Clemency suggests

Email registration

Free weekly email update

Great products and special offers for Spectator readers

Click here for great value reader offers and events

Click here for the latest Spectator Wine Offers

Slump fever

Lloyd Evans

Wednesday, 30th April 2008

Gone With the Wind
New London Theatre

How did they get it so wrong? Turning chicklit’s greatest story into a hit musical should have been a doddle. Just put the characters on stage and let the warm romantic breeze of the narrative carry you safely home. And that’s exactly what Trevor Nunn has done and yet the critics have misinterpreted Gone with the Wind and denounced it as a flop. I’m baffled. At last week’s Saturday matinée I joined a sell-out crowd and saw a handsome gutsy version of a completely captivating novel. Never mind the timeless magic of the storyline, look at the performances. Jill Paice is a brittle, beautiful cracker of a Scarlett and Darius Danesh’s Rhett has all that’s required, devilish eyes, a sonorous voice, a lot of slicked black hair and something extra too, the god-like swagger of a young Sean Connery. And Natasha Yvette Williams, playing Mammy, has a voice with a kick as powerful as Aretha’s. But not everything’s perfect. The opening song is a sluggish ensemble number so the show hits the ground dawdling. And there are too many melodies crammed into the 215-minute running time. Some should go, but which ones? Songs between the stars? No. The audience wants the stars. Songs by lesser characters? No. That’ll upset the dressing-room. Best solution is to keep it as it is and make that a selling point. Yes, it’s sprawling, it’s kitsch and it’s cumbersome but that’s the idea.

1 | 2 | 3 Next page

More articles from: Lloyd Evans | this section

Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (1)

Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Katharine Moffitt

May 5th, 2008 8:56pm

Why does not one of the (all) unfavorable reviews I have read of this musical mention the previous effort. I don't remember whether it was 1972 or 1974 - I visited London both times from America with my late mother. I was in my 20's and do not remember much about the production except that it was performed at the Drury Lane Theatre and was also universally panned by the critics - it lasted a very brief time! I must disagree with the author; I think turning 'Gone With the Wind' into a musical is a dreadful idea - that was my and my mother's reaction in the early '70's. Perhaps someday someone will manage it - after all, I was certainly wrong about 'Les Miserables'!!

Making sense

Ursula Buchan

If your ears go back, like a frightened horse, at the word ‘conceptualism’ when applied to modern art, you may not be very pleased to know that this is a hot topic in landscape design at the moment.

Value for money

Alan Judd

How far will the proposed road tax changes influence what we actually buy in the new car market? Not as much, perhaps, as the government likes to think.