Saturday 22 November 2008

 

The latest culture as recommended by our staff

Michael Henderson

Michael Henderson suggests


Naked commercial greed meets Stalinist control

Wednesday, 4th June 2008

When Leo McKinstry objected to his neighbours’ plan to build two blocks of flats, he quickly discovered the limits of ‘community empowerment’ under New Labour

There is an increasingly Orwellian tone about the language of the Labour government. The Ministry of Truth, the state propaganda machine in Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four, would have been only too pleased with the doublethink of the fashionable mantra ‘together in diversity’, endlessly repeated to justify the destructive creed of multiculturalism, or the inanity of the advertising slogan ‘the People’s Post Office’, launched at the very time when a mass cull of local post offices is underway against the wishes of the people. Equally dishonest is Gordon Brown’s pledge to support ‘British jobs for British workers’, when mass immigration actually means that most new jobs in the economy have gone to foreigners.

The term ‘eco-town’ is a classic Orwellian oxymoron, where the destruction of the green belt by suburban sprawl is presented as a measure for protecting the environment. Indeed, when it comes to the issue of planning, Hazel Blears, the minister responsible for the logical absurdity of eco-towns, has an almost unfathomable capacity for indulging in the sort of rhetorical euphemisms, distortions and contradictions that characterised official pronouncements in Orwell’s novel. So she claims that she wants the public to have a bigger say over local planning issues, but at the same time she wants the system to be more ‘streamlined’ and ‘efficient’ by removing ‘bureaucratic hurdles’, which is Orwellian code for overriding local objections to development schemes. She tells us with a straight face that Gordon Brown ‘really genuinely means it when he says he wants to move from the big centralist state to more local involvement’, yet she and the Prime Minister are proposing to set up a vast new centralist unelected quango called the Independent Planning Commission to oversee major projects.

‘Community empowerment’ is one of Ms Blears’s current favourite terms. There is to be a ‘Community Empowerment Bill’ this summer, based on the ‘Community Empowerment Action Plan’ she published last October, which called for local councils to become ‘Community Empowerment champions’ in the drive ‘to revive local democracy’. But the more she repeats the phrase, the more she exposes its hollowness. For in reality, local influence over planning has been traduced by Labour. Development in this country is now largely governed by a mix of naked commercial greed and Stalinist central control. In a climate of institutionalised bullying led by an unholy alliance of left-wing politicians, Whitehall bureaucrats, property firms and retail giants, local democracy is the loser.

More articles from: Leo McKinstry | this section

Subscribe now

Post this entry to:   del.icio.us | Digg | Newsvine | NowPublic | Reddit

Comments

Post a comment


Your comment:*

Your name:*

Your email address:*
(We won't publish this)

*Required information

Please click the button only once - your comment will not be published immediately

Raptus regaliter

June 5th, 2008 9:44am

Thank you, Leo, for speaking up for frustrated local councillors everywhere.

Charlie

June 5th, 2008 4:42pm

Morris said Labour will build the Tories out of London. Much of Labour's housing development is not about improving the quality of housing of the working class such as refurbishment of property they live in, but gerrymandering . Much of the 1960s new towns are Labout strongholds within a Tory/Liberal areas. The inability of Labour to support manufacturing and refurbish homes where people want to live is a betrayal of the working class. In the Pathfinder areas many of the houses could be refurbished. People would remain in their communities . The money could be spent on training and supporting R and D in order to encourage development of our manufacturing. The services for a new home - drains, water and gas pipes electricity pipes for a greenfield site can cost £20k per house. It is much cheaper to build in area where these services exist.

Mitch H

June 6th, 2008 11:47am

I sympathise with you over the house next door - we've had a similar experience here only in our case it was the local Conservative borough council which rode roughshod over the wishes of residents and the parish council. Your political memory is short, Leo. i seem to recall a Tory PM (Margaret something or the other) who whittled down local councils' democratic powers, encouraged privatisation of services, and broke their revenue through the widely acclaimed and hugely popular poll tax.

Dr. Gautam Sen

June 6th, 2008 12:05pm

Leo MCkinstry beware, anytime he pops his libertarian head into Stalinist Harrow, he will have a £ 60 parking ticket stapled to his head. Local people are only fit to be managed and finessed and of course good for funding gold-plated final-salary pensions local government pension schemes; 20% of all council taxes.
Remember those desirable retirement entitlements that Gordon Brown and New Labour now reserve for underemployed public servants, who vote Labour in the bargain and exactly for that reason!

roy roebuck

June 6th, 2008 12:12pm

It's a terrace house, not terraced. Use English.

David Miers

June 7th, 2008 11:00am

I've been thinking along the same lines as those in your last paragraph Leo. This government is out to destroy the countryside for the white middle classes and populate it with 'diverse communities'. The countryside is the last bastion of our historical ancestry. Having ruined the cities with muliculturalism they now plan to do the same in the countryside. Where there are currently churches there will soon be mosques. You have been warned and you know who to vote for when you get the chance, and it's NOT socialist Dave and his Blue Labour party. Time is running out...

John A, London

June 7th, 2008 10:07pm

I sometimes cynically wonder if these otherwise inexplicable planning approvals are given because then the applicant's cash rolls into the government coffers.
Application refused, no cash.

