Eleni Courea

No, the SNP isn’t planning a ‘republican insurrection’. Here’s why

So is Nicola Sturgeon planning ‘a quiet republican insurrection?’ The Times says so in a thundering leader today: Jacob Rees-Mogg has even outed the party as ‘closet republicans’. And why? Because the SNP is withholding £1.5m of funding that is due to the Queen. Or so we’re told.

The truth is a little more complex – and rather different. The money for the royal family does not come from the Crown Estate. It comes from HM Treasury, and under a formula set up in 2011 the Queen’s Budget is pegged to the profits of the Crown Estate (a kind of performance-linked pay, if you will. Very Tory).

The Crown Estate is the royal family’s sprawling property empire – an £8 billion kingdom of retail parks, hotels, farms, golf courses, Regent Street and the entire UK seabed. All revenue from the Crown Estate has been surrendered to the Treasury since 1760, with a fixed amount being granted to the monarch on an annual basis.

Now, as part of those oh-so-successful attempts to reduce support for the SNP, the UK government agreed to devolve control over the Crown Estate so that the Scottish Government would get control over the Scottish parts. This, of course, will diminish the profits of the remainder. But this, you might think, is easily remedied: rather than peg the so-called ‘Sovereign Grant’ to 15 per cent of the UK Crown Estate it could be pegged to, say, 18 per cent of the remaining Crown Estate. Simples.

At no point was it ever suggested that Scotland had to chip in towards the Sovereign Grant. Like defence and foreign affairs, it’s a reserved payment – the sole preserve of the UK government. Nicola Sturgeon may want to double the Queen’s pay; she may want it halved. It doesn’t matter, she has no control.

Now, it could well be that someone in Buckingham Palace thinks Scotland should have given the Queen the 15 per cent.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in