Mark Bathgate

The bills just keep coming in

The bills just keep coming in
Text settings
Comments

Two years after Northern Rock became the first bank failure of this crisis, another £30 billion of taxpayers’ money needs to be thrown at the banking system. Behind all the noise about improving competition and the European Commission lies one core fact: the UK banks have lost an astonishing sum of money. The above chart shows bank losses as a percentage share of GDP, and illustrates the scale of the crisis that has overwhelmed the banking system and the taxpayer. The IMF estimates that losses could be as high as 25% of UK GDP.

 

UK banks went on an orgy of lending around the world, becoming the biggest source of credit growth in many countries. RBS trebled its total lending in just three years, expanding its balance sheet to almost 1.5 times the size of the UK economy. Egged on by Gordon Brown – in whose tax receipts he felt he had found the “New North Sea Oil” to fund an ever grander government sector – money was thrown in almost every conceivable direction. In common with their cheerleader Brown, the banks decided there was no reason to worry about the day when the economy could decline because ‘boom and bust’ had ended. This led to many UK banks – the largest lenders at the height of the boom – facing the downturn with the lowest bad-loan reserves and the weakest liquidity position of any banks globally.

 

The list of bank failures that started with Northern Rocks is now long: Bradford and Bingley, Singer and Friedlander, Dunfermline Building Society, RBS, Lloyds, HBOS.  With over £30 billion handed over today, the direct cost for the taxpayer approaches £90 billion, with no certainty of these sums being recouped. On top of this, there are still over £1 trillion of other subsidies being provided to these banks and others who have not needed direct bailouts, like Barclays, to try and hold the system together.

This is not the end of the bill – most people will have noticed overdraft charges rising and the gap between mortgage rates and the Bank of England Base Rate soaring. UK banks have increased their margins to UK customers to pay for their losses. This is one of the key reasons that the UK economy remains, alone among the major economies, in recession. It’s not smart economics to refund the taxpayer the cost of the bailout by simply ramping up the costs of banking to the same taxpayer.

 

The UK bank crisis ranks as one of the most serious shocks to hit a developed economy in the post-war period. The scale of bank losses may even eclipse those of the Japanese banks in the 1990s - losses that cost the Japanese economy more than a decade of growth. Fixing the problem is every bit as important as addressing the government debt crisis, and will likely be the difference between stagnation and recovery.