Charles Clover hails the courage of Elizabeth Pascoe, who has fought against the compulsory purchase of her Victorian home, and the laws that enable such state vandalism
Elizabeth Pascoe, a granny in her sixties with a fondness for pink cardigans, is an unlikely heroine, but she is one to me. For when Liverpool city council and a government agency told her, four years ago, that they wanted to compulsorily purchase and demolish her fine Victorian home in the Edge Lane area for no particularly good reason, Ms Pascoe chose to fight.
Sitting in her cardigan, surrounded by piles of paper, Elizabeth fought two public inquiries and two high court actions against compulsory purchase orders (CPOs), which are the battering ram of the Pathfinder regeneration schemes, the 1960s-style urban clearances reinvented by John Prescott. These still, astonishingly, grind on all over the Midlands and the North, consuming billions of public money.
Elizabeth Pascoe won a famous victory in 2006, when she proved that Liverpool council, and Mr Prescott, had acted illegally and gone beyond their statutory powers in sanctioning the acquisition and demolition of 370 Edwardian and Victorian properties, including hers, in the Edge Lane West area.
By fighting, Ms Pascoe defined the front line in the war on one of the most oppressive aspects of the whole New Labour era. Her local MP, Jane Kennedy, defined it to the first public inquiry as ‘social cleansing’ — shortly afterwards she lost her job as health minister. By winning, Ms Pascoe also raised the hopes of little bands fighting similar schemes across the Midlands and the North.
The state, in the form of Liverpool council and something called, ironically, the Homes and Communities Agency, had its revenge on Ms Pascoe a couple of weeks ago when she narrowly lost her latest battle in the high court. The officials who blundered last time had found a piece of law that said they were entitled to knock down her home and what remains of her community. Mr Justice Ouseley ruled, despite evident misgivings, that there was no error of law this time.
More articles from: Charles Clover | this section
Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit
Advertisement
GASCONY, SW France, near Condom-en-Armagnac 13th Century stone house, 21st Century luxury for 12 in 5 en-suites. 50 acres +
IF YOU ARE PLANNING A CHAMPAGNE RECEPTION and looking for some light entertainment, you can now hire London's busiest steel
BOSC LEBAT, SW France. Only 45 minutes from Toulouse Airport with daily flights from most provincial airports avoiding the horrors
Spectator Business | Apollo Magazine
Corporate | Advertising | Privacy | Terms
Spectator, 22 Old Queen Street, London, SW1H 9HP
All Articles and Content Copyright ©2009 by The Spectator | All Rights Reserved
Ken Bishop
April 9th, 2009 9:34am Report this commentSadly, Liverpoool is demolishing thousands more houses like Pascoe's. Many are tiny, many are large, many are in horrible condition, many are not. But all have stood long enough to make it clear that they are well built. They are to be replaced by flats (less privacy, more neighbour problems), even though the newly built flats all along the waterfront are proving unsaleable. When we we ever learn?
BrianSJ
April 9th, 2009 10:59am Report this commentIt is such a shame we don't have a Conservative opposition.
Leah Owens
April 9th, 2009 11:48am Report this commentThis is not about 'renewal' other than the demolishing of history and remaking the area in Zanulabour's own image. When a country has no historical references then its history is, in effect, negated, forgotten and rewritten. Mao Tse Tung did this - albeit on a larger scale - during the Great Leap Forward, razing the beautiful buildings of old China to the ground. This vile Government is going about it in a more piecemeal way, but its purpose is the same.
Sidney Chambers
April 9th, 2009 3:30pm Report this commentThis is typical of modern Britains juggernaut authoritarian attitude to the man in the street. Free speach has gone, you can be fined for describing a road worker as a Pikey. The police are just Yobs in uniform who have been given too much power and are obviously drunk on it. So keen to club the public at the first oppotunity. The saddest thing I heard recently was from of a wartime Wellington bomber pilot who said "If I had known what this country would turn into I wouldn't have bothered". Mrs Pascoe deserves an award for services to the public, but no, the head of the banking system will get it instead. The system is corrupt.
LiverpoolTory
April 9th, 2009 3:58pm Report this commentThere are many houses in Liverpool which are in an absolutely appalling state. They are so dilapidated that it is impossible to view with any sense of admiration for the Georgian, Victorian or Edwardian architecture. This makes them slums of squalor and crime. Ultimately some housing should be knocked down in Liverpool to make way for new flats. These will be expensive with less living space but thats what you get with a rising population. Hopefully, it will get people living back in the city again and offset the inexcusable urban sprawl which is destroying our countryside.
jon livesey
April 10th, 2009 12:39am Report this commentTo me, the issue is wider than homes. The fact is that we have inherited laws that were written to be sweeping in their scope because that was safe in an age when the Civil Service was aware of the proper limits to the exercise of power, and the proper relationship of the Civil Service to the citizen.
Today we have a civil Service that exemplifies the arrogance of ignorance, and which tends towards the exercise of arbitrary powers simply to keep those powers in existence.
Today's Civil Service may not be very bright, have very much self-control, or understand its basic mission, but it does understand that powers must be used, otherwise they can decay away.
Expect to see yet more exercise of arbitrary powers in wider areas by Civil Servants and their legal representatives who are simply interested in keeping those powers in existence.
Tom Norton
April 10th, 2009 10:32pm Report this commentZanulabour disaster area - again.
Forlornehope
April 11th, 2009 10:47am Report this commentInterestingly, the same problem exists in the land of the free, but for a different reason. In the USA you can have your house taken "for the public good". This has been interpreted by t he courts as any economic development. So if someone wants to build a supermarket you lose your house. It happens and you have no comeback.
Gervas Douglas
April 11th, 2009 11:06pm Report this commentDon't expect the likes of David Cameron to do anything about these glaring injustices. There is no real constitutional opposition at present, just a bunch of opportunists hoping to grab the trappinhs of office by default.
Archie
April 12th, 2009 8:11am Report this commentSidney Chambers: My parents had a beautiful and historic piece of their property in the Midlands compulsorily purchased for a road widening scheme to provide access to a "redevelopment" by a friend of a councillor. No surprise then my father and an uncle, who both fought in WWII, are now staunch BNP members for exactly the reasons in your article.
Peter Kemp
April 12th, 2009 10:55am Report this commentAs a foreigner and regular visitor to your country I am not surprised by these actions.They are simply designed
to replace old traditional England with something that will accommodate the continuous
stream of old empire hopefuls that add very little to your economy yet continually want to change your culture and way of life.Take back England!!
Cisco
April 13th, 2009 2:20pm Report this commentThe really sad thing is, the road in question, Edge Lane, does not need widening. Granted, the area does need sprucing up, but this is more to do with the spitefulness of a landowner who is letting large areas of Edge Lane (including a fair sized retail park) fall into decay because the local council wont let him have his own way with redevelopment. The council aren't falling over themselves to compulsorily purchase any of his acres of property.
Back to top