Transparency marches on
Peter Hoskin 7:06pm
It has been quite a few days for transparency in Westminster. First, Ben Gummer's
ten minute rule bill for
tax transparency — which would see every taxpayer in the country receive a statement detailing what they owe and what the money's being spent on — earned itself a second reading in the House. And now, today, the Department for Education releases its new ‘performance
tables’ for secondary schools. You can sift through them here, and I'd recommend you spend at least a couple of minutes doing
just that. They reveal finer detail about schools and results than has been made public before, such as about how ‘disadvantaged children’ (those on free school meals or in local
authority care for at least six months) perform in individual schools. We've seen facts similar to today's
‘only 33.9 per cent of disadvantaged pupils achieved five A*-C grade GCSEs including English and maths, compared to the national average of 58.2 per cent in maintained schools’, before
now. It's more the capacity to delve down, quickly and easily, to a school-by-school level that's new.
I've waxed enthusiastic about transparency before now, so I'll spare CoffeeHousers the full routine. Suffice to say that these new school tables should make parents more informed (and thus, to a lesser degree, boost choice), as well as ratchet up the pressure on under-performing schools. It's less about targets and rankings than good ol’ honest truth. The more information there is, the harder it is for bad schools to game the system (or, rather, the more likely it is that they'll be exposed if they try). And the decent schools will get the full credit they deserve. Speaking of which, it turns out that — after the ARK group's impressive results yesterday — GCSE results at academies in general improved at almost twice the national average.
What's particularly encouraging is that there's more to come. Apparently, the Department for Education should be releasing even more detailed subject-by-subject data next month, in the build-up to the full National Pupil Database in the middle of the year. The government is excited about what this great mine of information will mean not just for education but also for the cause of transparency itself — and understandably so. The hope is that people outside of government will get their hands all over it and start producing snazzy, digital school guides that will tell parents everything they need to know. And they might tell educators and politicians the occasional thing too. If, for instance, one school is doing particularly well at teaching French, then there it is — visit it, learn its secret, spread it. Everyone stands to gain from this sort of transparency, except the charlatans.



Previous






geoffm
January 26th, 2012 7:50pm Report this commentSure its quiet they are all waiting for their next set of orders from brussels as spouted by the richtstag led by merkozy. Even daves speech had to be passed by them before he gave davros the benefit of his wisdom
toco
January 26th, 2012 7:52pm Report this commentWelcome news indeed!All of us who are parents and perhaps also grandparents regard the education of our children and grandchildren as one of the most important aspects of our lives and aspirations.No longer should schools and teachers who could do better be sheltered from the spotlight and the greater informed the parents the more effective they will be when going in to bat on behalf of their children.Transparency also helps those excellent teachers draw a distinction between themselves and more moderate colleagues who 'can do better'.
Sir Everard Digby
January 27th, 2012 7:33am Report this commentNo,no no! What you describe is a further symptom of the problem. Education is not a commodity to be priced and traded. This so-called 'transparency' is simply reinforcing the psyche which believes schools are business units which need to 'sell' services to parents.
What schools will therefore do is engage in selective statistics management to show themselves in the best light.That has nothing to do with education.
I believe education is :
A process of gaining knowledge, inculcating forms of proper conduct and acquiring technical competency.
Quite where these statistics support that is difficult to fathom.
We have had 13 years of endless statistics gathering.Where has that improved education?
Apparently young people to not have the skills to be employed,and they do not have mature enough thought processes by the time the enter University.
If this is true,glossy brochures will not be much use.
RCA
January 27th, 2012 8:34am Report this commentThis is excellent news. Will the BBC give the government and Mr Gove the. Credit for enabling it to happen?
oldtimer
January 27th, 2012 9:49am Report this commentFrom a quick scan of places I am familiar with, this looks like a very good initiative.
Adam Johnson
January 27th, 2012 5:07pm Report this commentBen Gummer sounds like something you'd pay £30 for, from an elderly hooker
Back to top