Daniel Jackson

MPs back plain cigarette packets. Smokers, get over it. Or switch to pretty e-cigs

MPs are voting today in favour of the introduction of standardised cigarette packaging. There hasn’t even been a debate on the issue and the BBC thinks the result is a foregone conclusion. That’s bad news for the tobacco industry, hardline libertarians and Nigel Farage.

It’s been amusing watching the Tobacco Manufacturer’s Association carve out its nuanced – almost schizophrenic – position on the matter. Smoking is bad for our health and it is impossible to argue otherwise. So they don’t. Theirs must be the only industry which is resigned, ostensibly at least, to deterring potential customers.

Big tobacco firms have an obligation to their shareholders, so they have to say something in their own defence. Their position is that plain packaging will make it easier for criminals to produce and sell counterfeit cigarettes. They quote HMRC’s tobacco smuggling strategy:

The availability of illegal tobacco products undermines public health objectives and impacts on the health of both individuals and wider communities; circumventing health labelling requirements and age of sale restrictions… Unregulated distribution networks associated with smuggling make tobacco more accessible to children and young people and perpetuate health inequalities across socio-economic groups.

The implication is that plain packages will be easier to counterfeit than branded ones. This argument is a smokescreen; criminals don’t usually spoof artwork. In my experience illicit tobacco is currently sold in plain packaging. In clear plastic bags. How ironic. In the UK only nine per cent of ready-rolled cigarettes are bought on the black market. This figure isn’t so low because the boxes are difficult to mimic; it’s because most smokers would rather not inhale arsenic, dead flies and dust.

In a tweet in January the chain-smoking Ukip leader said: ‘Plain packaging is an appalling intrusion into consumer choice and the operation of the free market.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in