Fraser Nelson Fraser Nelson

Starmer is caught in a web of his own words

(Photo: Getty)

I’ve so far found it hard to get outraged about Keir Starmer’s curry with staffers after a campaigning event in April last year. For the boss to buy in a curry for his local activists during the visit is a decent and human thing to do. I’d not condemn anyone for it. But this is politically tricky for Starmer for three reasons:

  1. Starmer was not a voice of moderation on lockdown. He was always calling for an even tougher regime than that which the Tories needlessly imposed. As Opposition leader, I’d say, he had not only the option but the duty to oppose a cruel and draconian policy that gratuitously criminalised harmless, everyday acts.
  2. Starmer did not change his mind on lockdown. As he sat down for that curry, he should have thought: should I really have voted for this to be illegal? Or at very least put decent people in a bizarre situation where they need to invent a story about going back to work after 10pm, in order to dodge a potential police investigation? As Opposition leader, Starmer could and should have spoken out for the many who thought that it was time to leave people to their own judgement and decriminalise lockdown rules. He was right to judge that his offering a curry and a beer to his hardworking team posed no Covid risk. But he was wrong not to use his position to speak up against the obviously-crazy rules which were needlessly criminalising a great many people. Maybe even him
  3. Starmer called for Sunak to resign over that birthday cake. Thus establishing a principle: if a frontbench politician unwittingly breaks the rules – as Rishi Sunak did – he should walk the plank. It’s hard for Starmer not to apply the test to himself. 

This top-flight lawyer is now being caught in a web of his own words. This is precisely the kind of mess you’d think a former Director of Public Prosecutions would not get caught up in.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in