Britain is being demolished

Nyal Williams

Why would I subscribe when your teaser beginning of an article is covered up by an ad for an automobile such that I can't even read your teaser?

Nicholas Millman

Simon Thurley's interesting article focusses on urban "re-generation" but fails to mention the "urbanisation" of the rural countryside under this government's watch. Densely packed computer-plotted mini-estates squeeze themselves into even the smallest villages, pavements, kerbstones and railings appear, there are signs everywhere - mirroring the new town hall "Do this, do that" nannyism. New roads weave between blocks of houses with no front gardens, no space. Nowhere it appears have planners or designers got to grips with building in harmony with the rural environment; the beauty of our small towns and villages is being laid waste by blatent greed. And don't let anyone spin that yarn of the need for low-cost housing and more houses; this is not about that. This is about making the most money from development and re-development and disregarding the impact on the visual environment. The very worst kind of short-termism that proliferates in 21st Century corporate Britain.

Herbert Thornton

I already mentioned that I echo what Nyal Williams wrote. The car advert. is irritating.

Now I ask - why do I get a blank page when I try to read Paul Johnson's piece?

One-eye

We ain't seen nothing yet, millions more affordable homes, population 70 million by 2035-50. I dunno, where is all the short term - long term energy to come from to power all of this expansion? I reckon it's all a no brainer. Water availability is probably the biggest potential disaster waiting to happen. Just one long hot summer is all that it will take.

Minnie Ovens

How very true. There are very few post war buildings which live up to their Victorian counterparts. For instance, Chelsea and Kensington is a borough with a split personality Left with some of the most beautiful architecture in Britain it spent decades replacing this with concrete boxes. Yet they also have, at times, left the Victorian facades and rebuilt the interiors. This allows for the best of both worlds.

Laura Fox

You selfish elitist! We have millions of young people unable to afford decent housing! Young couples delaying getting married for not being able to buy, and some times not even rent, a house! A home! Young couples delaying having children, and having to pay exorbitant rents on miniscule flats! In the XXI century! And you, the middle and upper classes, keep talking about “urban sprawl”, “green belts”, or "concreting over the countryside"! Flimsy, pitiful excuse! Less than 2% of British soil is built up! Yes, less than 2%! And in the Southeast less than 4%! If you doubt it, do a proper academic research, but with SOLID data - Don’t just quote each other… Or, just fly over Britain and see for yourselves! You may even fly out of Heathrow or Gatwick, and you will be amazed. The feeling of crowdedness is just consequence of ridiculously low levels of investments, in all areas, but particularly transport, and a criminal planning system. Similar rubbish happened in the 1920s, with the Kensington elites leading a sneering campaign at the then new middle-classes building their family homes in the suburbs. What about the basic human right for SHELTER! Basic! A HOME for my family! I am not demanding any luxury here! You just want to keep your houses prices up! And don’t even have the courage and decency of admitting or even realising it! Talk about “cognitive dissonance”! Repugnant. In many decent countries, when development brings better living standards to the people, the elite is happy with it. I've personally seen it in USA, Italy, Sweden and Netherlands. But Britain? No... Shame on you all! Disgusting!

Natalie Law

Laura Fox - you are the selfish one here. What gives on earth gives you the "right" to a home for "you and your family"? No doubt you also want a garden and bedroom for each of the endless number of children you may want to have, and if you are not in work no doubt you will also expect the state to pay for it. Moreover, the debate is not about stopping development, but the type and method of development. Why do you think the vast failed council estates of the 1960s are now being pulled down? They were also built due to the mistaken propaganda from people like you who demanded new homes be built at all costs. What's wrong with renovating an old home? There are 1 million empty homes in Britain - why don't you get off your backside and renovate one yourself?

gerry

Excellent article with no obscuring advert. Hey guys, you need Firefox's "adblock plus".

Nicholas Millman

Laura, you sound like someone strident and right-on who missed out on buying a home because you spent too long camped outside Greenham Common. Natalie is spot on. This is not about stopping development but about the way it is being done. Perhaps you need to spend more time reading and understanding what people have actually written than shouting, placard waving and name-calling?

Peter York

Simon Hurley makes a good point and appears to be concentrating on the nature of rather than the extent of development. Why have we not been able to create a modern aesthetic which is appreciated?
The tawdry character of our general urban environment appears to be a lack of imagination and lack of care rather than lack of funding.

Roger Inkpen

Housing I agree with Laura Fox. This is all down to nimbyism. Sometimes those who complain about excess development argue that they want better quality homes and towns. Of course we all want this, but if anyone ever hints that some field will be built on, the protests start. If you want better homes, how about coming up with serious proposals, unlike the luddites at CPRE who think we can make do with the odd 2-3 homes built at any one location. We need new towns. No, not dictated by the state, but preferably between the developers and the people who will live there. These need to be planned where are there are decent transport links already, so that you won’t get the situation we have in a new town built between Portsmouth and Southampton, which is already looking like a ghost town just 10 years after being built with its only access from a congested motorway link road. Besides, I don’t understand why all the fuss about the Gorgon’s housing plans. Just like so much else he and his predecessor announced: the integrated transport policy, NHS improvements, better education, environmental changes, it won’t happen as they aren’t capable.

Laura Fox

Natalie and Nicholas,

My husband and I both university graduated. He graduated in 1998 and helped me to graduate in 2003. Since then, in career-starting jobs, we started trying to save for a deposit, and tried to qualify for a mortgage. But as you probably foresaw, from the years of our graduations, the housing market boom has kept ahead of us.

No, we have NEVER used any state benefit, and don't want any either. If we could by a little plot, at normal land price, we could build our own house = home! But planning blocks us from it.