World

James Forsyth

Hard cases make bad law

The row over Fred Goodwin’s pension reminds me of the debate over the alleged killers of Stephen Lawrence and whether the law of double-jeopardy should be altered to allow them to be prosecuted again for his murder. It is clearly morally wrong that Goodwin should be receiving such massive rewards for failure, a £693,000 annual pension for ruining two great banks. But there’s also little doubt that, thanks to the government not checking the fine print before they signed off on him retiring early, that he is legally entitled to it. It is tempting to rewrite, or bend, the law to redress this wrong as it is (far more intensely

Alex Massie

Pakistan Edges Closer to the Abyss

Sometimes it’s the seemingly minor events – minor, that is, in the grand scheme of matters, not necessarily small or insignificant at the moment they occur – that can carry more weight than more obviously important or telling developments. Lord knows, there’s been no end of troubling news from Pakistan in recent years. But, silly as it may seem, there’s something especially terrible about today’s attack on the Sri Lankan cricket team which killed at least six policemen and injured five members of the Sri Lankan team. (See Cricinfo’s rolling updates for the latest news.) Political assassinations, for instance, are hardly unknown in Pakistan (or elsewhere on the subcontinent) and

Alex Massie

Pollsters Go To War

I sometimes wonder about pollsters and political consultants. That is, I wonder if they are rather like the financial Masters of the Universe whose mastery turns out, it seems, to have been somewhat exaggerated. That’s not say there aren’t differences between well-run campaigns (Barack Obama) and lousy, ill-focused, foolish ones (Hillary Clinton), rather that the benefits of good political advice aren’t nearly so great as the damage caused by poor advice and ill-conceived strategy. Hindsight is always useful, of course, but imagine how different the race for the Democratic party’s presidential nomination might have been had the Clinton campaign remembered that it might be useful to compete seriously in caucus

The Oxbridge Elitism Debate: Lynne Featherstone Intervenes

I always worry about attacks on the so-called elitism of our top universities. It strikes me that academic excellence must always be the “sine qua non” of access to the best institutions in the country. It must be in the interests of those institutions to open their doors to the widest possible pool of talent. And of course Oxford, Cambridge and other institutions must look for potential in students from state school backgrounds as well as taking the ready-made products of the public school system.  But this is not as simple as it sounds. Friends of mine involved in the admissions process tell me in is very difficult to make these judgements — how

Alex Massie

Today’s government news

Avigdor Lieberman – Israel’s new kingmaker and, according to no less a hawk than Marty Peretz, a “neo-fascist” – says his ideas on citizenship really aren’t any different from those espoused by Gordon Brown’s government. Elsewhere, regardless of whether or not Fred Goodwin “deserves” a £650,000 pension is becomes abundantly clear that, despite this still being Hang-a-Banker season, the government’s descent into idiotic, populist pandering should also be resisted. Goodwin’s pension may indeed be excessive, but John Prescott will receive £60,000 a year from the public purse which seems equally generous or, if you prefer, scandalous. Thirdly, it turns out that Jack Straw has a rather strained relationship with the

Alex Massie

How do you know Obama will defend Israel? John Bolton says he won’t.

How do you know the Obama administration isn’t “soft” on Israel? John Bolton says it is. To wit, Bolton was asked at CPAC today if Obama would defend Israel “when” the “Arab nations” attack it and here’s what he said: BOLTON: I would certainly hope they would come to Israel’s assistance, but I think there’s no guarantee of it. I think the more likely response is to appoint a special envoy and try to negotiate an end the hostilities. Q: Your short answer then would be “no”. BOLTON: I very much fear that’s right. Bolton is an engaging fellow who is always good copy (apart from anything else he is

Alex Massie

Holding out for a hero: GOP division.

I don’t know why Bobby Jindal, the Republican party’s Great Brown Hope, agreed to give the GOP response to Obama’s speech last night. Supposedly a privilege, this more often turns out to be a fools errand. Indeed, the only successful opposition response I can recall in recent years was given by Senator Jim Webb. Generally, however, the poor sap offered the chance to go up against the President is on a hiding to nothing: the man in charge has the full majesty of his office behind him; the opposition spokesman sits in a wee room on their own waiting for their chance to give a speech no-one is very interested

Alex Massie

The Age of Obama

WASHINGTON – FEBRUARY 24: U.S. President Barack Obama addresses a joint meeting of the U.S. Congress February 24, 2009 at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, DC. Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images. And so it begins. The contrast between Barack Obama last night and George W Bush was striking. Not merely in terms of the content of their speeches, but in their demeanour: whereas Bush seemed a shrunken figure in his final years, dwarfed by the enormity of the challenges of the Presidency and by the scale of his own blunders, Obama, armed with the confidence of victory and unburdened by the oppressive turn of events, seemed to fit his surroundings

Alex Massie

Salmond’s Confederacy?

