Saturday 17 May 2008

Spectator 180th Anniversary Blog
 

The latest culture as recommended by our staff

Peter Hoskin

Pete suggests


My dream for Turkey, by Boris’s great-grandfather

Wednesday, 23rd April 2008

Norman Stone on the dramatic life and death of Ali Kemal, one-time interior minister of Turkey and our mayoral candidate’s forebear

Boris Johnson is one eighth Turkish. His great-grandfather (there is, if you abstract the fez and the moustache, a family resemblance) was a well-known writer, Ali Kemal (1868–1922) who came, because of his politics, to a tragic end. He knew England very well, and when the British occupied Constantinople for four years at the end of the first world war, he collaborated with them. They had left the Sultan on his throne, and there was a puppet government which controlled a few back-streets. Poor Ali Kemal made the awful mistake of becoming its minister of the interior for some three months. As happens with collaborationist regimes, he quarrelled with his colleagues (there is a very funny scene of this sort, about Vichy France, in Céline’s D’un château l’autre, where Alphonse de Châteaubriant ends up throwing the crockery). Then he spent his time on journalism, and taught at the university: he knew a great deal about literature. But a nationalist resistance built up in the interior (based on Ankara) and when, late in 1922, it triumphed, Ali Kemal did not leave.

It was crazy: the Sultan himself was smuggled out in a British ambulance to Malta, and the Ottoman dynasty was thrown to the four winds. History does not reveal the reasons for Ali Kemal’s staying. At any rate he was picked up, while being shaved at the Grand Cercle d’Orient in the European city — it was the Levantines’ club, and only Turks of a high rank were admitted — and put on a train for trial in Ankara. His captor, Nurettin Pasha, had lost his two sons in the war, and had gone a little mad. Somehow, he allowed a mob to take Ali Kemal off the train at Izmit, the old Nicomedia, and they lynched him. The episode is written up in Louis de Bernières’s Birds Without Wings.

That book is a homage to the Turkey that might have been, with Greeks and Armenians taking their place. Ali Kemal thought that that should have happened. That was why he supported the British, in whom he put his faith. But at the time Lloyd George was really after the partition of Turkey: Greater Greece, Greater Armenia, even an Anglo-Kurdistan, with bits and pieces for the French and the Italians. There would have been a rump Turkey, run by a puppet Sultan. Ali Kemal was the puppet of a puppet. Everyone, including himself, let him down. The story ends, none the less, with some uplift. He had had two wives, one British — hence the Boris connection — and, after her death from childbirth, one Turkish. Boris (and his father, Stanley Johnson) has done him proud. On the Turkish side, there was a boy, Zeki Kuneralp, who was very bright and needed a state scholarship. Kemal Atatürk, the chief target of Ali Kemal’s journalistic attacks, was by then the Turkish equivalent of de Gaulle. He said: give that boy the money. Zeki’s son is now a chief negotiator on the subject Turkey-in-Europe. Another son is a leading publisher.

More articles from: Norman Stone | this section

Subscribe now

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments

Post a comment


Your comment:*

Your name:*

Your email address:*
(We won't publish this)

*Required information

Please click the button only once - your comment will not be published immediately

Charles

April 24th, 2008 8:35am

Just a small point, but Ali Kemal was not lynched. He was, reportedly, killed by women armed with knives and stones en route to the lynching (see NYT online archives article dated 13th Nov 1922). His body was then dragged through the streets before being placed on the scaffold for public view. Gruesome, I know, but pretty much what one would expect of Turkey in its genocidal years.

Ed Hummer

April 24th, 2008 2:20pm

"And lo and behold". Although modern Turkey may be the land of milk and honey for Stone, I doubt that islamist state garbed in democratic feathers would have been Ali Kemal's dream.

Max

April 26th, 2008 2:23pm

Charles, that sounds rather like my idea of lynching. The (London) Times says he was hanged. His son's memoir of him says that he was deliberately put to death. And he was certainly no Islamist.

Charles

April 27th, 2008 11:47am

Max, sounds like you are better read on this subject than I am, so I shall defer to your opinion. I had only stumbled across the NYT article (about Ali Kemal Bey's demise) whilst investigating the fate of another Ali Kemal (a regional governor with a very unsavoury reputation).

