
All those who believe Gaza is in need of more international aid should be aware of what has now happened twice to summer camps for children in Gaza that are run by the UN. Foreign Policy magazine reports:
Last night, 25 armed, masked men set fire to a U.N. summer camp at a beach in Nuseirat, Gaza, destroying inflatable pools and tents and roughing up a group of guards protecting the facility. It was the second attack on a U.N. recreation facility in just over a month. On May 23, a group of 30 masked, armed men set fire to another U.N. summer camp facility under construction in Gaza City. They also threatened to kill the U.N.'s top relief official in Gaza.
U.N. officials told Turtle Bay they don't know who attacked the recreation facilities but they suspect the vandals are Islamic extremists who object to programs that allow boys and girls to jointly swim, play volleyball, and learn about the arts, theater and other cultural activities.
This is yet another example of what I wrote about in the Daily Mail the other week – that the principle behind international aid programmes, that humanitarian assistance must be delivered regardless of the political situation because human need transcends politics or war, is totally flawed. All too often that aid is hijacked, trashed or used to prolong and deepen war or repression. In respect of Gaza, Barry Rubin makes a further related and salutary observation:
Prior to turning over the Gaza Strip to rule by the Palestinian Authority in 1994, Israel at times tried to resettle the refugees in new housing. This step was not only opposed by the PLO—which wanted to keep the refugees in temporary housing until their triumphant return to a Palestine built on the smoldering remains of a destroyed Israel—but by a UN resolution. And so Israel abandoned the effort.
The Palestinian Authority (PA) ruled the Gaza Strip for more than a dozen years and received lavish aid funding, some of it specifically earmarked for new housing. But it was PA policy never to move refugees into new housing, for the same reason as before. Their suffering was good propaganda abroad and also was intended to keep the refugees in a dissatisfied state of mind so they would support continuing the battle until total victory and be willing to sacrifice their lives for the cause.
So why do refugees in the Gaza Strip and West Bank live in refugee camps today? For the same reason that there is no Palestinian state: Because of decisions made by the Palestinian leadership, both nationalist and Islamist.
Absurdly (and totally in character) John Ging, the director of operations for the U.N. Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees, has reacted to the trashing of the summer camps by saying that the attacks provided
‘...further evidence, if that were needed, of the urgency to change the circumstances on the ground that are generating such extremism.’
Those ‘circumstances on the ground’ are the presence of Hamas. It is Hamas that has to be isolated and defeated if a start is to be made in slowing down the rate of extremism. But that’s not what Ging means. What he means is the idiotic mantra mouthed by the UN, Britain America and the EU who all chant in brainwashed chorus that Israel must not only allow in yet more humanitarian aid but also – increasingly – bring in Hamas from the cold.
In other words, the way to stop more extremism being generated in Gaza is -- to provide more aid, encouragement and legitimacy to the extremists. That is what the UN, Britain, the US and EU are all now doing – supporting the extremism which makes the lives of Gaza’s Arabs such a misery. At the same time they blame Israel, the principal state victim of that extremism, for that misery; and have now even forced it to open up the channels of that western support, with the result that yet more Israelis will also be attacked.
The implacable resolution with which the bien-pensant western world persists in this mad inversion of reality is truly terrifying – and is one of the main reasons why the bad people are winning.
Blogs: Martin Bright | Susan Hill | Alex Massie | Coffee House | Faith Based
Actions: Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (38)
Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit
Advertisement
1 The danger for the Lib Dems - James Forsyth
2 Ignore the European Court and deport Abu Qatada tonight - Douglas Murray
3 The strange survival of Labour England - Fraser Nelson
1 Ignore the European Court and deport Abu Qatada tonight - Douglas Murray (82)
2 Don’t let’s be beastly to the bankers - Fraser Nelson (71)
3 An Israeli strike on Iran? - Daniel Korski (66)
4 We must be honest about honour killings - William Maxwell (55)
5 The government will have to fight for Lords reform - James Forsyth (39)
Melanie Phillips is a Daily Mail columnist. She also writes for the Jewish Chronicle and is a panellist on BBC Radio Four's Moral Maze. Her most recent book is 'The World Turned Upside Down: The Global Battle over God, Truth and Power', published by Encounter.
For a complete set of Melanie's articles click here
Are you making the right impression?
1,700 Unusual Christmas Presents Request Catalogue 01935 815 195 Quote SPEC10 for 10% discount www.presentfinder.co.uk
Pimilco based Florist with online ordering Web: www.olivebranch.net Tel: 020 7630 1868 Fax: 020 7233 8844
Apollo Magazine | Corporate | Advertising | Privacy | Terms
Spectator, 22 Old Queen Street, London, SW1H 9HP
All Articles and Content Copyright ©2012 by The Spectator | All Rights Reserved
Bill Rees
June 29th, 2010 3:50pmWith information like this now so widely disseminated over the Internet, you would hope that international perceptions of Hamas would surely change.
