Mats Persson

Opposing the EU Bill

The EU Bill is back in parliament today, amid speculation that Cameron has a Europe-fuelled rebellion on his hands. Despite the talk, the chances are that the Bill will go through Parliament wholly unscathed in its first test.
 
Today’s debate is about the so-called ‘sovereignty clause’ – or Clause 18 – within the EU Bill. Of the Bill’s 17 pages, the clause only takes up four lines, but has still managed to cause the most fuss (the vast majority of the text relates to the EU ‘referendum lock’).
 
The government claims that Clause 18 confirms that EU law “is only recognised by virtue of the authority of acts of Parliament”, and that it seeks to counter fears that parliamentary sovereignty can “be eroded by decision of the courts”.
 
Such reasoning hasn’t convinced some Tory backbench MPs. They say that parliamentary sovereignty is not based on common law – which is hammered out by judges not MPs – but on parliament’s victory over the monarchy hundreds of years ago. In other words, parliament is sovereign because parliament is sovereign, not because judges say so. These MPs worry that the EU Bill could undermine this principle rather than strengthen it.
 
The confusion arises from an unfortunate formulation in the explanatory notes of the Bill which states that Clause 18 reinforces the “common law principle” that EU law takes effect through the will of parliament – which implies that judges could at some point take it away.
 
The explanatory note should be corrected to stamp out this confusion because the sovereignty clause itself specifically addresses a different point – the primacy of parliament over EU law. It’s hard to see how such a clause will do any harm if allowed to stand alone.
 
But you can understand why backbench MPs have chosen the EU Bill to make this constitutional point.











Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in