Subscribe to The Spectator

Friday 10 February 2012

Latest issue

Buy the current issue

Jobs at Telegraph

Wednesday, 8th September 2010

PMQs live blog

Peter Hoskin 11:50am

Stay tuned for live coverage of Clegg vs Straw from 1200.

1201: And here we go. Clegg begins by passing on his best wishes to David Cameron and his family. Condolences for the fallen in Afghanistan follow - "we will never forget their sacrifices."

1204: Mark Pritchard begins with a dubiously plant-like question. "300 policemen have been laid off in West Mercia," he observes - is the fiscal mess left by the last government to blame? It tees Clegg up to tear into Labour's legacy. A combative start.

1206: Jack Straw steps up to the dispatch box. He begins with condolences for our troops, and then adds some warm regards for Cameron and his family. The first question, though, changes the tone: is Clegg satisfied that Andy Coulson wasn't aware of phone hacking at the NotW.

1208: Clegg handles the question well, saying that Andy Coulson has already "taken responsibility" for what happened uder his editorship. He adds that it is a matter for the police to decide whether matters should go further.

1207:
Smart, smart stuff from Clegg. He has a newspaper quote from when Coulson resigned, to the effect that Gordon Brown was the first to call Coulson and offer his commiserations. "You'll go on to do a great job somewhere," said Brown. Much mirth on the coalition benches.

1210: Clegg is far less on the defensive than you might expect. He says that the previous investigation was conducted under a Labour government - so they're to blame if it was inadequate.

1211: Woah, look at him go. Now Clegg's reeling off all the reasons why he shouldn't take lessons from Labour: the "dodgy dossier," McBride, etc.

1213: Straw is pushing the same line of questioning: is it realistic to think that Coulson didn't know about phone hacking. Clegg remains surefooted.

1214: And Clegg rounds if off by asking whether, with a "war in Afghanistan and a flood in Pakistan," Labour should have their collective mind on other issues than Coulson.

1215: A question from John Redwood gives Clegg the opportunity to quote one Tony Blair on the deficit and public finances. The coalition are delighted with the postscript to his memoir - and I expect they'll mention its prescriptions time and again.

1217: Groans from the Labour benches as Clegg once again brings up "the legacy we've inherited," in response to a question abour spending. In response, he stresses that the British public "needs to know" that we have one of the worst deficits in the developed world.

1219: Clegg outlines an independent inquiry in the Mull of Kintyre accident.

1221: Clegg declines to say that the Catholic Church should apologise for the actions of Father James Chesney. 

1223:
Labour's Joan Walley asks whether Clegg has any qualms about cuts to JobCentre Plus workforces. Clegg is unabashed in response: he asks her whether she has any qualms that the Labour government planned £44bn of cuts but didn't tell the British public. Fiesty stuff.

1225: Ian Davidson quips that today is his Birthday - and that he'd like a couple of British, not French, aircraft carriers by way of a present. Clegg responds that "I'd like to give him a gift, but it may not be of the shape and size he's requested."

1227:
Nic Dakin tells the story of one of his constituents whose "Big Society neighbourhood group" will lose money because of the coalition's cuts. Clegg falls back on the ol' legacy argument again.

1229:
Quizzed about today's Sheffield Forgemasters developements, Clegg is blunt: the money wasn't there for the £80 million loan that the Labour government promised the company.

1231:
Clegg fears that the "worst may be to come" in the flooded regions of Pakistan, as "water-borne deseases take hold".

1232: On the AV referendum, Clegg says: "the stability of the coalition is not dependent on the result of one vote." He adds that the overall politcal reform package is more expansive than that.

1233: And that's it. My verdict shortly.

VERDICT: The summer break has clearly done Nick Clegg some good. Here he was, back to the form he displayed in the TV debates: combative, surefooted and effervescent. One might have expected Jack Straw's questions about Andy Coulson to cause some discomfort, but, really, they failed to connect at all. Indeed, with that well-chosen Gordon Brown quote, and a plea for more serious questions about Afghanistan or Pakistan, Clegg even managed to tread the moral high ground. The rest of the session followed a pattern which will become familiar to observers, if it isn't already: innuendo about cuts set against attacks on Labour's legacy. As his answer to Joan Walley demonstrated (see 1223 above), Clegg got stuck into that battle with some relish. An encouraging performance.

Filed under: Conservatives (2076 more articles) , Jack Straw (33 more articles) , Labour (2014 more articles) , Liberal Democrats (1044 more articles) , Live blog (73 more articles) , Nick Clegg (637 more articles) , Parliament (232 more articles) , PMQs (227 more articles) , UK politics (4910 more articles)

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Alex Massie | Melanie Phillips | Faith Based | Cappuccino Culture

Actions: Email to a friend  |   Permalink   |   Comments (16) | Subscribe

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments Post comment

Kasou

September 8th, 2010 12:11pm Report this comment

Wasnt Jack Straw something to do with Justice, last year ? Wondert why he didnt push the matter then ?

