Michael Henderson suggests

Email registration

Free weekly email update

Great products and special offers for Spectator readers

Click here for great value events

Click here for exclusive articles, offers, tasting notes and discussion

Three in the park

Michael Tanner

Wednesday, 30th July 2008

La Gioconda; Pulcinella; Iolanta
Opera Holland Park

Orla Boylan, who is one of the most consistently radiant presences in our opera houses, but never seems to become the star she deserves to be, is wonderful in the title role, singing as securely and warmly as a Tchaikovsky heroine needs to, while also being as fragile and vulnerable; her palpations are convincing, too, though it takes the loving Vaudemont, just as well portrayed by Peter Auty, an unconscionable time to realise why they are required. Iolanta’s father the King, sung with authentic Slav boom by Mikhail Svetlov, has some of the score’s least satisfactory music, but makes a lot of it. Mark Stone enjoys his rollicking relationship with Vaudemont, an odd feature of the work. At OHP nowadays we get star casting in minor roles. This piece hardly needed a makeweight, but it was preceded by a sprightly account of Stravinsky’s eternally mischievous Pulcinella. I am unfortunately wholly immune to the charms of ballet, but the playing and singing here was just as good, and made for a rich, lengthy evening.

The previous evening was Ponchielli’s La Gioconda, which has happily never been a popular work in the UK, but which was of course the vehicle of Callas’s international debut in 1947, and has altogether been treated far better than it deserves, with astounding arrays of stars lavished on its nonsensical inconsequentiality. It’s hard to believe that Boito, librettist of Verdi’s last two operas, produced this ramshackle piece in which there are too many characters and almost no motives among them. Oddly, at its centre is also a blind woman, for whom the eponymous heroine her daughter will endure anything and has to. The veteran Nuala Willis acted strongly as La Cieca, perhaps she really did have her eyes closed: and sang her number with warmth. Gweneth-Ann Jeffers as the heroine sang and acted intensely, too, but wobbling seemed to be a family affliction. The production of James Clutton seems to go out of its way to be ‘authentic’, though since there are no props onstage they can’t be clutched, but the air does suffer a lot of that treatment. The finest singing by far came from the two wicked men, Barnaba the spy, whose final growl should be recorded for posterity, it could make Olafur Sigurdarson a star; and the Alvise of David Soar, who has a bass of major quality which, if the part had permitted, he could have mesmerised us with. Once again there were no weak links in the casting, but Peter Robinson’s conducting could well have been tighter, though he persuaded the orchestra to do the Dance of the Hours with the requisite sleazy abandon.