Clemency suggests

Email registration

Free weekly email update

Great products and special offers for Spectator readers

Click here for great value reader offers and events

Click here for the latest Spectator Wine Offers

Global Warning

Theodore Dalrymple

Wednesday, 18th June 2008

Theodore Dalrymple delivers a Global Warning

The last time I played rugby, I was sent off for reading on the field. It was my small satirical protest against the supposition that my character would be much improved by having my knees dragged along icy ground, or my hand trodden into the mud by boys who, by dint of no effort of their own, were twice as large as I. Now I am not so sure. It appears to me that every soul should be tempered a little in the fire of humiliation and suffering: though the precise dose of laudably character-forming humiliation and suffering is, I admit, difficult to estimate and dole out.

In fact, it is impossible, which is why human beings usually turn out badly. Unfortunately, all roads lead to resentment. Too little suffering in childhood means that people resent the difficulties that they inevitably encounter later in life; too much, and no success can extinguish the embers of resentment smouldering in the depths of their souls, ready to burst into flames at the first addition of tinder.

Since my youth, I have developed a visceral distaste for sport, not as an activity for amateurs, but as a spectacle that occupies the thoughts, raises the hopes and stimulates the emotions of millions. I try to understand why it does so, but try as I might, I cannot.

Yesterday, for example, I sat on a train from Paris to Avignon opposite a young man who read a newspaper devoted to football the whole way. (As in all Western European countries, the French championship is about which team can import the best foreigners.) The TGV is fast, but it still takes nearly three hours to go from Paris to Avignon. Can a human mind really be satisfied by such pabulum? (I was irritated: the young man didn’t look by any means unintelligent.) I know that Nature hates a vacuum, but surely not that much.

As it happens, I was reading with enjoyment a slim volume entitled Barbaric Sport: Critique of a Global Plague, by Marc Perelman. The author, an architect by training and a professor of aesthetics by occupation, is a man of the far Left, slightly too young to have taken part in the events of 1968, but who was obviously affected by the slogan, ‘Be realistic: demand the impossible.’ He ends his book with an uncompromising demand for a society without sport. For sport ‘flattens everything in its way’ and is ‘the steam-roller of decadent modernity’.

1 | 2 Next page

More articles from: Theodore Dalrymple | this section

Print this article | Email to a friend | Permalink | Comments (2)

Post this entry to: del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Richard from St. Louis

June 19th, 2008 5:06pm

'What objection can the democratic secularist make?'

Well, you, Mr Dem Secularist, have denied God and removed Him from the lives of people, so naturally, they will seek other gods, like Sport and Mammon and Moloch. Quit your complaining.

Stewart Paterson

June 23rd, 2008 9:04am

Ah, the old canard, life without the God (God is imiganary by the way) is pointless.
Could you explain why so many believers still play sport? Why do people (esp. Americans) thank God for their victories and pray before matches.
Mr Dalrymple, are you also violentlty against sports which pitch the competitor against himself? Like Time Trialing? What of chess? The last time I played chess I was disqualified for playing with a yo-yo, my personal demonstration that it wasn't fair to put me up against others who, by no effort on their part, were clever than me.