AndyinBrum

September 8th, 2010 12:31pm Report this comment

Has Gordon turned up?

TrevorsDen

September 8th, 2010 12:37pm Report this comment

The reality is that there is only marginal difference between 'Tory' cuts and Labour ones, and about 6 months difference between when they start.
This is hardly an Armageddon scenario.

Of course 'loadsamoney' Balls wants to scrap even the Labour cuts and add even more borrowing. Does he tell us where he will get the money from (and which programmes he will cut) to pay for the extra interest on the extra borrowing?

Paul

September 8th, 2010 1:01pm Report this comment

Have to say, Clegg did very well.

Was watching BBC2 coverage, and viewers were commenting that they were fed up with the "this is Labour's fault" line fron Nick Clegg - in all fairness, how can that response be avoided? Labour's failures pervade the whole thing.

Occasional Ostrich

September 8th, 2010 1:07pm Report this comment

Young Nick's really starting to enjoy this, isn't he? Once he really gets into his stride DC'd better start watching his back.

Oh, I forgot, he's watching it already, against attacks from what should be his own side.

Paddy

September 8th, 2010 1:32pm Report this comment

Has it not dawned on Labour yet that they are now in opposition.

Richard of York

September 8th, 2010 2:44pm Report this comment

Its time the coalition realised they have to answer some questions and tell us what they are doing.
So far it's been all huff and puff.
No new politics here today.
Clegg is nailled and his blocking statements will haunt him for a long time.
Are we paying Cameron to have his extended leave paternity leave and now compassionate leave the man is a serial absentee.

Noa

September 8th, 2010 4:28pm Report this comment

RoY

A heartless comment that does you no credit given the sudden death of David Cameron's father.

When can we expect your graceful apology?

perdix

September 8th, 2010 4:33pm Report this comment

Richard of York - in view of the seriousness of the illness of Cameron's father your comment is entirely inappropriate.His father died today.

Cameo Parkway Kid

September 8th, 2010 4:41pm Report this comment

Has it not dawned on the Condem's that they are no longer in opposition?

Paddy

September 8th, 2010 6:06pm Report this comment

What a shame Blair has had to cancel his book signing again.

If only he had stood-up to Brown and his henchmen whilst in government.

His party also seem to have abandoned him.

What a shame he won 3 elections for them and now Brown has 'trashed' it all

Richard of York

September 8th, 2010 6:14pm Report this comment

My comment was made before the news of his fathers death reached Florida....my crystal ball is still in transit.
I hope in return for the sympathy of the people Cameron will attend all the funerals of those who take their own lives due to his cuts and the heartlessness of his policies. Maybe the victims of mental health patients left to fend for themselves untreated in the community will at least get a card saying sorry.

Yorkshire Pit Village

September 8th, 2010 7:18pm Report this comment

Richard Of York @ 6:14

I usually laugh along with your banter, this however is something else.

Hopefully you won’t be left to fend for yourself for too long.

Richard of York

September 8th, 2010 8:12pm Report this comment

@ Yorkie Pit Village

Glad you like my posts. Sorry you feel less well adjusted to my last one.
Sometimes you have to strike a balance and when Speccies get their dander up they can be quite horrid so a little antidote helps keep the whole thing within the bounds of reason.
When an old man dies its sad who ever it is. However when a child dies it is beyond sad. When the old man has a long and comfortable life with the social trappings and strong family around him its a mourned passing but not a tradgedy. The baby left to die of cold, thirst and hunger because a mother is too poor then thats an outrage.

Noa Zrk

September 8th, 2010 10:51pm Report this comment

RoY

The graciousness of your 'apology' speaks for itself, in such family matters the same consideration that you would expect apply to yourself apply even to politicians.

Your outrage at 'cot deaths from cuts' is seen for what it really is; a risible attempt to detract from your appalling ill manners.

If that's an apology for your

Joseph

September 9th, 2010 3:38am Report this comment

I'm suddenly reminded of primary school, Richard of York gave battle in vain.

Post comment

Back to top

Cartoons

Tag Cloud

Coffee House archive

sponsored links

Spectator recommends

Spectator classifieds

THE PRESENT FINDER

1,700 Unusual Christmas Presents Request Catalogue 01935 815 195 Quote SPEC10 for 10% discount www.presentfinder.co.uk

OLIVE BRANCH FLORISTS

Pimilco based Florist with online ordering Web: www.olivebranch.net Tel: 020 7630 1868 Fax: 020 7233 8844

RUFFS Bespoke Signet rings

62 Shore Road, Warsash, Southampton, SO31 9FT Telephone: 01489 578867 Web site: www.ruffs.co.uk