Daniel McCarthy

The War on Terror is a war of religion

Western policymakers think of themselves as revolutionaries when they are more like theologians

An unidentified fire fighter walks away from Ground Zero after the collapse of the twin towers (Image: Getty)

Compare the world 20 years after the 9/11 attacks to the world two decades after Pearl Harbour. World War Two was a vivid presence in popular culture and national memory in 1961, but America in the first year of John F. Kennedy’s administration was in no sense living in the shadow of Japan’s attack. That war had ended 15 years ago; Japan was now our ally in the Cold War with the Soviet Union.

Twenty years after 9/11, the US has only just ended its war in Afghanistan, and the result of that conflict, which lasted five times longer than the one with Imperial Japan (and Hitler’s Germany), was the immediate return to power of the regime we set out to depose at the start.

After Afghanistan, the US is still fighting a War on Terror against al-Qaeda and similar groups. The foreign-policy community continues to dream of bringing regime change to the Islamic world, while weapons of mass destruction at the disposal of the ‘Axis of Evil’ remains a preoccupation of our diplomats and think-tankers, or tank-thinkers.

    Like a classic war of religion, its objective is the claiming of territory for the faith and ultimately the conversion of the people who live there

    This is what ‘forever war’ means. And in fact, it began at least a decade before 9/11, with the 1991 Persian Gulf War that didn’t really conclude successfully and cleanly but instead became an open-ended policing operation over the skies of Iraq and in the purported deports and workshops of Saddam Hussein’s WMDs. Congress was still fighting the Gulf War in 1998 when it passed the ‘Iraq Liberation Act’, five years before George W. Bush invaded in full force.

    1998 was also the year Bill Clinton’s administration launched air strikes against al-Qaeda camps in Afghanistan (and Sudan) in retaliation for the group’s attacks on US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania earlier that year.

    Already a subscriber? Log in

    Keep reading with a free trial

    Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

    There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

    Or

    Unlock more articles

    REGISTER

    Comments

    Don't miss out

    Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

    Already a subscriber? Log in