John McDonnell has accused me of telling an untruth. Yes, I know, worse things have happened. But still. His accusation refers to the closure of the Redcar SSI steel plant.
@bbcquestiontime Untruth from Rod Liddle. I visited Redcar on Monday after Labour Conference when plant's future was still being discussed
Mr McDonnell claimed that a visit to the area, where he met with tearful workers, prompted him to do a u-turn on supporting the Conservative plan to balance to budget. I said on Question Time last week and again in The Sunday Times this Sunday that this was utter cant. A charge I will cheerfully repeat now. It is utter cant, McDonnell. The shadow chancellor made his commitment to abide by Osborne’s budget surplus proposal at the Labour conference on 28 September – it had been reported in advance by most papers.
That was fully ten days after SSI had announced it was ceasing steel production at the plant. And eleven days after local Labour MPs had raised the issue in the House of Commons, insisting that the government ‘did not give a fig’ for steel-making on Teesside. No, indeed. And nor did John McDonnell. Clear, John?
Incidentally – and I know most of you won’t agree – I would have nationalised the plant. £100m. Wait to see how much we spend clearing up after it.
The trouble with history is that it is topiary. History is what’s left after the unwanted foliage has been clipped and cleared away. The topiary birds, pigs and pyramids are just yew bushes minus the clippings, these forms having emerged from the topiarist’s shears. Your yew-based pig is a product of selective disposal, even down
Comments
Join the debate for just $5 for 3 months
Be part of the conversation with other Spectator readers by getting your first three months for $5.
UNLOCK ACCESS Just $5 for 3 monthsAlready a subscriber? Log in