Alex Massie

And So the Debates Begin...

Text settings

As James suggests, few things are more tempting and pointless as "adjudicating" debates according to the Expectations Game. These matters may not be as zero-sum as a horse-race but it's silly - even if one does it oneself  - to view them in terms of Who Did Better than Expected? None of these fellows is a Cicero who might need to carry a penalty weight...

Should, however, you want to see how people who judge debates for a living umpire these occasions then I direct you to Election Debates where a panel of grizzled veterans* (who ought to know better but can't quite leave the game) will offer their verdicts - based, I trust, on whatever passes for actual "debating" tonight rather than awarding points for turning up and seeming marginally more human/substantial/old than you might have expected...

Meanwhile, CSPAN have done an amazing thing: their entire archive is now online and you can watch the whole of the first Nixon-Kennedy debate here. A taster follows. Note how the journalists asking the questions introduce themselves. Groovy!

*Disclosure: Some of them are friends of mine.

Written byAlex Massie

Alex Massie is Scotland Editor of The Spectator. He also writes a column for The Times and is a regular contributor to the Scottish Daily Mail, The Scotsman and other publications.

Topics in this articlePolitics