World

Alex Massie

Swine Flu Panic

The latest news should obviously have you feeling Very, Very Afraid: Mexico has revised down the suspected death toll from swine flu from 176 to 101, indicating that the outbreak may not be as bad as was initially feared. Health Minister Jose Angel Cordova told the BBC that, based on samples tested, the mortality rate was comparable with that of seasonal flu. You don’t say! Will this be reflected in the media coverage? Don’t be silly. I mean, the hospitals are sending people home even though they don’t have swine flu…

Alex Massie

Petain, de Gaulle and Patriotism

As part of an excellent back-and-forth with Daniel Larison on the question of patritism, Noah Millman asks: Can one hold that both Marsall Petain and General de Gaulle were French patriots? I think the answer to this one has to be “yes.” You can’t hold that both were right, but you can believe that both were acting sincerely out of patriotic motives – that both were doing what they felt was best for France as France. I rather agree with this, but would go further and argue that you can hold that both Petain and de Gaulle were right. That is, if one imagines onself as a Frenchman in the

Alex Massie

Faith and Begorrah…

Good lord, it’s like the last thirty years never happened: the Irish government wants a new law to prohibit blasphemy. If passed then, astonishingly, the courts will be asked to decide if the supposed victim has been sufficiently outraged for there to have been an offence. Remarkable. And expensive too since it could cost you up to €100,000 and a visit from the Gardai Siochana to confiscate the “offensive material”. As Carol Coulter explains: For that to happen, a court will have to be satisfied the matter published is “grossly abusive or insulting in relation to matters held sacred by any religion, thereby causing outrage among a substantial number of

Alex Massie

Karl Rove and the Limits of the Presidency

Karl Rove’s latest column is quite something. He writes that: Another emphasis in the Obama 100 days talking points is that the president is a decisive leader. However, Mr. Obama is enormously deferential to Democrats in Congress and has outsourced formulation of key policies to them. He appears largely ambivalent about the contents of important legislation, satisfied to simply sign someone else’s bill. On the $787 billion stimulus package, he specified less than a quarter of the bill’s spending and let House Appropriations Chairman Dave Obey decide the rest. On cap and trade, Mr. Obama is comfortable to let Democratic Reps. Henry Waxman and Edward Markey write that legislation with

Alex Massie

The Unbearable Deliciousness of Minaret-Shaped Candy

Like Mr Larison I wish Mr Salam had not cut this paragraph from this (excellent) piece on the popularity of the paranoid style: So despite the fact that Obama has been a church-going Christian for most of his adult life, more than a tenth of the country believes that while roaming the streets of Jakarta as an elementary schooler, Obama met some wily bearded imam who lured him into his roving Muslim-mobile with delicious minaret-shaped candies and converted him to radical Islam. Dazzled by his obvious intelligence, and convinced long before David Axelrod that Americans were itching to elect a half-Kenyan youth as president, he also sold young Obama on

Alex Massie

Barack Obama and King Canute

No-one would argue that Barack Obama is without ego. Then again, that’s also true of most politicians. Mark Steyn, however, objects that Obama “seems to see himself as Nelson Mandela and the previous regime as the old National Party”. This seems a stretch given that the evidence proffered is Obama’s quip that We cannot pretend somehow that because Barack Hussein Obama got elected as president, suddenly everything is going to be okay. Steyn suggests the offence – or the arrogance – of this was made worse by the fact that Obama was speaking in Strasbourg at the time. But itsn’t it obvious that, on this occasion at least, Obama is

India is in peril. Obama is making it worse

Brahma Chellaney says that India is indeed ‘the sponge that protects us all’ from terrorism emanating from Pakistan. The new President’s strategy is compounding the Af-Pak problem New Delhi One of the most striking things about the larger Asian strategic landscape is that India is wedged in an arc of failing or troubled states. This harsh reality is India’s most glaring weakness; its neighbourhood is so combustible as to impose a tyranny of geography. Today, Pakistan’s rapid Talebanisation tops India’s concerns. After all, the brunt of escalating terrorism from Pakistan will be borne by India, which already has become, in the words of ex-US official Ashley Tellis, ‘the sponge that