Jeff Chaplin

June 11th, 2008 10:16pm

This Independent Planning Commission sounds exactly like the Ontario Municipal Board, used as an instrument of centralized decision making of just the type described in this article.

Roy

July 9th, 2008 11:14am

It all revolves around the diminishing available space. Scientist discovered aeon's ago that rats kept in closer and closer confined spaces indulged in the most diabolical behavior, including eating one another. Nobody would suggest this extreme would happen, but as people become more and more frustrated ... if things are not handled correctly ... bad habits would and are occurring. A balancing act has to be done. The land has to be used for food production and room for the catchment and collection of water. On the other side of the scale there has to be room for the vast amount of wast, room for recreation, room for housing and room for industry. You can not continually be extending your population. At some point you must say enough is enough. The blind continuation of immigration into these islands is screaming lunatic-ism, we do not have the open spaces of the USA in the 1800's. Sooner or later when an emergency turns up ... and it surely will ... you will start to think how stupid could we get. It's time the powers that be get off their high horses, did some careful arithmetic, and put into place a 'think tank' for some important changes in policy.

Alfred T Mahan

August 21st, 2008 11:41am

Ever since some bright ancient Greek came up with the concept of the separation of powers, it has been understood that the legislature, judiciary and executive arms of government have different roles and society is best when they are in balance. In Britain today, this is no longer the case: the executive has captured the legislature. No longer do we see MPs as defenders of our freedoms against an over-mighty state. Instead, they are career 'governers' with no other role in society (and very questionable skill sets to boot). Nowhere is this more true than in local government where the powers exercised by councils have expanded enormously but the power of councillors to overturn officials have dwindled. John Prescott's Code of Practice, for example, has allowed (or perhaps compelled) officials to prevent councillors speaking out on matters of concern - even if they were part of an election manifesto. There is no one to hold officials to account any more. All political parties have shied away from local government reform, but it is now urgent as our freedoms are whittled away one by one.


The Spectator Parliamentarian Awards
Spectator Book Club
The Spectator Billabong

In this section

Thank goodness we can have a run on the pound when we need one

Martin Vander Weyer

Martin Vander Weyer looks ahead to next week’s Pre-Budget Report and reflects on George Osborne’s contentious remarks about the devaluation of sterling. It looks like Gordon Brown is getting away with his borrowing binge — leaving the Tories isolated

I loved Oliver Stone’s Bush film — and I know why the critics hated it

Rod Liddle

The movie W. did not provide the crude anti-Bush agitprop that the reviewers craved, says Rod Liddle. This was precisely its strength: we need to get inside the minds even of those we most deplore

The great Tory tax and spend battle: seconds out...

Fraser Nelson and Daniel Finkelstein

In the wake of Cameron’s decision to drop his pledge to match Labour spending, Fraser Nelson and Daniel Fin kelstein of the Times trade rhetorical blows over the issue that is gripping and troubling the Conservative party as it adjusts to the transformed economic context

Where is our inspiration when we most need it?

Bryan Forbes

Bryan Forbes remembers listening to Churchill as a 14-year-old evacuee and now looks with envy at Obama’s capacity to galvanise hope. Where are his UK counterparts?

For a bit of perspective, try thinking Jurassic

Christopher Lloyd

The first takeaways originated about 150 million years ago, says Christopher Lloyd; global travel is pretty ancient, too. And as for democracy...

Related articles

Want to cut taxes? First cut spending. Here’s how

Fraser Nelson

After a week of clamorous competition between the parties over tax cuts, Fraser Nelson offers a guide to paying for them: a programme of spending cuts that would preserve core services but shave off the fat of the Brown years. All that is needed is political will

The Tory quest for a fiscal Holy Grail is doomed

Irwin Stelzer

Brown’s golden rules have been exposed as a sham, says Irwin Stelzer, but the Tory response has been feeble. Their target should be the PM’s feathering of Old Labour nests

Ashley Cole deserved to be booed for all that he personifies

Rod Liddle

Rod Liddle says that the magnificently horrid England defender exemplifies the greed, lack of respect for the fans and whining self-regard that is ruining football

Amid the financial turmoil, Peter versus George is the key battle

Fraser Nelson

Stand by for a mighty clash between two politicians, says Fraser Nelson. The now infamous dinner between Mandelson and Osborne was a cordial parting for power-brokers of different generations who will fight each other savagely for electoral advantage

This charming man: an audience with the Gover

Fraser Nelson

Fraser Nelson meets the shadow schools secretary and finds him bracingly radical and disarmingly polite: a recipe for success in government

Spectator recommends

Sky - Official Site

Build your own Sky package online. Sky TV, Broadband & Talk only £17.

Free Sky Digital Offer - Order Now

Subscribe to Sky from £16 a month. Get free equipment and free broadband - Join Now. Sky HD - be...


Spectator classifieds

ROME CENTRE

PORTA METRONIA, ROME Standing high on the top of one of the seven hills of Rome- the Coelian- this unique

City Breaks. ROME and PARIS

ROME and PARIS: over 350 holiday rentals apartments listed: visit  www.romanreference.com  and  www.parisreference.com or call +39 0648 903612.

Jewellery. RUFFS (Estd. 1904).

Goldsmiths by Design Welcome to Ruffs!  You have found a company of Goldsmiths that specialises in the manufacture, amongst other