Michael Henderson

In praise of burning pianos

The New Zealander Annea Lockwood is just one of the world’s radical musicians unjustly mocked by hidebound snobs, says Kate Molleson

Annea Lockwood burning a piano in 1968, from which she is making a live recording. [Getty Images]

How are non-conformists assimilated within the cloistered walls of tradition? Richard Wagner supplied the best answer to the age-old question in Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, when Hans Sachs, the cobbler-poet, reconciles youthful ardour with the wisdom bestowed by experience. Learn from the masters, he tells the townsfolk, if you want to start afresh.

It was a lesson absorbed by all the great modernists. Stravinsky, Joyce, Eliot, Picasso, Kandinsky and the rest of the gang understood thoroughly what had come before. Alas, it is a lesson as yet unlearned by Kate Molleson, whose pleading on behalf of ten musical misfits is unlikely to ‘open our ears’, despite her best intentions. For who do we open them to?

Julian Carrillo, perhaps, presented here as a semi-tonal Mexican brave, missing only warpaint and spear. In the manner of Leonard Sachs, that garrulous, gavel-bashing compere of The Good Old Days, Molleson piles up windy phrases like turrets on a seaside castle. Carrillo ‘was an awkward innovator, a problematic vanguard, a stubborn renegade’. That’s just the bonne-bouche. A feast of absurd claims follows.

‘It’s all legal. I’m getting it piped over from Dorset.’

Other readers may prefer the Filipino, Jose Maceda, with his ‘malleable drones’; or incline towards Galina Ustvolskaya, whose deliberately unpleasant music is praised for its ‘ineluctable rigour’. With such mastery of code, Molleson might have been a star at Bletchley Park. In a particularly unsettling passage, which makes one fear for her equilibrium, she deciphers the Russian lady’s ‘wilful and often inexorable cruelty’, ‘terror’, ‘physical pain’, ‘trauma’, ‘steely discipline’, and ‘violence’. And they say music is the food of love.

At least she stakes her claim honestly. A love of music counts for less in this world than the modish inflation of race and gender.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in