Alex Massie

Government Rules Out Recreating Workhouses, Debtors Prison Etc

Sometimes it seems as though the British appetite for nostalgia can never be satisfied. On the other hand, it seems there are in fact limits to our willingness to recreate the past, albeit often as pastiche. Announcing plans for new prisons, Jack Straw reassured/disappointed us by promising: “These new prisons will be neither Victorian replicas nor large warehouses,” Mr Straw said. Does this mean they’ll be modern and bijou instead? Perhaps not, since rather than build three huge prisons, they’re planning to construct five very large ones. And then again, the government is missing a trick here: recreating Victorian prisons might be quite popular…

Ancient & Modern | 25 April 2009

Paeans of praise are being heaped on US President Barack Obama for being able to speak well in public, while commentators trace his skill back to the rules of rhetoric invented by Aristotle and Cicero. Plato would be spitting. The main difference between our orators and the ancient Greek rhêtor in democratic Athens is that the ancient rhêtor had no political power whatsoever. He was trying to persuade an Assembly of citizens (males over 18) to do what he wanted, but it was they who made the final decision whether to act on his advice or not. In our system, an Obama or Brown can speak well or badly, intelligibly

Alex Massie

Dolly Parton: Still Fab After All This Time

A lovely piece on the Queen of the Smokey Mountains, Dolly Parton, by Jesse Green in this week’s edition of New York magazine. Here is the Backwoods Barbie in typically forthright, charming form:  “I’m an energy vampire,” she says. “I just suck off everybody’s energy, but I give it back.” She almost dares me to ask her something tawdry: “What else ya got?” But like the fan in the hilarious documentary For the Love of Dolly who finds Judy’s car in a mall parking lot and can think of nothing better to do once inside than lick the seat belt on the passenger side, I find myself deranged by her

Alex Massie

Denying the Armenians

So, as expected Barack Obama has reneged upon his campaign promise to call the Armenian genocide, er, genocide. Instead it’s “slaughter”. Such are the prosaic demands of office. As Mike Crowley suggests this is not a defining moment in the Obama administration, but nor is it a particularly edifying spectacle. Memo to politicians: be careful what you promise! Memo to voters: Don’t believe the promises! Today’s statement in full here; reaction from Turks and Armenians here. UPDATE: Courtesy of Ben Smith there’s this video in which Samantha Power argues that: “What is amazing about Barack…[is]…his willingness as president to commemorate [the genocide] and certainly to call a spade a spade

Alex Massie

Torture, Dissidents and Talking to Dictators

Daniel Henninger in the Wall Street Journal today: In New York this week, I asked a former Eastern European dissident who spent time in prison under the Communists: “If you were sitting in a cell in Cuba, Iran or Syria and saw this photo of a smiling American president shaking hands with a smiling Hugo Chávez, what would you think?” He said: “I would think that I was losing ground.” Fair enough. Hugo Chavez isn’t my cup of tea either. But it’s hardly that unusual for American presidents to be photographed with autocrats and dictators. More importantly, however, if I were to ask a former Soviet dissident: “If you learned

Alex Massie

Caption Contest: When Obama Met Lara

Brian Lara gives President Barack Obama a lesson, during last week’s Summit of the Americas in Trinidad. Photo: White House photo by Pete Souza. Kridaya rounds up some of the cricketsphere’s reaction to the President’s meeting with the Prince of Trinidad. Obama is said to have been delighted by his encounter with “the Michael Jordan” of cricket. While well-intentioned – and doubtless popular in Trinidad – this won’t, as you know, quite do. Technically, there are clearly some issues with elbow flex and, vitally, weight transference. Obama looks as though he’s going to be attempting a front-foot drive while keeping his weight on his back leg. This ensures his head

