Pete suggests

Email registration

Free weekly email update

Great products and special offers for Spectator readers

Click here for great value reader offers and events

Click here for the latest Spectator Wine Offers

House of Meetings

Back to top form

Martin Amis
Cape, 198pp, £15.99, ISBN 0224076094
Buy this book at Amazon.co.uk

Simon Baker

Thursday, 28th September 2006

If you are a fairly successful writer, among the privileged ten per cent or so, your novels are reviewed. If, however, you are a superlatively successful one, often considered to be the voice of a generation, then such is the level of interest that even your reviews are reviewed. The following, from John Sutherland’s recent book, How to Read a Novel, concerns a now famous evocation by Tibor Fischer in his review of Martin Amis’s Yellow Dog (2003):

The abuse (it could hardly be called literary criticism) was published in the Daily Telegraph and widely reprinted, creating less a pre- emptive strike than a kicking to death of a novel in the womb … Somehow the image of the uncle wanking in the schoolyard was unexpungeable.

Martin Amis’s fame as a novelist is such that the lexical equivalent of a Russian doll exists around his work; I am a critic referring to the comments of a critic on the comments of a critic on the merits of a novel.

Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comment | Apollo Art Books