Matthew Lesh

The Online Harms Bill still threatens free speech and privacy 

The Online Safety Bill became a lightning rod for criticism during the Conservative party leadership contest over the summer. A wide array of candidates, from Kemi Badenoch to Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak, promised to take another look at how the legislation, and its attempt to crack down on online harms, could interfere with free speech. 

The ‘legal but harmful’ duties, now being removed, required the largest digital companies to address state-determined categories of legal speech – like ‘disinformation’ or ‘hate speech’ – in their terms and conditions. But in practice ‘legal but harmful’ was never the most problematic part of the proposed legislation. While the impetus was for more user content to be removed, technically the platforms could have opted to do nothing. And regardless, the provision only applied to the largest companies. 

The most concerning part of the Bill, perhaps counterintuitively, relates to illegal content. The Bill requires all digital platforms, from Twitter to Mumsnet, to proactively scan user speech for a wide array of prioritised content and censor it using automated systems. Shockingly, this duty even applies to encrypted private messaging services like WhatsApp and iMessage. In the name of avoiding large fines – up to 10 per cent of any given platform’s global revenue – this could turn into censorship on an industrial scale.

The Bill presumes that the government can legislate for safety simply by handing off complex societal issues to Big Tech in the form of ‘duties’

Even worse, the removal of content is required on the whimsical basis of anything that the platform has ‘reasonable grounds to infer’ could be illegal. This includes inferring whether the ‘mental elements’ of an offence (e.g. intent to cause harm) are present and whether there is a lack of defence. This raises obvious challenges: how is a digital platform meant to read a user’s mind? Why is the threshold below the usual legal standard (i.e.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in