Politics

Read about the latest UK political news, views and analysis.

James Forsyth

Clegg’s idea would give the Lib Dems more of an identity

Nick Clegg’s announcement that if ID cards are introduced he will simply refuse to register is smart politics. First, it prevents Chris Huhne from gaining a monopoly on eye-catching, activist-pleasing ideas in the Lib Dem leadership contest. Second, it shows that Clegg is prepared to exploit the greater license that the leader of the third party has. However, stridently the Tories oppose ID cards it is hard to imagine David Cameron or David Davis indulging in civil disobedience. The key test for any Lib Dem leader is to get their party noticed. This is what Ming Campbell was incapable of doing and why he ultimately failed as leader. This pledge

James Forsyth

No Ming, more zing for the Lib Dems

Maybe the Lib Dems shouldn’t elect a new leader at all. In their current leaderless state, they have jumped 4 percent in the latest ICM poll to put them at a respectable 18 percent. The Tories are down three, but still at the psychologically important 40 percent mark. Labour are on 35 percent, a one percent drop. The Lib Dem spike is best explained by the amount of coverage they are currently getting thanks to their leadership race. Once the Lib Dems elect a leader they can expect to come under heavy fire, the Tories in particular will be keen to prevent a new Lib Dem leader from gaining any

Listen Live: Can capitalism save the planet? | 30 October 2007

Tonight, Spectator.co.uk broadcasts the latest debate in the Spectator / Intelligence Squared series. From 6:45pm, listen to John Redwood, Nigel Lawson, Tim Harford, David Rieff, Eric Bettellheim and Frances Cairncross discuss whether carbon trading can combat climate change without hurting economic growth. You can listen to the debate here and have your say by voting in our poll.

The rewards of failure

We’ve just posted a great piece by Martin Vander Weyer on the dangers to capitalism of the kind of huge pay-offs that the departing boss of Merrill Lynch is set to receive. You can read it here.

Gove skewers Gordon

As I predicted yesterday, Michael Gove’s speech to the Bow Group this morning was a belter: as trenchant and subtle an analysis of Gordon Brown’s politics as any Tory politician has yet made. The Gover launched his attack more in sorrow than in anger – and it was all the deadlier for that. Look at his choice of historical precedents for the Prime Minister: David Lloyd George – one of our most historically significant Chancellors whose peacetime premiership descended into an exercise in idealism-free positioning, truckling to establishment media figures and ideological drift. Lyndon B Johnson – a man whose early career was marked by a genuine desire to tackle

James Forsyth

Talking Turkey

If you want to see how real the danger of the West losing Turkey is, examine these poll numbers. The United States’s favourability rating is down to 9%- from 52% in 2000. The European Union’s favourability rating has fallen from 54% in 2004 to 27% today. Turks are now more hostile towards Westerners than either Egyptians or Pakistanis. In some ways, these numbers aren’t surprising: both the United States and the EU have shown little consideration of the Turks in recent years. But they should worry us. If Turkey becomes permanently alienated from the West, dealing with the problems of the Middle East will become even more difficult.  Hat tip:

Gove to deliver the Tory verdict on Brown

Huge excitement at Tory HQ over a speech which Michael Gove will deliver tomorrow on Gordon Brown’s politics. It is meant, I am told, to be seen both as the “definitive” take on Gordon-so-far and as a companion piece to David Cameron’s speech on immigration today – a measure of how (justly) high Gove’s stock is in the Cameroon circle. Apt, as well, that the most brilliant Scot of one generation should be selected to take on the most brilliant of another. The Shadow Schools Secretary was President of the Union when I was at Oxford and, though he has deliberately restrained the rhetorical fireworks as Shadow Schools Secretary –

Fraser Nelson

Cameron must bring honesty to the immigration debate

I had thought David Cameron would shy away from immigration. That the scars of the 2005 campaign would keep him away from it just as Letwin’s 2001 disaster left him too traumatised to ever consider tax cuts again. Yet today at 11.15am at Policy Exchange, Cameron will give a keynote speech on immigration – the topic which, polls show, troubles the public the most. Remember, Iain Dale had told us on Friday that the Great Clunking Fist was planning to grasp this nettle first. So Cameron today beats him too it. For me, his mission will be to show a more mature understanding of the problem than Labour. The bar

James Forsyth

Blair’s thwarted plans

The latest revelations from the Anthony Seldon book reveal just how much Tony Blair was weakened by his diminished majority following the 2005 election. The Times reports that not only was Blair forced to abandon his plans to reform the Treasury and possibly move Gordon Brown, but also saw John Prescott and others thwarting his reshuffle plans.  This exchange between Blair and Brown reveals how Blair was incapable of getting his way even on relatively minor personnel issues: Blair had decided that he was going to move in on the Treasury appointments. ‘Isn’t it at last time to sack Dawn Primarolo [the Treasury minister, now Minister for Public Health]?’ Blair

Alex Massie

Why does John McCain hate America?