Or am I being foolishly optimistic?
Si, N
June 29th, 2010 4:02pm'Hamas torches children's summer camps'???
Hamas have condemned these attacks and vowed to apprehend those responsible.
Flakey
John
June 29th, 2010 4:10pmNo they are 'peace campaigners' don't you know anything?
Vandoren
June 29th, 2010 4:11pmMelanie what you think about new EU and British steps in Jerusalem? I mean news about EU hires British firm Saladin Security to train special Palestinian unit to be deployed in east Jerusalem?
Si, N
June 29th, 2010 4:14pmInteresting...my post was edited
AussieMark
June 29th, 2010 4:15pmI would be willing to bet that Hamas is responsible for destroying the UN Summer Camp. The UN and Hamas are running competing camps in Gaza this summer, and I don’t think Hamas appreciates the lack of “religious”, “cultural” and “technology” activities in the UN Camps. “Religious” activities of course is the teaching of radical Islamic ideology (Jihad), the “cultural” activities is teaching hatred of Jews and Israel, and the “technology” activities is military (terrorist) training on how to kill Jews (eg suicide bombings, firing rockets, etc). For a taste of what the kiddies get up to in the Hamas camps, take a look at this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Wq4QwiMEbY&feature=player_embedded
There is also an interesting background report about the summer camps:
http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/html/hamas_e004.htm
David, Thailand
June 29th, 2010 4:17pmQuite clearly the UN is not doing enough for the poor sods.
David, Thailand
AussieMark
June 29th, 2010 4:24pmSomething that’s a bit off topic, but still related to Israel. Last week Al Jazeera Television interviewed the Indonesian Justice and "Human Rights" minister Patrialis Akbar. In this interview, Akbar encouraged Jemaah Islamiyah terrorists not to commit attacks in Indonesia, but rather to commit attacks in Israel! Akbar said he would support the terrorists by funding them, supplying weapons, and even supporting the families they leave behind in Indonesia. The interview can be seen here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soLLd4vfWvw
I cant work out why the media have ignored this story...
Augustus
June 29th, 2010 4:32pmAs George w. Bush once cynically remarked, 'Don't confuse me with the facts'. And the fact is that Hamas is a fundamentalist terrorist organization, and is listed as such by the US, Great Britain, Canada, Australia, Japan, Israel
and the EU. So what Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov thinks he can achieve by talking to them, God only knows.
In 2009 alone Hamas received over 2 billion dollars in international aid, but none of that money was spent on infrastructure, schools or hospitals. All they can do is to blame Israel for blocking imports of medicines and food, and tell the media about the rotten Zionist occupier. The fact that Israel pulled out of Gaza five years ago is forgotten. And that Gaza also has a border with Egypt, who sealed the border, is also conveniently forgotten. And the fact that Egypt got so fed up with the smuggling of everything
except food and medicines, and
gassed a number of tunnels killing seven Palestinians, is also something you don't hear about. No, it's Israel who are the bandits.
Day and night Hamas media broadcast how Israel will be destroyed. How the great Zionist cancer will be eliminated, and how terrible the Jews are.
Funny then how every morning at 4am a miracle takes place. Thousands of Gazans assemble in rows at the border controls to go and work in Israel. Because Hanmas won't employ them, and neither will Egypt. Only those rotten Jews will do that. Naturally, Hamas has tried to
'reinforce' the rows of workers with suicide bombers. Explosives in cheese, in the bread rolls, in bottles of drink, and even in medicine bottles. Pregnant women have been laid on stretchers covered in explosives, and toddlers got explosives strapped to their bodies, just to get entry into Israel. And If the Israeli soldiers decide to check these pregnant women, a video is soon made and posted on YouTube, so that the whole world can see how
cruel the Israelis are.
And they came up with more ideas
and decided to call for an embargo on all goods manufactered in occupied territories. Only they forgot one thing: Who actually worked in those factories producing the goods? Yes, that's right! The Palestinians themselves!
Baron
June 29th, 2010 5:11pmSi, N @ 4.02:
if you believe that Hamas didn’t know about the destruction, or more likely orchestrated it, you must also believe the earth’s flat, is that it?
Hamas may be everything but stupid they ain’t. A mouse wouldn’t make a move in Gaza without them knowing about it. On this point, Melanie’s dead right. Hamas’s the culprit, the Palestinian’s unwashed the victims, the bunch of the international do-gooders the mugs. What’s new then?
Adam B.
June 29th, 2010 7:22pmYes Sin, we should of course believe every word from an antisemitic racist fundamentalist Islamist neo-Nazi terror group.
