David Abulafia David Abulafia

Why does Priyamvada Gopal find ‘eloquence’ troubling?

The fallen statue of Edward Colston (Getty images)

Why should anyone feel insulted when they are described as ‘eloquent’? Priyamvada Gopal, professor of post-colonial studies at Cambridge University, felt moved to speak on behalf of David Olusoga when I used that very compliment to describe him. In an article for the Daily Telegraph, I argued that Olusoga’s testimony in the trial of the ‘Colston Four’ was not relevant. After all, it was not a trial of the long-dead Edward Colston but one for criminal damage. Would Olusoga have been called as an expert witness were he not something of a celebrity whose TV appearances are often impressive? I’m not convinced. Yet in the eyes of my Cambridge colleague, my biggest error was to refer to Olusoga’s impressive way with words.

‘Calling writers/scholars/intellectuals of colour ‘eloquent’ or ‘articulate’, Gopal averred, ‘can quite often be a little sleight of hand dismissal: ‘yeah yeah yeah, you talk a good game, people are gonna like it, but you’re just whipping up passions, no substance’.

A few years ago, I was attacked by a colleague after I described an unsuccessful female candidate for a senior post as a ‘witterer’

The suggestion was that the e-word could be used as a sort of back-handed compliment to those from certain ethnic minorities, a condescending way of appearing to offer praise while really expressing disdain for their views. 

I clearly move in a charmed circle, as no one to whom I have spoken since she raised her objection accepts that ‘eloquent’ carries this hidden meaning. But there are quite a few words that are having red labels tied to them. A few years ago, I was attacked by a colleague after I described an unsuccessful female candidate for a senior post as a ‘witterer’. She (the colleague) said that this was a term only used of women. No, I responded: I use it regularly of a learned male professor (not present) who cannot keep to the point at meetings.

Already a subscriber? Log in

Keep reading with a free trial

Subscribe and get your first month of online and app access for free. After that it’s just £1 a week.

There’s no commitment, you can cancel any time.

Or

Unlock more articles

REGISTER

Comments

Don't miss out

Join the conversation with other Spectator readers. Subscribe to leave a comment.

Already a subscriber? Log in