Fraser Nelson Fraser Nelson

Current Tory health plans are backward-looking and reactionary

I have long been depressed about Tory health policy, or lack thereof. The News of the World today does a head-to-head about whether Andy Burnham or Andrew Lansley would be better to run the NHS – and I give my verdict.  The answer, I say, is neither of them. The patient should become the consumer, as is the case in the healthcare system of every developed country. But this would require taking on the NHS establishment, which no party is committed to doing. Or, rather, Alan Milburn was committed to – and had actually started to enact. But that reform agenda came under attack from the Brownites and Andrew Lansley.

The Tory health policy, as it stands, defies understanding. There are various, welcome plans to broaden the supply of providers – but they start with a proposal to grant operational independence to the NHS bureaucracy. Cameron calls this the “NHS Independence Bill”; its intention is to assure the poor NHS staff that government will not be reorganizing them again, and that they will be spared what Cameron says is the “disruptive” influence of politicians. He had in mind the Blairite supply-side reforms, which tried to force the NHS to open up to independent providers and force GPs to give parents the choice.
 
 “Trust the professions” went the cry amongst the Cameroons; “It’s a very conservative thing.” Erm, no it’s not. It’s a very Kinnockite thing, a very Dobsonite thing.  Alan Milburn had been bravely attempting to introduce competition into the NHS – asking private clinics to bid to provide services to NHS patients. He wanted overseas clinics to set up here, and some were.  But the Empire struck back: the NHS Confederation, the BMA etc. And they found a strong ally in Mr Lansley. Not only did he say: “I won’t reform you”; he said: “I will grant you operational independence so no minister will again reform you”.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in