Alan Roden

Alex Salmond’s curious relationship with the media

(Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)

This afternoon, Alex Salmond’s coffin, draped in a saltire, arrived in Scotland from North Macedonia. The chartered flight was paid for by Sir Tom Hunter, a billionaire philanthropist. ‘He deserved the dignity and privacy of a private return to the home of his birth,’ Sir Tom wrote in a brief statement, praising the former first minister for devoting his life to Scotland.

Salmond was, as many have rightly observed, one of the greatest political strategists of modern times. But his ability to think one step ahead of his opponents wasn’t only obvious in the political arena: he was also a master at setting the media agenda. When arriving at a Salmond press conference or gathering around him for a media huddle, there was little doubt who was in charge. Perhaps he would volunteer information that would keep the spotlight where he wanted it, or deliver a memorable turn of phrase that reporters simply couldn’t ignore.

A potential by-election victory in Glasgow? A ‘political earthquake’ to send ‘shivers down Labour’s spine’. A boom in green energy? Scotland will be the ‘Saudi Arabia of renewables’. He was at it in one of his final newspaper interviews with The Scotsman, accusing the SNP leadership of a ‘brain dead’ response to the general election result and branding a Scottish cabinet secretary a ‘fud’. When he did misstep, it lasted longer in the memory because of the headlines he had created in the first place: the ‘unpardonable folly’ of the Nato bombing of Serbia, or his attempt at segregating the ‘Scolympians; from Team GB during the 2012 London Games.

Salmond’s ability to think one step ahead of his opponents wasn’t only obvious in the political arena: he was also a master at setting the media agenda.

Salmond was also a master at deflection when he didn’t want to answer a question. A traditional politician’s pivot to more comfortable ground wasn’t for him: his solution was to mock the journalist, ridiculing the line of questioning or the publication responsible. It was good natured – most of the time – and delivered with his trademark confident chuckle. And he wasn’t averse to later joining the very same reporters for a convivial glass of fizz in the parliament bar.

He was a constant contradiction, as former SNP MP Stewart McDonald highlighted when reflecting on Salmond’s complex legacy. He would warmly slap a journalist on the back – before stabbing them in the back by complaining to their editor. He raged against the newspapers opposed to independence but was obsessed by what they published. He dismissed the impact of the media but claimed for years after the referendum that a single frontpage of the Daily Record had somehow swung the result. (Coincidentally, the former editor of that paper, who oversaw the publication of that very page, resigned from his post as chief executive of the SNP today.) Salmond was renowned for providing media access – and yet barred a group of reporters from hostile newspapers from his resignation press conference.

The former first minister’s relationship with the media was a curious one. In his referendum memoirs, Salmond mentions delivering the Edinburgh Evening News as a paperboy. Years later he still paid attention to what the paper published: my first direct encounter with Salmond was as a cub reporter when he rang the News to berate me about coverage of a 2006 by-election. He described the genteel Sunday Post as ‘once a great Scottish tradition’ which had developed a ‘touch of malice’. Even the day before the referendum itself, he was incensed by a ‘ludicrous piece of Telegraph nonsense’. For those of us who reported on the long independence referendum campaign, Alex Salmond shaped the most memorable period of our working lives. I believe he made us better journalists. It is incredibly hard to come to terms with his untimely death, and to imagine the heartbreak and pain felt by those closest to him. He was a brilliant headline-grabber and story-creator, and it was compelling to be in his company.

However the allegations of inappropriate behaviour in office – by his own admission, he was ‘no angel’ – which took him to trial in 2021, at which he was acquitted on all counts, left an indelible stain on his legacy. Had he returned to Holyrood in 2026 as an Alba party MSP for North East Scotland, it would have been very different to the referendum era he bestrode like a colossus. Yet he would have of course relished the opportunity to once again lock horns with the fourth estate and embrace, entertain, belittle and manipulate the media as only he could.

Written by
Alan Roden

Alan Roden is the co-founder of Quantum Communications. He is a former communications director for Scottish Labour and was the political editor of the Scottish Daily Mail during the independence referendum campaign. He recently launched the justice publication 1919 Magazine. 

Topics in this article

Comments