Tom Goodenough Tom Goodenough

The battle for Brexit moves to the High Court

More than 17 million people voted for Brexit. Yet for some, that mandate isn’t quite enough. Today, the High Court is hearing a legal challenge on whether the Government should be allowed to pull the Article 50 trigger without the direct say-so of Parliament. The Commons might have spent hours debating Brexit over the last few days but for Gina Miller – the fund manager bringing the High Court case – only another vote will do. Here’s what she said on the Today show explaining her argument:

‘It’s actually very simple, our case is that this is a fundamental constitutional case saying that parliament and parliament alone can take away rights. The Government can not use this ancient secretive royal prerogative to do so.’

But is Miller just a bad loser? No, she said, before insisting ‘we’re all leavers now’. So if that’s true, why the hold-up?

Miller is making this an argument about the division of powers between the executive and the legislature – murky waters in an uncodified constitution like Britain’s. And to be fair to those challenging the Government today, Theresa May hasn’t helped matters by making her biggest Brexit announcement at Tory conference rather than in Parliament, where she said simply she didn’t want to give a running commentary on negotiations.

To complicate matters, even the experts are split on who is responsible for kick starting Article 50. Here’s Parliament’s website’s somewhat opaque attempt at an explanation:

‘The Prime Minister has said it would be for his successor and his or her Cabinet to decide whether the House of Commons should have a vote on the decision to trigger Article 50, the formal process set out in the Treaty on European Union for member states to follow should they decide to leave the EU.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.


Unlock more articles



Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in