John McCain tells ABC’s This Week that – shockingly! – torture is ” a very important issue to me” and consequently that he can’t guarantee that he will vote to confirm Michael Mukasey as Attorney General if the nominee continues to fudge on the question of whether or not he believes waterboarding constitutes torture. McCain, noting yet again that it was a favourite method of Pol Pot’s happy warriors, would, one senses like to vote No but there’s the problem that… well, let’s go and see what the GOP blogs are saying. Here’s Rich Lowry, editor of National Review, confirming that supporting the use of waterboarding would indeed seem to

Listen Live: Can capitalism save the planet?

This Tuesday, Spectator.co.uk broadcasts the latest debate in the Spectator / Intelligence Squared series. From 6:45pm, listen to John Redwood, Nigel Lawson, Tim Harford, David Rieff, Eric Bettellheim and Frances Cairncross discuss whether carbon trading can combat climate change without hurting economic growth. You can listen to previous debates on whether Britain has failed Zimbabwe and whether we should be reluctant to assert the superiority of Western values by clicking here.

James Forsyth

Whitehall put on PMQs alert

If anyone wants to know how rattled Downing Street is by the hammering that Gordon Brown now regularly receives at Prime Ministers Questions they should read this story in The Sunday Times. It reveals that civil servants are being instructed to spend more time thinking about what topics might come up at PMQs and to find ‘good third-party endorsements’ for government policies including from opposition politicians. It is true that PMQs isn’t the be and end all of politics—if it was Prime Minister Hague would be riding high in the polls—but it does help determine the mood at Westminster. Today’s poll which shows Labour marginally ahead of the Tories isn’t seen as

Fraser Nelson

What’s next after English votes for English laws

Once, Alistair Campbell would have spotted and filled the news vacuum which sucks away at the papers this weekend. Instead it the Tories have scored a spin coup. They have grabbed headlines by re-announcing their longstanding “English votes for English laws” policy which (as Jonathan Freedland said in July) is “not new but in their 2001 and 2005 manifestos”.   No one cared about the policy then: now, it hits a nerve because there’s much agitation about Scotland’s subsidy. I’ve just been doing the papers on Sky News with Dawn Butler who said this policy was anti-Scottish. Wrongly: it was originally proposed by The Scotsman many years ago. Polls show

Alex Massie

Press Management By Dummies

Say what one may about the Blair-Brown years but I’m not sure even they would be mad brazen enough to try something like this: The Federal Emergency Management Agency’s No. 2 official apologized yesterday for leading a staged news conference Tuesday in which FEMA employees posed as reporters while real reporters listened on a telephone conference line and were barred from asking questions. “We are reviewing our press procedures and will make the changes necessary to ensure that all of our communications are straight forward and transparent,” Vice Adm. Harvey E. Johnson Jr., FEMA’s deputy administrator, said in a four-paragraph statement. “We can and must do better, and apologize for

Brown has set a trap into which Tory Eurosceptics must not march

Gordon Brown looks like a moth-eaten Prime Minister nowadays. His botched handling of a general election and his help in unifying the Conservatives have been the unexpected hallmarks of an amateur, not a consummate professional. If one adds to this his unpopular protestations that the European Treaty does not require the promised referendum, it would seem that never again will it be glad confident morn for his tenure in Downing Street. But with Gordon Brown one should always read the small print before getting too excited. He has promised more than 20 days’ debate in the House of Commons before the Treaty is ratified. Week after week of debate may

A hellfire sermon for HSBC’s boss

Matthew Lynn says shareholder activist Eric Knight is right to castigate HSBC’s strategy, and that the bank’s deeply religious chairman Stephen Green now faces a battle to hang on to his job When he isn’t running the world’s second biggest bank, Stephen Green, the chairman of HSBC, is an ordained priest and amateur theologian. In 1996 he published Serving God? Serving Mammon? Christians and the Financial Markets, in which he explored whether you can do the Lord’s work whilst also commuting to Canary Wharf every morning to do battle in the boardroom and kick ass on the trading floor. ‘Christians can serve God in the world of finance and commerce,

‘We take the risks that private finance can’t’

Even being soaked by driving rain isn’t enough to dampen Jonathan Kestenbaum’s passion for innovation. Even being soaked by driving rain isn’t enough to dampen Jonathan Kestenbaum’s passion for innovation. The chief executive of Britain’s largest source of endowment funds (£350 million and counting) arrives in the Notting Hill coffee shop where we are meeting, shakes off his coat, and within seconds is talking with almost religious fervour about how well-targeted public finance can promote technological and social change. The National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts (NESTA), which he runs, is difficult to categorise. It began in 1998 with £200 million from the National Lottery. It has both

James Forsyth

Cameron’s outdated foreign policy

David Cameron’s speech in Berlin today on foreign policy advocated a cautious, liberal conservative approach to foreign policy. It is very different, at least in tone, from the foreign policy vision that he set out when running for leader.  The sound bite from today’s speech is ‘national security first.’ Leaving aside the unpleasant historical associations that the phrase has, it is so intellectually outdated as to be meaningless. We can’t have national security—even in the very narrowest sense of the word—in this country, while foreign-funded religious institutions try to convert young British Muslims to a perverted form of faith that sees opposition to the British state as a religious duty and British