It's those Jews you have to look out for.
blue_&_white_avenger
June 29th, 2010 7:49pmRegarding Ging's stupid statement (again), there are others following a similar path. The British commander in Afghanistan (who is currently overall commander until the US Congress approves MaChrystal's replacement) expressed his personal opinion that it was time to talk to the Taleban. Is this logical? I thought that the Taleban are against (strongly against) women's rights, women's education & all the good things on which Western democracy is based.
Like Ging, talking to these people - rather than destroying them - legitimises them in the eyes of their supporters and those who have reservations.
What's happened to "unconditional surrender"?
Shaun Harbord
June 29th, 2010 8:27pmLike it or not, and you plainly do not like it, Hamas is elected.
John Edwards
June 29th, 2010 8:27pmReferring to the Palestinians in Gaza as "Gaza's Arabs" doesn't make them any less Palestinian than those in the West Bank or in occupied East Jerusalem.
This story underlines the need to stop blocking the creation of a national unity government and to put the Palestinian Authority back together.
Charlene Hale
June 29th, 2010 9:19pmWell done Melanie for reporting the cold hard facts which our politicians, the media and lefties will not dare whisper let alone speak. How evil that Israel is being constantly castigated, blamed and vilified, while the real villains hide behind the UN, EU, the West ect. It is more than grotesque and proves just how the West has lost the plot.
Gábor Fränkl
June 29th, 2010 9:37pmShaun Harbord, Hitler was "elected" too. Quite democratically. What's your point?
Linda Smith
June 29th, 2010 11:06pm"This story underlines the need to stop blocking the creation of a national unity government and to put the Palestinian Authority back together."
Silly John Edwards, "national unity government"? Hamas and Fatah are blocking it themselves; they hate each other.
JOHN ROOSEVELT
June 30th, 2010 8:39amShaun Harbord
June 29th, 2010 8:27pm
Like it or not, and you plainly do not like it, Hamas is elected"
Yep Shaun. We do indeed reap what we sew, right?
Those poor people of gaza...
GeoffM
June 30th, 2010 9:29amWill the Hamas activists get a "Firestarter" badge now they have burnt down the summer camps?
Seriously, it is interesting just how much news, like this, is "censored" in the West.
I also never cease to be amazed at how much stuff that directly affects the UK never sees the light of day.
I now find myself watching channels like Russia Today, Fox News and France 24 to see what is actually happening in the UK.
Last week Fox News showed EXACTLY what happened in Barking, Essex with muslims insulting and abusing returning troops. None of that footage was shown on UK television.
No debate was held and no action taken.
Margaret Muller-Johansson
June 30th, 2010 9:33amThe muslims are wrecking their countries all the time even children camps are not safe anymore, I wonder what those Islamic extremist butt kissing leftist think about this? like George Galloway etc etc.
Adam B.
June 30th, 2010 2:59pmShaun, so were the Nazis - your point being?
Throwing the Fatah members to their deaths from the rooftops isn't exactly democratic. Neither is shutting down any free press, the torture chambers operated by Hamas and lack of independent judiciary. Could you tell me when the next general election is to be held?
Are YOU happy they were elected?
Adam B.
June 30th, 2010 3:00pmEdwards, East Jeruslams doesn't exist. The Old City does. Since when has the Jewish quarter of the city been "occupied" - by...the Jews?
James E McMullen III
June 30th, 2010 4:40pmWhat great family values these people have. It is so nice to know that something like this can come across our southern border.
Pyrus
June 30th, 2010 6:11pmI think you're certainly being optimistic Bill.
Though at times it's difficult to understand why so often it is Israel that is condemned in the strongest terms.
The most concise argument I've heard in favour of redressing the balance is as follows:
“It is also indisputably the case, as has often been said, that if Hamas, Hezbollah, and the rest were to lay down their arms, there would be peace in Palestine, while if Israel were to lay down her arms, the Israelis would be slaughtered.”
source: http://www.takimag.com/article/taking_israels_side
Eldarus
June 30th, 2010 6:14pmThey call themself "brave freedom fighters" fighting behind childrens back, killing innocent civilians and destroying summer camps. They ignore all rules of human rights however using those rules very effectivly with propaganda agains Israel.
C.Gee
June 30th, 2010 8:04pmLinda Smith @ June 29th, 2010 11:06pm:
You are quite right.
I am always amused when phrases like "national unity government" are used in connection with the Palestinians. "Democratically elected" is also a thigh-slapper, along with "civil infrastructure", "civil rights", and "security forces."
The terms of reasoned Western political discourse sit about as well on the Palestinians as dress-up clothes from Mommy's closet do on children. So cute.
Augustus
June 30th, 2010 9:43pmIt seems to have escaped some people's notice that political parties form coalitions after elections. And that's exactly what Hamas and Fatah did, until Hamas threw Fatah out of Gaza and took control. Btw, Hamas isn't a true political party, but an extremist organization with an extremist ideology, which holds that Jews are cursed by Allah and must be destroyed in order to attain the Muslim 'End Times' prophecy.
