Home > Coffee House

Friday 20 November 2009

Friday, 20th November 2009

The problem with Brown's latest Big Idea

Peter Hoskin 12:05pm

There's some very readable stuff in this week's Economist (including a leader which outlines what Brown's government should – but almost certainly won't – do with its "last months in power"). But if you read only one article from it, make sure it's the Bagehot column and its dissection of Brown's latest Big Idea: public service guarantees.

These are the pledges-turned-legal entitlements which popped up throughout the Queen's Speech – such as the "guarantee" that patients will have hospital treatment within 18 weeks of being referred by a GP. As Bagehot...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (13)

Thursday, 19th November 2009

The day ends on a sour note for Labour

Peter Hoskin 6:49pm

Two Labour figures, two bad news stories. The first is Tony Blair, and the news that he has given up on the role of EU President – leaving the path more or less clear for the Belgian PM, Herman Van Rompuy. The second is Harriet Harman, and the news that she faces prosecution for allegedly "driving without due care and attention and driving while using a mobile phone."

The Blair story is significant enough on its own – but throw in Harman, and it's doubly certain that Brown's legislative programme will be...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (42)

They think it's all over

David Blackburn 1:07pm

It looks like curtains for ‘President’ Blair. Every commentator besides Adam Boulton and James MacIntyre, who is possessed of a ruinous gambling streak, have now virtually written off the former PM. Blair has an uncanny knack of winning through against the odds, so I will not call time on his chances quite yet. But with Merkel and Sarkozy united against him, the fat lady is warming up for the main event with a few scales and arpeggios.

Where would failure leave Blair with regard to Labour and the election? Staunch Brownite...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (19)

Hoist by his own petard

David Blackburn 9:00am

The Queen’s Speech contained some worthwhile bills. Parents will face orders when a child breaches antisocial behaviour rules, and the Flood and Water Maintainence Bill, whilst unlikely to rival the 1911 Parliament Act in the annals of Westminster, is welcome, responsible legislation. I can even see that if you’re that way inclined, which I’m not, Harman’s Equality Bill has something to commend it.

The remainder of the programme is a political landmine, presenting benevolences that mask incendiary conceits. Clever politics theoretically, but in the rush to prime the fuses, and with little thought...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (41)

Wednesday, 18th November 2009

A paper-thin Queen’s Speech

Lloyd Evans 5:12pm

Even before the Queen had trundled back to Buckingham Palace, Mandy had let the cat out of the bag. Speaking on BBC News he said of the Gracious Speech, ‘All these laws are relevant … and achievable. It will be for the public to decide whether they want them or not.’ There you have it. The greatest power in the land admits the Queen’s Speech is Labour’s manifesto.

The response to the Gracious Speech is an enjoyably ragged parliamentary occasion, full of ancient traditions and even more ancient jokes. Frank Dobson proposed the...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (21)

The Prince is playing politics

David Blackburn 1:57pm

Lord Mandelson argues in the Evening Standard that Labour’s legislative programme has the Tories running for cover. The forthcoming debate should prove this thesis to be nonsense. 7 minutes of largely rehashed policies, including all the old favourites – equality, the ‘smarter’ state and so forth, is unlikely to give Cameron sleepless nights.

I suspect Mandelson knows this as there is little substance to his argument. The article contains more insinuations than an episode of Midsomer Murders. Mandelson writes:

‘David Cameron seems to be getting a little rattled. Following his flustered performance...

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (26)

The Queen's Speech: complete footage

Peter Hoskin 1:28pm

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comment

Nothing to see here

Peter Hoskin 11:59am

Blink and you missed it. After seven minutes, the Queen had rattled through the Government's legislative agenda for the next few months. It was all pretty much as expected – although it’s worth noting the “council of financial stability,” made up of the Treasury, the Bank of England and FSA, chaired by the Chancellor, and which was first mooted back in July. The question is whether any of this will connect with the public. I rather doubt it.

We’ll put footage on Coffee House as soon as it’s available.

Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (10)

Last chance saloon

Peter Hoskin 10:37am

So what to make of today's Queen's Speech? Myself, I'm finding it hard to drum up much excitement. After all, we already know most of its contents (if you want a primer, then check out this excellent Guardian summary article here), and much of it is either underwhelming, unworkable or – as everyone from David Cameron to Michael White has pointed out – self-servingly political on Labour's part. Tory peers are saying that they'll block the proposals, but you've got to doubt whether they'll be enacted before the next election...