Subscribe to The Spectator

Saturday 26 May 2012

Latest issue

Buy the current issue

Jobs at Telegraph

Tuesday, 3rd August 2010

Why the government needn't fear the strikes

Peter Hoskin 1:00pm

With the threat of major strikes timed to coincide with Osborne's spending review in October, I think it's worth exhuming an important point that Julian Glover made in his Guardian column last month:

"UK politics is often characterised as a contest for the centre ground, but that misdescribes the nature of the quest. Centrism implies banality, but I don't think voters want their governments to be mundane. There is a willingness to endorse radical action if it is explained and if it looks practicable. It worked for the left under Attlee and Blair; it worked for the right under Thatcher; and it is working – so far – for this government.

That a large number of people oppose what you are doing, very strongly, can become a strength, so long as they are seen to be opposing something rooted in a kind of imperative. Eight years ago almost half a million people marched through London with the aim of blocking the hunting ban – and to their dismay, the public took the government's side. The miners' strike, the Iraq war – examples are legion. Half a million people and more will probably be marching against the budget cuts soon, and will feel just as strongly that their solidarity brings invincibility. They may be proved wrong.

Keep calm and carry on has become a cliche, but it is good advice for a government. Stay pragmatic and keep explaining, firmly, in moderate language and with courtesy. The left will howl at budget cuts that their own economic legacy makes necessary, just as the right will howl against political reform. That doesn't mean these things won't get through. The noisiest causes often fail."

To my mind, there's plenty of truth in that – and this autumn may well be the proof of it. There will be much vocal opposition to the government's fiscal agenda, but that could simply obscure an even deeper vein of support for what Osborne is doing. The coalition's primary task will be to remain unmoved, and continue making the case for deficit-reduction, as best it can, to the silent majority.

Filed under: Coalition (2088 more articles) , George Osborne (798 more articles) , Public finances (753 more articles) , Spending cuts (626 more articles) , Spending review (50 more articles) , Strikes (66 more articles) , Trade Unions (46 more articles) , TUC (4 more articles) , UK politics (5405 more articles)

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Alex Massie | Melanie Phillips | Faith Based | Cappuccino Culture

Actions: Email to a friend  |   Permalink   |   Comments (17) | Subscribe

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments Post comment

Alan Edwards

August 3rd, 2010 1:40pm Report this comment

The merit of such objections are usually inversly proportional to their merit.
Just look at Northern Ireland politics for proof of this!

strapworld

August 3rd, 2010 1:44pm Report this comment

I would love to see Balls interviewed by Jeff Randall,Peter Hitchins and Richard Littlejohn a sort of Star Chamber interview, where he would not be able to get away with his normal bully boy tactics.

With someone impartial as Chairman, say Lord Tebbit?

John Findlater

August 3rd, 2010 1:45pm Report this comment

As there are way too many civil servants and, as Francis Maud said, there are thousands doing nothing but are too expensive to fire,,,,,,,well,, if the parasites go on strike the government has a spelndid opportunity to cure the problem by firing them.
If a worker goes on strike, then the work contract is broken and they run the risk of being fired with no redundancy, pensions etc.

So Public sector Please do us all a favour and go on strike,,we wont miss you because most you are lazy wasters, plus it will save the tax payer lots of money.

Olaf Rye

August 3rd, 2010 2:02pm Report this comment

I do not think that anyone is too expensive to fire--in the long term, getting rid of them will save a fortune. Surely, their benefit entitlement does not match their salary nor the pension contributions that tax-payers must make on their behalf. As for pay-offs on redundancies, well, it is costly but I would rather see them gone and out of the system, unable to cause more damage. In short, from my perspective, the mass firings are well worth the cost !

Chris lancashire

August 3rd, 2010 2:17pm Report this comment

Another reason not to fear the strikes is that the public may not notice.

JohnPage

August 3rd, 2010 2:46pm Report this comment

When the government is putting its case, there are two lessons it should learn from the Labour spinmeisters.

1. Phrase making - such as 'investment in public services'. It needs three or four phrases which encapsulate its themes.

2. Then repetition, repetition, repetition of the phrases - word for word.

Ian Walker

August 3rd, 2010 2:51pm Report this comment

I'm terrified of our local Diversity Officers going on strike. Imagine the lack of diversity that will ensue...

