a necessary (welcome?) period of austerity.
Kennybhoy
June 25th, 2010 5:11pm Report this commentIf I dinnae end up composting in some foreign field first, I will be the last one oot! One of my favourite among many Ray Bradbury short stories is, "Henry the Ninth"!
oldtimer
June 25th, 2010 7:46pm Report this commentRod Liddle is right.
oldtimer
June 25th, 2010 7:46pm Report this commentRod Liddle is right.
Gary Williams
June 25th, 2010 9:11pm Report this commentMarcher Baron:
It may interest you to know that a dual US-UK citizen is required to use his US passport upon entering or leaving the US, regardless of his sentiments about the UK. If Bonnie Greer sometimes visits her country of origin, no inferences whatsoever should be drawn from her sometime use of a US passport.
Nicholas:
You are suggesting that those who woke up one morning to find themselves being born, by chance, in the UK are more entitled than those who cared enough about UK citizenship to seek it out and then earn it would be to participate in the UK polis.
One sees your point - it is quite outrageous that anyone not born a British subject should presume to have an opinion on anything in Britain. Indeed, if too many ersatz Britons were to voice their thoughts, real Brits might actually learn something.
AY
June 25th, 2010 9:58pm Report this comment‘The in-queue is bigger than the out-queue.’
Yes ma'am. And it doesn't matter at all who and why are in and out.
Oh my. Some people definitely should use their heads only for primary purpose - for eating. If too lazy to think.
Jez
June 25th, 2010 9:58pm Report this commentHa Ha haaaaa!
Come on guys, don't see it as 198 against common sense.... see it as 198 people, that if you were in a scrape you be able to easily rip off out of their life's savings (er, probably over the phone by the looks of that)- especially the 57 for-a-while undecided borderline-retards!
How can such gullible people function in real life, day to day situations?
"Well you know, i don't really er, knoooow... but after talking to Bonnie i've joined the SWP."
Give us a break. Please.
yank
June 26th, 2010 1:02am Report this commentCraig Strachan: "...California's deficit, measured by next's year's projected shortfall as a % of this year's state budget, is in fact one of the lowest amongst US states. The absolute numbers are big, but so is California."
.
.
Hmmmm, so Mr. Strachan, you believe California is too big to fail? I'm sorry, but California's current bond rating is junk, and lower than Greece's, so the people who judge such things disagree with you. The Cali crowd recently resorted to paying off creditors with IOUs, they are so broke.
The rosy projections you reference for next year are made by the same people who rang up the junk bond rating, and were passing out the IOUs. Their word likely matches their bond ratings. Junk.
Soon, after the 2010 census, we will reconfigure congressional districts, and California's count of House reps will likely drop, as a result of % population drops, likely 1-2 of their seats yanked from their grasping fingers, after a 1/2 century of 5-10 seat gains every decade. People are recognizing the economic carnage the Left has caused out there, and are fleeing.
Worse, those who flee are the educated and business class, so the % of uneducated, illiterate, non-english speaking and often illegal alien increases, and these are the prime breeding stock out there, as you should know.
The image of California that the lad posted at the top of this discussion is decades aged. I'd sooner start a business in Greece than in Cali, and the food is better there as well.
Craig Strachan
June 26th, 2010 4:26pm Report this commentyank: "Hmmmm, so Mr. Strachan, you believe California is too big to fail?"
Too big, too many electoral votes, too innovative to fail!
yank
June 26th, 2010 6:13pm Report this commentNope, as mentioned above, the kooks' political work in California is measured by the coming DROP in electoral college votes, and corresponding drop in congressional seats, after decades and decades of 5-10 increases in both. Political power drops as well, as you should know.
Folks fleeing will do that. You're reading from a Hollywood script that's like most of them... false... and decades old. California is as close to failure as Greece, or worse.
TGF UKIP
June 26th, 2010 11:15pm Report this commentWTF is Bonnie Greer. Judging by the participants the whole thing seems like just another of The Fanzines lefty fests.
Back to top