Sunday 22 November 2009

Jobs at Telegraph

Thursday, 31st July 2008

Miliband approaches the point of no return

James Forsyth 2:32pm

David Miliband is not backing down. Listening to him on the Jeremy Vine Show just now, it was noticeable how pleased he sounded when callers rung in to say how awful Brown was and how what Labour needed was a nice young man like him in charge. Indeed, when the final caller launched an assault on the Prime Minister’s character, Miliband offered only the must lukewarm praise for the PM and joked about the caller being his mother. At the top of the show, Miliband delivered the wonderfully ambiguous line, “I’ve always wanted to support Gordon as leader.”

Miliband’s performance showed how far he has to go before he can convince the public that he is cut-out for the top job. He lacks gravitas. The callers treated him with very little respect---a problem that will be compounded when voters become more familiar with what he looks like. More surprisingly, Miliband can’t do feel your pain. When a woman called in to complain about how difficult her life was now that her husband had been laid off and how she was getting no help from the government, Miliband started to lecture her before correcting himself. He was also patronising to the callers; there were a few too many dismissive actuallys.

Miliband might have picked up a few of Blair’s verbal ticks and mannerisms but he is nowhere near as good a communicator as Blair was back in 1994. In the presentation terms at least, Cameron is far more the heir—or, should we say successor—to Blair than Miliband is.

Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Alex Massie | Melanie Phillips | Faith Based | Cappuccino Culture

Actions: Email to a friend  |   Permalink   |   Comments (12) | Subscribe

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments Post comment

J H Holloway

July 31st, 2008 2:57pm Report this comment

Interesting. Still, it suggests that Milipede could prevent a massive Labour wipe-out. It seems the country has (rightly) turned against Brown himself.

Mike, Brighton

July 31st, 2008 3:14pm Report this comment

Do the math:
Brown + Labour = Electoral Meltdown

Millibland + Labour = Electoral Catastrophe

So the problem in Labour, the leader merely compounds the problem.

Surely Labour's worst nightmare is to go through the pain, divisiveness and appalling PR of removing Brown to replace him with (say) Millibland.
For the polls to barely move yet the election has now been brought forward by a year (or more)

Faceless Bureaucrat

July 31st, 2008 3:30pm Report this comment

Milipede, Harpic, Purnell, Cruddas - all irrelevant.

It's over for Labour, whoever is at the helm...

TrevorH

July 31st, 2008 3:40pm Report this comment

Just how would Milliband prevent a Labour wipe out?

Is he going to conjour up benign economic circumstances?

Milliband is an empty vessel - a state-ist marxist empty vessel. He like ALL of Labour stood by and applauded all the way through Browns ministrations as Chancellor, which have now been shown to be useless.

Lets be clear - if Milliband succeeds in his ambitions then all we will get from him is spin - plus surrender to the EU. The marxist Milliband family hate everything Britain stands for.

JR

July 31st, 2008 3:44pm Report this comment

To repeat what I commented on Peter's post:

"The fact Brown will dither is actually a significant opportunity for Milliband or someone else to position themselves as a friend to the voter and enemy to Brown. Given the deep seated hatred of Brown among the electorate there is a possibility of a figure (or movement) within the Labour party to upsurp Cameron as the 'opposition'.Coupled with a bold, almost reckless, set of policies on becoming PM (e.g. free prescriptions, tax on £250ks to fund increase in personal allowances, windfall tax on energy companies, free childcare for all etc) it could pull them back to respectability - and a snap election could then give them a fighting chance of a hung parliament."

I don't think Milliband is the man to do it - but a combination of Milliband and Johnson (with Johnson taking DPM and doing lots of media) - I could just about see it.

Fergus Pickering

July 31st, 2008 3:51pm Report this comment

It's OK folks. This man is not the man to bother David Cameron. This is the poor man's Obama. I gather your average voter thinks he IS Obama, same haircut, same light brown complexion, same patronising bullshit, same discomfort among ther poor. He's gratifyingly useless.

Carrie

July 31st, 2008 4:12pm Report this comment

I wonder who are Milbands supporters?

Tel, Spain

July 31st, 2008 4:18pm Report this comment

Ed Balls is the man to watch now, his next move will be telling. If it comes down to a Miliband V Balls contest civil war will break out inside the Labour party......hold on tight it's gonna get interesting!!

David C

July 31st, 2008 4:22pm Report this comment

The worst nightmare for Labour would be to repeat (albeit on a smaller scale)
the mistake Brown made last Autumn.
The aborted ‘election-that-never-was’, lead to the events that convinced the public that Brown was not fit to govern.
For Labour to set in motion a leadership challenge, yet lack the courage to carry it through, would leave an already frustrated and deeply sceptical electorate with no other impression than Labour itself is no longer fit to govern.

Harman and Milliband, together with the background noise from the PLP, have started the process that leads to the removal of Brown; the survival of the Party will be decided if they succeed or fail.

Nothing like pressure, is there?

Miliband for PM???

July 31st, 2008 4:36pm Report this comment

Tnak God for the BBC iplayer!

Frank Pulley

July 31st, 2008 5:20pm Report this comment

I just don't want this ugly, self-regarding little greenhouse-raised Marxist representing my country as Foreign Secretary (albeit as Mollocks-Brown's puppet), never mind as Prime Minister. As for anyone who thinks that he did "quite well" on the Jeremy Whine show, they really shouldn't be writing for this magazine; it was puerile, LSE text-book political prattle and if Brown had any balls other than Ed, David Milibollocks would be sacked today. However, instead the BBC gives him a two hour political broadcast to launch his bid, aided and abetted by Jewermy, with a filtration process that shielded him from some really shitty questions that should have been forthcoming and weren't. Ye Gods!

kiffa

August 4th, 2008 9:35am Report this comment

On that show, only one caller got through: an extremely angry working class lady who told him that Labour couldn't run a bath! It was classic.
The BBC pro-Labour filtration process is a disgrace: it is time we turned our fire on that institution, as well

Post comment

Back to top

Tag Cloud

Coffee House archive

sponsored links

Spectator recommends

Spectator classifieds

      GASCONY

GASCONY, SW France, near Condom-en-Armagnac 13th Century stone house, 21st Century luxury for 12 in 5 en-suites. 50 acres +

BIG SAND STEEL BAND

IF YOU ARE PLANNING A CHAMPAGNE RECEPTION and looking for some light entertainment, you can now hire London's busiest steel

BOSC LEBAT, Tarn et Garonne.

BOSC LEBAT, SW France. Only 45 minutes from Toulouse Airport with daily flights from most provincial airports avoiding the horrors