Morgan Meaker

The first amendment and the internet’s free speech clash

For Silicon Valley, 2018 was defined by one impossible question: should there be limits to free speech on the internet? The first amendment is hardwired into the (American) CEOs of the big three social media sites: Twitter, YouTube and Facebook. Each platform grew its user-base with a “words can never hurt me” attitude. Back in 2012, Twitter defined itself as the “free speech wing of the free speech party”; Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has defended his users’ right to be wrong – even for Holocaust deniers. For years, social media platforms allowed posts that could arguably inspire real-life violence in the US, Germany and in Myanmar. But now things are changing. It is only recently, after a series of scandals, that these sites are expanding their army of content moderators to decide when the phrase “Free Kashmir” prohibits Indian law, for example, or when the vomit emoji is used to incite hatred against Muslims.

These companies have their headquarters in a country that is typically proud of its first amendment, protecting even offensive speech. In a recent poll of 38 countries, the Pew Research Center found that US citizens were the most supportive of free speech, with 71 per cent agreeing with the statement “it is very important that people can say what they want without state/ government censorship in our country”. In Europe, support for that statement was 65 per cent; while in the Middle East and Africa, fewer than half of people agreed. But the ubiquity of social media is making other countries reconsider their own attitudes. In the UK, for example, expectations of free speech are becoming Americanised as a result of the internet. The ‘Free Tommy Robinson’ campaign was, rightly or wrongly, framed as a free speech issue with his supporters calling for Brits to be allowed to say whatever they want, however offensive it might be.

This is new here.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.


Unlock more articles



Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in