According to the NYT piece, Boris's great-grandfather was indeed tried before one General Nureddin Pasha, the Military Governor of Smyrna. He pronounced a death sentence but then Ali Kemal was killed by the women on his way to the scaffold.

His crime was to be known as a prominent 'anti-nationalist'. His death, apparently, caused great concern in Constantinople where he was held in high regard.

M Clyde

April 28th, 2008 12:27pm

What a fascinating story. What a fascinating man. He sounds fundamentally decent; moderate, urbane, and loyal to the traditional rule and to the traditional foreign policy; loyal to both the British and the Sultan. Such men perish in radical times.

Boris has written a Telegraph article (Nov 07) on Turkey's accession to the EU, of which he remains heartily in favour. I respect his reasons, but like his grandfather I think he fails to read the runes. These are radical times. Traditional attitudes are shifting dramatically.

Turkey is headed in an Islamist nationalist direction. Such a Turkey would be a disaster for Europe.

vangos

May 8th, 2008 5:36pm

1.the author of the article has curiously omitted to mention that Turkey joined the I world war on the side of Germany.
2.In a distorted reporting he fails to make clear that the Turkish percentage died fighting the British & Greek armies, while the Greek & Armenian losses in Turkey were the result of genocide practised on the latter two populations by the Turks.

In this section

The secret letters of the Jonestown death cult

Barry Isaacson

Thirty years after the mass suicides and murders in Guyana, Barry Isaacson unveils a cache of letters he found in his LA home, mapping the pain of one of the families

C’mon Cherie: even Goering stuck up a bit for Hitler

Rod Liddle

Rod Liddle says it is no surprise that Gordon Brown has ended up as surly and suspicious as he has: the memoirs of John Prescott, Lord Levy and Cherie Blair are appalling acts of treachery and avarice

I never want to be as insecure as Olivier

Tim Walker

Tim Walker talks to Greta Scacchi about her new role in The Deep Blue Sea, the gaucheness of Bill Murray — and being offered the lead in Basic Instinct

Meet James Purnell: the best hope Labour has of avoiding disaster

Fraser Nelson

Fraser Nelson says that the 38-year-old Work and Pensions Secretary is the best candidate to succeed Gordon Brown. Already surging ahead at his department, he has the gift of sounding like an ordinary human being — and he understands the Cameron Conservative party

An Actor's Life

Joan Collins

Joan Collins lives an actor's life


Related articles

London Notebook

Barry Humphries

Barry Humphries on life in the capital

Joking apart: why Boris is the man for the job

Boris Johnson has confounded his critics, says Matthew d’Ancona. The contest will go to the wire, but our man has proved himself to be both shrewd enough and serious enough to take charge

So what is England?

To celebrate St George’s Day and Shakespeare’s birthday, The Spectator asked some leading public figures for their answers to this vexing question. Here are their sometimes uplifting, sometimes nostalgic replies

The miners’ strike and the fight against Islamism

Charles Moore

Extremism dies when its lack of legitimacy is revealed, Charles Moore says. Muslim fundamentalism is as brittle as union militancy was in the Eighties

‘They have guns’: a Sloane at large in gangsta land

Venetia Thompson

Tired of Euro-Sloane bores in Chelsea, Venetia Thompson tours the clubs of Harlesden, the UK’s ‘gun capital’, and experiences a world where a firearm is as normal a status symbol as a Chanel handbag or a Rolex watch would be in SW3

Spectator recommends

Bush Hall Hotel - Hertfordshire, UK

Bush Hall Hotel - traditional quality country house hotel & restaurant, in Hertfordshire UK. Luxury leisure breaks, wedding & conference...

Savings & Investments

Information & advice on savings and investment schemes.


Spectator classifieds

UMBRIA

UMBRIA, Niccone Valley.Farmhouse Rental. Newly renovated 400 year old farmhouse, high on the south facing slope of Niccone Valley, on

Cornwall.

AMAZING CORNISH HOUSE previously featured in Vogue Living, available to let during the last 3 weeks of August either on a

City Breaks: PARIS and ROME

PARIS and ROME: over 350 holiday rentals apartments listed: visit www.parisreference.com and www.romanreference.com or call +39 0648 903612.