Fraser Nelson

The top ten Brownies of Budget 2009

This was a Budget of tricks, of bogus assumptions and of huge traps for the Conservatives. As Lord Lamont says, it was historic in its admission of failure. I do tire of the Treasury’s approach: every Budget we get pie-in-the-sky forecasts, which are torn up later. But the effect of these fake forecasts is to advance (or, in this case, protect) state spending. For all the mentions of 2014/15 this is a Budget designed to last no more than a year.  Here are my top ten Brownies. 1. The “trampoline recovery” theory is a fiction.  To reassure the debt markets (on whom the UK government is now utterly dependent) HMT

Alex Massie

The American Justification for War

Linking to this post, Daniel Larison makes an excellent point: Even though this claim about fighting on behalf of innocent Muslims is dubious (not least because several of our wars, especially the war in Iraq, have killed or led to the killing of hundreds of thousands of these people), it reflects something basic to Americanism. This is the idea that anytime the U.S. fights a war, no matter what the actual reasons for it are, whichever group or nation comes out ahead at the end of the fighting must show eternal gratitude to us. It is apparently an additional requirement that anytime the U.S. fights a war that may benefit

Budget 2009: A crisis waiting to happen?

At a few minutes to one o’clock today the country’s fate passed from the Chancellor and was cast on the waters of the money markets.  Public borrowing will be £175bn this year and £173bn the following year. From the very start of the crisis the Government has consistently underrated its severity.  Even so, Britain will proportionately be borrowing more than any other G8 country. Are the funds out there to meet the colossal requirements of G8 countries?  Where do we rate in the international league tables as to whom colossal sums should be lent? In these very early stages the Government is finding the gilts market sticky when it comes

What to expect in the Budget

After a decade of reckless spending, the government’s kitty is bare and its debts are mounting. In November, Alastair Darling said the economy would shrink just 2%, but predicted, Micawber-style, that it would turn up in mid-2009. Well, the economists’ consensus is that it actually shrank 3.7%, and that it’s hardly going to turn up this year at all. Unemployment’s already 2 million, heading for 3.2 million. That’s a lot more people drawing benefits and not paying taxes. And there’s those expensive bank bailouts to pay for. So the Chancellor is borrowing wildly. Again, the economists’ consensus is that he borrowed £160 billion in 2008-09 and will need another £167

The state of the railways

The Treasury thought the railways were in terminal decline. John Major’s government thought they were a political nuisance — vexed commuters meant lost voters. Privatisation would get the railways off the government’s back, and breaking them into 100 pieces would mean that if one piece was on strike, the other 99 would not be. In the event, they refused to go away, and have maintained an obstinate tendency to put on business. Successive governments have had to cope with the consequences, and we must soon be due for the next set of answers. For New Labour, sweeping into power a dozen years ago, the first and easiest answer was to

Alex Massie

Bombing Iran? Counter-productive and unlikely to even work.

Of all the many reasons to be wary of bombing Iran, one of the best is also one of the simplest: it won’t work. Or, rather, whatever advantage there may be in delaying Iran’s nuclear ambitions by a year or two is unlikely to be worth the unfortunate consequences involved, merely increasing the risks of a nuclear Iran further down the line. As Deence Secretary Robert Gates says: Using his strongest language on the subject to date, Gates told a group of Marine Corps students that a strike would probably delay Tehran’s nuclear program from one to three years. A strike, however, would unify Iran, “cement their determination to have

Obama’s 100 days and Guido’s triumph

There’s a special pullout in this week’s issue of the magazine, analysing Obama’s first 100 days in power.  All the article from it are available online, and you can access them via these links: Reihan Salam, the leading young conservative intellectual, argues that although Obama isn’t doing badly, the sheen has already come off his presidency. Adam Boulton opens up his Washington diary. Irwin Stelzer says that Obama’s budget shows that he wants to turn the United States into a European-style social democracy British Conservatives may be reaching the end of their term in the wilderness. American Republicans look to be just beginning theirs, writes David Frum For all her