RSS

Contact us

Friday 9 January 2009

Best left in the attic

Matthew Bourne’s Dorian Gray
Sadler’s Wells

Unfortunately, what could have been two great dramatic threads get totally lost under an overwhelming amount of superficial padding. The narrative, therefore, never goes beyond the click-and-tell dimension of a gossip magazine, packing in stereotype after stereotype. The theoretically pivotal character of Lady H (Michela Meazza), Bourne’s female equivalent of Wilde’s Lord Henry, is too Sex and the City meets The Devil Wears Prada to gain any dramatic depth; similarly, the male ballet dancer Dorian falls in love with, another of Bourne’s gender-twisting interventions on the original story, is too much of a camp caricature of the proverbial ballet ‘queen’; thus his tragedy, the first to hit Dorian’s gilded life, has little or no dramatic impact. He dies like Juliet in MacMillan’s Romeo and Juliet — references to which are made both musically and choreographically — after a scene that draws upon the graphic sensationalism favoured by most soap operas when dealing with drug issues.

In Bourne’s usual style, all sorts of in-jokes fill what is a messy canvas badly in need of some drastic editing. Unfortunately, the more highbrow ones, such as Dorian’s visit to the Royal Opera or his radio alarm clock blurting excerpts from Tchaikovsky’s Sleeping Beauty, come across as a repeat of far more hilariously effective ones seen in previous and more engaging works of his. As for the more lowbrow ones, including a spoof of Tonight with Jonathan Ross, they are so lame that they failed to elicit laughter at a Saturday matinee. By the time the second act begins all the clever ideas have run out of steam. The action becomes choreographically repetitive and dramaturgically garbled. Despite the haunting presence of the dopplegänger, Dorian’s descent into hell is hell to watch and digest. No trick is spared. Blood, rape, zombies, the smothering of the haunting double and a herd of paparazzi feasting on Dorian’s lifeless body turn the last 20 minutes into a whirlpool of wham-bam solutions the scriptwriters of Dallas would have paid good money for.

There is no doubt the click-and-tell approach will make a hit of this work, especially among the various A-level dance and performing arts students who, thanks to the cultural blinkeredness imparted by the flawed syllabi they study, will find it daringly innovative. Not to mention the success it will likely have among the shock-thirsty inhabitants of puritan-land across the pond. Pity, for somewhere inside all that lurks a potential theatre gem — I only wish it had not been locked up in the attic.

More articles from: Giannandrea Poesio | this section

Print this article  |  Email to a friend  |  Permalink  |   Comments (1)

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Advertisement

Spectator Business | Apollo Magazine

Corporate | Advertising | Privacy | Terms

Spectator, 22 Old Queen Street, London, SW1H 9HP

All Articles and Content Copyright ©2008 by The Spectator | All Rights Reserved