Not a scandal but a textbook success
Ross Butler says MPs’ criticisms of the sell-off of theformer Defence Research Agency are financially naive
That change in QinetiQ’s profile boosted its value to more than £1.3 billion at flotation, making the stake retained by the government worth £800 million. But the National Audit Office was concerned that more money might have been raised from the 2003 sale to Carlyle. The reasoning smacks of hindsight, and misses the vital point that QinetiQ found a private equity partner capable of taking the company towards success. Since the government remained the majority shareholder after the Carlyle deal, extracting the highest possible price at that stage to the exclusion of future growth considerations would have been shortsighted. As a result of Carlyle’s investment, QinetiQ is a fundamentally different business, and today’s valuation bears no relation to that of its pre-Carlyle era.
Two other findings from the National Audit Office inquiry stuck in the Committee’s throat. The first is that Carlyle reduced its offer price after being offered an ‘exclusive’ negotiating position in the 2003 auction. Whether Carlyle’s late price reduction — relating to pensions liabilities and an unsigned supplier agreement — could have been resisted is unclear, although one suspects that UBS investment bankers are not pushovers. What is clear is such hardball tactics are part of everyday life in the world of corporate deals. In attempting to second-guess decisions made in the thick of intense negotiations, the Committee has proven itself the real innocent. But the aspect of the privatisation that the MPs found hardest to stomach was the sheer amount of money made by senior management. By any normal standards, it is astonishing: the top ten managers invested £540,000 between them in 2003; it turned into £107 million at the flotation in 2006.
More articles from: Ross Butler | this section
Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit
Advertisement
Is gold still a safe haven?
Matthew LynnIngots are just another commodity
City Life
Robert Beaumont
At last, a fine statue of Brian Clough — but still not even a plaque for Jesse Boot
The global currency crisis is still to come
Jonathan RufferJonathan Ruffer argues that state bail-outs in response to the credit crunch could lead to yet another massive shock: a widespread collapse of currencies, and a new inflation
Any Other Business
Martin Vander Weyer
The ticking parcel I failed to spot and the oil-price prediction I got spot on
New Deal economics: lessons from Herbert Hoover
Bill JamiesonBill Jamieson says calls for a Rooseveltian New Deal to stave off US recession are misinformed; it was FDR’s much-maligned predecessor who set the course for recovery
Can London be turned around like a troubled company?
Judi BevanJudi Bevan meets Tim Parker, the controversial private-equity player who slashed jobs and boosted value at Kwik-Fit and the AA, and is about to apply his skills at City Hall
Will the wisdom of Warren Buffett translate into German?
Matthew LynnMatthew Lynn wonders whether the world’s greatest investor will be able to pick winners in continental Europe the way he has for more than four decades in the US
The new ‘special relationship’: between London and New York
Michael BloombergMichael Bloomberg, the Mayor of New York, unveils his new partnership with Boris, and their plans to forge a transatlantic alliance between the two greatest cities on earth to promote state-of-the-art public policy, cultural links and economic prosperity
Latest blog posts
sponsored links
Sky - Official Site
Build your own Sky package online. Sky TV, Broadband & Talk only £17.
Free Sky Digital Offer - Order Now
Subscribe to Sky from £16 a month. Get free equipment and free broadband - Join Now. Sky HD - be amongst the first to have it - order now.
Sky - Official Site
Build your own Sky package online. Sky TV, Broadband & Talk only £17.
Free Sky Digital Offer - Order Now
Subscribe to Sky from £16 a month. Get free equipment and free broadband - Join Now. Sky HD - be...
ROME CENTRE
PORTA METRONIA, ROME Standing high on the top of one of the seven hills of Rome- the Coelian- this unique
City Breaks. ROME and PARIS
ROME and PARIS: over 350 holiday rentals apartments listed: visit www.romanreference.com and www.parisreference.com or call +39 0648 903612.
Jewellery. RUFFS (Estd. 1904).
Goldsmiths by Design Welcome to Ruffs! You have found a company of Goldsmiths that specialises in the manufacture, amongst other
Spectator Business | Apollo Magazine
Corporate | Advertising | Privacy | Terms
Spectator, 22 Old Queen Street, London, SW1H 9HP
All Articles and Content Copyright ©2008 by The Spectator | All Rights Reserved
Cogito Ergosum
June 19th, 2008 4:39pmIf the Governement feels it got too little from the deal, that merely matches their disdain for the scientific skills which propelled the company.
If they really valued scientists and engineers, they would have kept ownership of the company.
Peter Sugar
June 20th, 2008 2:58amYou are forgetting the large single tender government contract handed down by government for the management of the ranges, just prior to flotation.
You are also forgetting the enormous amount of land that the government allowed QinetiQ to keep and which they sold for cash to fund the purchase of those companies in the USA.
The chairman and people who profiteered did not work for that but were handed all of that on a plate. How could the valuation of the business had been so low escapes everyone and it stinks to high heaven.
The numbers look unbelievable whatever you say about context. The business of this firm today is what it always was a handout from government (UK or US) and the patents and elite scientists they inherited meant that they could not fail. The firm is not as robust as you are describing it for otherwise the share value would be much higher than at flotation prices.