Baron
June 30th, 2010 10:55pmShaun Harbord @ 8.27:
so were the communist thugs in the East, you liked it then?
the ordinary hoi polloi in Gaza and the West Bank face a dilemma totally akin to that of the great unwashed of the East before communism collapsed there. About two years before 1989, a high power bunch of UN deluded appeaseniks, similar to those pretending to know how the ordinary Palestinians feel, visited what’s now the Czech Republic. They walked around, talked to people and reported how ‘happy, content and in tune with the Party’ the locals were.
Not more than a couple of years after the visit, and few months after the Red Menace got booted out and free democratic parties allowed to campaign, the candidates of by then the supposedly reformed Commies got less than 20% of the national vote.
during the ‘free’ election in Gaza and the West Bank only two ‘parties’ were participating. One that campaigned to destroy Israel slowly, the other to accomplish the same aim with greater urgency. How could anyone in the West who regards oneself as a democrat fall for it beggars belief.
Tony Allwright
July 1st, 2010 11:38amQUOTE: An American envoy is scheduled to meet with Hamas representatives in an Arab country and hand them a letter from the Obama Administration. UNQUOTE
Why is it no longer shocking, or even surprising, to learn that the White House may be trying to cosy up, in secret, to an avowed genocidal terrorist organization?
When even the American President gives the impression of being on the side of Hamas, it is hard to imagine a pretty outcome for Israel.
Can anyone disprove the linked story, which is dated 25th June?
Carl
July 1st, 2010 2:11pmAdam B, according to commentators in Haartez who know a great deal more about the region than you do, not only does East Jerusalem exist but it is the rightful Palestinian Capital. These are Jewish commentators, living in Israel, not wannabees.
Augustus
July 1st, 2010 4:15pmCarl - Do you mean the Eastern part, including the old city centre, which the Jordanians annexed in 1950, proceeding to destroy all Jewish possessions and holy places before banning them from re-entry, despite agreements reached at the cease-
fire of the War of Independence?
I bet you would have loved to have had a whip hand in that!
Adam B.
July 1st, 2010 4:27pmI see Carl.
I that the same level-headed Haaretz whose editor said that Israel needs a "good raping"?
You, Carl, have clearly never been to Jerusalem. If you had, you would know that there is no distict entity of East Jerusalem. There is the Old and the New City. The Old City includes the Jewish and Armenian Quarters. I would be most interested to learn from you when these became exclusively "Palestinian"? "Palestine" as never existed, it was never an independent entity, and never had a capital. Indeed, Palestinian nationalism was invented in 1967.
By the way, do you still refuse to condemn Hamas, the antisemitic racist terror group which advocates the extermination of every living Jew?
JOHN ROOSEVELT
July 1st, 2010 9:00pmIs it true that Carl supports the Armenian claim to Jerusalem and that Turkey is supporting them?
JOHN ROOSEVELT
July 1st, 2010 9:02pmSeriously, Carl, take a look at Dore Gold's "Fight for Jerusalem".
Bob, son of Bob
July 2nd, 2010 3:14pm"and is one of the main reasons why the bad people are winning."
The Western leaders know exactly what they are doing with all this aid money. They are either bad people like the Liberals or Labour or have given up and let the bad ones get on with it. That is why foreign aid is ring-fenced, it is part of the corrupt left.
We have full democracy, but because the masses are so easily deceived they have placed bad people in power. The foolish have voted for the wicked.
As for the Palestinians - their average age is 15, the money per head from aid is astronomical so we can hardly expect rational behaviour. If they get what they want, however, their VIP status will vanish overnight as did that of the blacks of Zimbabwe. The left are only interested in destruction, then they move on.
Ken-in-CA
July 6th, 2010 3:13amPretty sneaky, those Jews! The 25 armed, masked men who set fire to the U.N. summer camp must have been landed on the beach by an Israeli submarine.
John Mc Donald
July 9th, 2010 1:24pmI wonder when the government of Israel will finally wake up and begin to understand the depth of feeling which Israels actions are creating world wide. Israel cannot continue with it's present failed policies and actions and expect the world to love it.
Gaza must get International support to rebuild it's shattered people never mind it's infrastructure or kids summer camps.
Adam B.
July 9th, 2010 3:03pmJohn McDonald, Gaza gets more international support than any comparable territory. They get more aid than any sub-Saharan African country, despite the need not being nearly as great.
Israel only operates a partial blockade against an entity hellbent on killing Jews. It does this legally, and to protect itself. Thousands of Palestinians receive free medical treatment in Israel, and every week, thousands of tonnes of goods enter Gaza from Israel. Egypt on the other hand operates a total blockade, and gives Gaza precisely nothing. Hamas fire rockets into Israel, not Egypt.
Go figure.