Hugh Janus

August 3rd, 2010 2:53pm Report this comment

Good to see that we can rely as always on the unions to foul things up and create an even bigger shambles than the one we started with in May. Never mind, it will be their jobs that go in the event of any prolonged industrial action. History shows that this is a lesson they have never been able to understand.

yank

August 3rd, 2010 2:55pm Report this comment

The public employee unions here are taking out advertisements describing the carnage that will arise if budget cuts take hold.

Real wrath of God type stuff.

Disease and pestilence and plague.

Criminals running rampant.

Women rustled.

Cattle raped.

Dogs and cats... living together.

It's not being well received, to say no more. In 100 days, we'll tab up the results of their efforts.

Harry Paget

August 3rd, 2010 3:51pm Report this comment

The public sector go on strike? They'd have to come back from long term sick leave first.

At the risk of sounding Pythonesque, I dream of a 1% pay rise, considering many in the private sector, like me, have been on the receiving end of a 12% pay cut.

JohnPage

August 3rd, 2010 4:50pm Report this comment

I'm terrified of our local Diversity Officers going on strike. Imagine the lack of diversity that will ensue.

It must have been said before, but presumably they would strike in diverse ways.

David Bouvier

August 3rd, 2010 5:00pm Report this comment

Olaf Rye - it some cases apparently it is up to 6 years salary.

Anyone, the government was told by the courts that a drastic revision of these terms was not possible as a matter of ministerial discretion because of the some of the legal infrastructure set up to give the civil service a slight buffer against ministerial whim (ie discretion). But I believe an SI or similar should be sufficient to enable a reduction in their serverance terms.

TGF UKIP

August 3rd, 2010 7:13pm Report this comment

Your problem is Pete that this gang didn't exactly hold steady in opposition. All Gordon had to do was to say "boo" and Wobbly Dave scuttled to agree with him.

I agree, though, that their test will come in the Autumn with figures almost certainly indicating that borrowing this year will be substantially lower than forecast. What will they do then? Row back on their tax increases particularly on higher rate taxpayers to ensure growth next year doesn't slip below 2% or row back on the spending cuts to appease the BBC and North London?

I think you will know only too well where their past form indicates they will go.

Major Plonquer 1

August 4th, 2010 2:10am Report this comment

In the past there have been some great technological and social leaps that have come from public sector strikes. How many people now heat their homes with coal?

In the 1980s in the USA 45,000 Bell Telephone operators went on strike. Their employer AT&T switched on the first fully automated telephone operator system and 45,000 people lost their jobs. Now these fully automated telephone systems have been replaced with much cheaper Indian people the economic impact of which has brought India to the brink of the First World. Moreover the existence of 45,000 out of work telephone operators sitting around with nothing to do explains why the USA leads the world in utterly useless technology such as Twitter and Facebook and why the word 'friends' has had to be redefined.

However, the finest example was when the Air Traffic Controllers went on strike. Ronald Regan first handed the job over to the military and then went on TV and fired ALL the controllers in public. They were subsequently invited to reapply for their jobs and only 80% were rehired, many at substantially lower rates.

So you see, public sector strikes can actually work for the public good.

Clear Memories

August 4th, 2010 2:44am Report this comment

John Page

There is nothing this government can learn from Labour save how to do things the wrong way.

To use the words 'government' and 'Labour' in the same sentence is itself a contradiction in terms. 'Labour' and 'self-interested oppression' go together much more accurately.

maddy1

August 4th, 2010 4:46am Report this comment

I know some of our workers have nothing to do! I do wonder, if our special diversity "teh tarik" division have created special "non jobs" for our muslims, like they have in Asia? Will a future generation of retired muslims be suing the health service for work related piles and other complaints of the posterior. Does anyone else see behind this facade.

2trueblue

August 4th, 2010 1:19pm Report this comment

David Bouvier. 6yrs. discression?????? Gosh, they are living in a different world to all of us. Surely common sense must prevail at some point? Perhaps not. No wonder we are in trouble.

Post comment

Back to top

Cartoons

Tag Cloud

Coffee House archive

sponsored links

Spectator recommends

Spectator classifieds

THE PRESENT FINDER

1,700 Unusual Christmas Presents Request Catalogue 01935 815 195 Quote SPEC10 for 10% discount www.presentfinder.co.uk

OLIVE BRANCH FLORISTS

Pimilco based Florist with online ordering Web: www.olivebranch.net Tel: 020 7630 1868 Fax: 020 7233 8844

RUFFS Bespoke Signet rings

62 Shore Road, Warsash, Southampton, SO31 9FT Telephone: 01489 578867 Web site: www.ruffs.co.uk