Status Anxiety

2 February 2008

The disturbing thing about fairy stories is that the father is always a useless weed

Consequently, it was with unconfined joy that I greeted the decision of Berca — the government’s educational technology body — to condemn the Three Little Pigs on the grounds that ‘the use of pigs raises cultural issues’. Their primary concern was to protect Muslim children from emotional distress, but I see no reason why my children’s wellbeing shouldn’t be taken into account. After all, their maternal grandfather is Jewish, so pork ‘raises cultural issues’ for them, too. In any event, it was the perfect excuse I was looking for to discard the Three Little Pigs. After reading this story to my children every night for the best part of two years, I would be happy if every copy in existence was consigned to a Fahrenheit 451-style bonfire.

As an alternative, I went out and bought Grimm’s Fairy Tales. What better introduction to the joys of storytelling? I thought. Here is the treasure trove of fables that will instil in them a lifelong love of literature.

I began with Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and, after a cacophony of objections, they settled down to enjoy it. It wasn’t until about halfway through that it began to dawn on me that it, too, ‘raises cultural issues’. No, I’m not talking about the stereotypical depiction of people of restricted growth, but its unflattering portrait of fathers. Why does the King do nothing to protect Snow White from the Wicked Queen? Why doesn’t she ask him for help? Why is running away her only option?

The next night, I bravely resisted the demands to read Snow White again and turned to Cinderella instead. Here, too, the father is portrayed as criminally negligent. How can he fail to intervene as his new wife and her two daughters systematically exploit and humiliate his only child? At her lowest ebb, poor Cinderella is forced to repeatedly pick lentils out of a grate filled with ashes — a form of psychological torture that would shame Abu Ghraib. As I was reading this, Sasha was staring at me with a look of wounded indignation. ‘Where’s her father in all this?’ she seemed to be saying. ‘Why doesn’t he do something?’

However, neither of these fairy tales, disturbing as they are, comes close to the one I chose on my third night: Hansel and Gretel. In this story, the father is so pathetic — so incapable of standing up to his new wife — that he actually joins a conspiracy to murder his own children. At his wife’s insistence, he leads them into a forest and abandons them in the hope that they’ll die of starvation — not once, but twice! At the end of the story, we’re told that the children’s stepmother is dead and they all lived happily ever after, but judging from how feeble their father is, they would be better off in a foster home.

Admittedly, stepmothers don’t come out of these stories particularly well, either, but at least they have the excuse of not being the biological parents. In a court of law, they might be able to plead temporary insanity, given how consumed they are with jealousy. But what mitigating circumstances can the fathers point to? Their love for their children is not in doubt, it’s just that they’re too weak to offer them any protection. I don’t know what the politics of the Brothers Grimm were — Revolutionary Communists? Feminist Separatists? — but if their object was to undermine the trust that little children place in their fathers they couldn’t have done a better job.

It seems I may have to go back to reading the Three Little Pigs. At least in that story there is no father who stands by and watches as the lives of his children are in danger.

Previous page 1 | 2

More articles from: Toby Young | this section

Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (2)

Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Post comment

Gina Stepp

February 3rd, 2008 8:10am Report this comment

Toby, you should do what Eric B. Anderson is doing, and start your own series of children's books that depict fathers in a better light. The more the better! There's a link to Anderson's book here, but please let me know when you start yours: http://familymatters.vision.org/public/item/195983

Mark Sevier

February 6th, 2008 12:45am Report this comment

Mr. Young is a twit. He essentially blames the fathers in the fairy tales for being dead. Hansel & Gretel's father, admittedly, is a weak-willed willy, but he's one of the few who are actually alive during the tale.

Post comment