RSS

Contact us

Thursday 4 December 2008

Damp squib

Carmen
Royal Opera House

Suppose they made the transition from whatever delights Deloitte Ignite provided for them and paid their £165 for a ticket, what would they think of, say, the revival of Carmen which is on at present? They would certainly recognise some of the tunes, and might well be exhilarated by the panache with which the conductor Daniel Oren launches into the prelude. When the curtain rises, they’d see the most conventional set for Carmen one could imagine, not a whiff of creativity (‘Say that word again! I love it!’ as the potential employer says to the applicant in a great Biff cartoon) about it, just sun-drenched Spain, a shaky orange tree, a donkey, and plenty of hip-swinging passers-by. Tanya McCallin’s designs are of a piece with Francesca Zambello’s production, blatantly intended for a succession of performers to fit in with without any special instructions, unless they are up to abseiling down the cliff in Act III. One almost sympathises with Sally Potter in her attempt to make it new with ENO’s production last autumn. ‘Don’t come back, but 10 per cent is forgiven,’ I felt like saying about that absurdity.

Oren’s conducting is, apart from occasional spurts, so lethargic that it became a question whether we would ever see Carmen, as the afternoon sun brought things to a virtual standstill. When she arrived, she did nothing to raise anyone’s emotional temperature. This may have been the most undersung Habanera I have heard. And nothing in Nancy Fabiola Herrera’s performance erased the impression that it had no place in an international house. Even the Card Song, which is so impressive as almost to defy a performer to mess it up, just passed as a piece of slow, low singing, punctuated by the giggles of Carmen’s friends — they sang and acted very well, as did Don José’s colleagues.

Marcelo Alvarez was suffering from a feverish cold on the opening night, but that didn’t prevent him from giving the best performance I have seen from him for a long time. He is not an idiomatic singer, he might as well have been singing Canio. But he is heartfelt, and he gave a lovely account of the Flower Song, ending it with breathtaking quietness. In the last scene, a tricky one because it is dramatically so tense, yet musically and verbally rather diffuse, he and Herrera achieved no more rapport than they had the rest of the evening. As so often in this strange opera, the short exchanges between Carmen and Escamillo before he goes into the bullring were the most intimate moments. Kyle Ketelsen, the toreador, was even more upstaged by the magnificent horse he appeared on than his predecessors have been. The one singer who had everything was Susan Gritton, a Micaela who sang the whole part ravishingly and did what she could to make a non-role into a living character. For once the pathetic and the good were far more interesting and moving than the amoral and the swaggering, and how often can you say that?

More articles from: Michael Tanner | this section

Print this article  |  Email to a friend  |  Permalink  |   Comment

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Advertisement

Spectator Business | Apollo Magazine

Corporate | Advertising | Privacy | Terms

Spectator, 22 Old Queen Street, London, SW1H 9HP

All Articles and Content Copyright ©2008 by The Spectator | All Rights Reserved