Jonathan Jones

Ed Balls reverses over his own progress on fiscal responsibility

The battle-lines over the Welfare Benefits Up-rating Bill — which faces its second reading in the Commons this afternoon — have been drawn. Labour has tied its opposition to the Resolution Foundation’s analysis showing that the bulk of the policy will hit working families. As Ed Balls put it last week, ‘Two-thirds of people who will be hit by David Cameron and George Osborne’s real terms cuts to tax credits and benefits are in work.’ They’ve labelled the move a ‘strivers’ tax’, a continuation of the divisive rhetoric from both them and the Conservatives that seeks to pit ‘hardworking families’ against ‘people who won’t work’ (as a recent Tory ad put it). Then there’s the new Tory poster, highlighted by Isabel this morning, proclaiming that ‘Today Labour are voting to increase benefits by more than workers’ wages.’ But that’s not strictly true. Labour are voting to continue increasing benefits in line with prices (as measured by the Consumer Prices Index). And according to the Office for Budget Responsibility’s latest forecasts, prices will rise more slowly than earnings from the end of this year. So, under the old policy, benefits would increase by less than wages anyway from next year. The Tories’ argument is really more about the fact that benefits have risen more quickly than earnings over the past few years. In his Autumn Statement, George Osborne said:

‘over the last five years those on out of work benefits have seen their incomes rise twice as fast as those in work. With pay restraint in businesses and government, average earnings have risen by around 10 per cent since 2007. Out of work benefits have gone up by around 20 per cent. That’s not fair to working people who pay the taxes that fund them.’

And this morning, party chairman Grant Shapps said:

‘For years, the gap between those who earn and those who live on benefits has grown – and this government is restoring fairness to the system.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in