Theo Hobson Theo Hobson

Golliwog, Totem and Taboo

Commentary on the Carol Thatcher business has been predictably superficial and self-righteous. Its real meaning is that racial correctness can only be understood in relation to religion. Bear with me.

Did she commit a serious offence? She referred to someone as a golliwog, obviously knowing that it was a taboo word, capable of causing great offence to black people, and of producing a frisson of disapproval among the white people who were actually present. It was, perhaps, a momentary lapse of judgment, a brief failure of self-censorship – there is no evidence that she holds racist views. For this lapse she has been dropped from a television show, and her reputation has been damaged beyond repair.

It sounds like a shocking over-reaction, political correctness gone Stalinist. She was guilty of nothing more than ‘bad manners’, says Simon HefferAccording to Charles Moore ‘she committed no offence, professional or moral – not even, since the person she described was not in the room, an offence of manners.’


This response is an evasion of a complex reality. The fact is that some race terms are genuinely taboo, in the anthropological sense – they have a sort of magic power. They conjure up a whole mental attitude, a way of seeing the world. Because of this power, they are effectively prohibited. This is not a matter of ‘political correctness’, but of quasi-religious piety. The prohibition stands for something larger: it is a totem of white repentance for historical racism. To use one of these words, ‘as a joke’, is to dissent from this; to signal scepticism about the necessity of white repentance for historical racism.

But is Carol Thatcher’s little slip an instance of serious racism? On one level obviously not, but in race as in religion, symbolism is powerful.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in