James Heale James Heale

Shapps seeks the mantle of moderation on strikes

Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images

Fresh from his photoshop debacle, Grant Shapps arrived in the Commons today to outline the government’s plans for minimum safety level legislation. He and his colleagues are currently engaged in a difficult balancing act: negotiating with unions over pay one day, then seeking to curb their powers the next. It is emblematic of the ‘carrot and stick’ approach that ministers have adopted throughout this winter of industrial action – hinting heavily that workers will receive pay improvements in the next financial settlement, while threatening new restrictions to prevent a future repeat of these strikes.

Shapps is seen as one of the Conservatives’ more affable communicators. He therefore sought to present today’s measures as sensible and pragmatic, a ‘reasonable and mature way’ to ensure that ‘lives and livelihoods are not lost’ in industrial action. He promised to consult on what a minimum service level should look like but confirmed that the legislation will apply to six key sectors of health, education, fire, ambulance, rail and nuclear power.

The Business Secretary also pointed to the ‘mature European democracies’ which have such legislation on their statute books such as France and Germany. Yet, faced with the jeering of the Labour benches, he wasn’t afraid to splice soothing words with a bit of boilerplate union-bashing. He accused striking paramedics of putting ‘lives at risk’ and ‘a lack of timely co-operation’ which meant that ‘health officials were left guessing at the likely minimum coverage, making contingency planning almost impossible.’

Naturally, such talk found little favour with his opposite number Angela Rayner, wearing one of her many hats as Shadow Secretary of State for the Future of Work. She gave a punchy reply, raising a constituent who died, unable to get an ambulance on a day when there was no strike action. Responding to Shapps’ talk of conciliation, Rayner pointed to the ‘dismal’ read out by the trade unions involved in yesterday’s talks with the Health Secretary and noted how some of the countries with minimum service levels still suffer more strikes than Britain.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.


Unlock more articles



Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in