Alex Salmond has been in Washington, where he snagged an audience with Hillary Clinton and delivered a speech at Georgetown University. Hamish Macdonnell explains: In a speech on Monday he took the time to praise Abraham Lincoln. This is what he said: “A man whose spirit and example will light America’s path for centuries to come. And a man whose name evokes, in the minds of your friends worldwide, the very highest image of America.” It did not take long, however, for Labour spin doctors to point out that Lincoln was, of course, the one man who did more to keep the Union in America together, even going to war

Nuclear aspirations

Well worth reading the splash story in today’s Independent.  It reveals that four “leading environmentalists” have given their backing to nuclear power, despite being opposed to it in the past.  One of them – Stephen Tindale, the former director of Greenpeace – relates his experience thus: “It was kind of like a religious conversion. Being anti-nuclear was an essential part of being an environmentalist for a long time but now that I’m talking to a number of environmentalists about this, it’s actually quite widespread this view that nuclear power is not ideal but it’s better than climate change.” Now, I imagine a few CoffeeHousers might be thinking: “Who cares what

Alex Massie

Obama and Israel

Melanie Phillips makes a pretty remarkable claim at the end of this post: The fact is that Israel faces the nightmare scenario that it now stands alone — and against America. Whether through naivety, ideology or rank malice, there is now a fifth columnist in the White House, undermining the cause of the free world. The vast majority of Americans who staunchly support Israel’s struggle to exist in the face of genocidal attack, and understand only too well its role as the front line of defence for the free world, need to become aware of what is being done in their name. As polemic, this is fine stuff. But as

Alex Massie

Annals of Policing

Not much gets past the Garda Siochana… HE WAS one of Ireland’s most reckless drivers, a serial offender who crossed the country wantonly piling up dozens of speeding fines and parking tickets while somehow managing to elude the law. So effective was his modus operandi of giving a different address each time he was caught that by June 2007 there were more than 50 separate entries under his name, Prawo Jazdy, in the Garda Pulse system. And still not a single conviction. In the end, the vital clue to his identity lay not with Interpol or the fingerprint database but in the pages of a Polish-English dictionary. Prawo jazdy means

Alex Massie

Hillaryland takes on the world

Mike Crowley has a characteristically interesting piece on Hillary Clinton’s State Department, asking the question: “Huge expectations, big egos, turf wars: Is Clinton’s State Department just like her campaign?” Even allowing for the fact that this may be a marginally premature question there’s some good stuff in there. Old habits die hard however, and there’s always the temptation to view anything Clintonian in the most sceptical, conspiracy-fuelled light. Remember: just because it’s fun doesn’t mean it can’t be true! Premise: Hillary Clinton still has ambitions to be President of the United States. Traditional Clintonian intrigue demands that all her actions, no matter how sweetly reasonable they may seem, be viewed

Alex Massie

World Gone Mad: French Division

Things you never thought you would see: the French government advising against wine consumption… In the midst of the winter gloom, President Sarkozy’s administration  has chosen this moment to tell its people to stop drinking wine. You are hearing right. The Ministry of Health has issued rules for reducing the risk of cancer and one of the main ones is never drink alcohol.  “The consumption of alcohol, and especially wine, is discouraged,” say guidelines that are drawn from the findings of the National Cancer Institute (INCA). A single glass of wine per day will raise your chance of contracting cancer by up to 168 percent, it says. A you might expect, the

Alex Massie

Carrying the Country First

An excellent post from Blimpish, making the point that while Labour governments tend to be elected with great enthusiasm, voters are usually more cautious when choosing Conservative ministries. It was only in 1983 that Thatcher won her landslide (Reagan, of course, emulated her example in 1984). And as he says, you don’t need to win your party (completely) to win the country: Thatcher’s latter-day hero-worshippers may believe the British people enthusiastically embraced the full-blooded Thatcherite agenda of sound money, free markets, union-busting, etc.  But it wasn’t the case; leaving aside that what became ‘Thatcherism’ didn’t really exist in 1979, inasmuch as it was articulated, people were generally sceptical – after

Alex Massie

The Sporting White House

I take my hat off to Katty Kay. Writing at the Daily Beast she comes up with a novel criticism of the Obama administration: it’s too fond of  sports metaphors. Seriously. This, apparently, is “insidiously sexist” and consequently unfair to female political reporters trying to understand how the White House is approaching any given matter. I’d have thought that this injustice was scarcely limited to women, since presumably male reporters with no interest in baseball or basketball would be similarly disadvantaged. But perhaps not. Still, this shouldn’t surprise anyone: after all it is the media that loves to cover politics as a “horse race” (reducing politics to the level of

Alex Massie

In Praise of Stella Rimington

A statement of the obvious perhaps, but a welcome one nonetheless given that it’s hard to see how Stella Rimington, as a former head of MI5, can sensibly be caricatured as a weak-kneed, soft-on-terrorism simpleton: “Since I have retired I feel more at liberty to be against certain decisions of the Government, especially the attempt to pass laws which interfere with people’s privacy,” Dame Stella said in an interview with a Spanish newspaper. “It would be better that the Government recognised that there are risks, rather than frightening people in order to be able to pass laws which restrict civil liberties, precisely one of the objects of terrorism: that we

Alex Massie

Republicans and Churchill

As if determined to prove my point about the absurd excesses of the GOP’s love for Winston Churchill, consider this entertaining snippet culled from the pages of the Washington Post: But  Rep. Eric Cantor (Va.), the House minority whip who led the fight to deny Obama every GOP vote for the plan, is studying Winston Churchill’s role leading the Tories in the late 1930s, a principled minority that was eventually catapulted into power over the Labor Party. He calls the stimulus bill “a stinker.” Well! It’s a shame the Post doesn’t seem to know any more British history than does Mr Cantor; then again it’s a shame Mr Cantor should

Reporting protest

Anyone who has ever been on a protest march or felt the heady frission of student rebelliousness should check out Hugo Rifkind’s piece in the Times today. A really subtle piece of reporting, with no hint of the usual establishment sneer. What’s fascinating about his observations the history of student revolt is how similar the present wave of sit-ins is to the protests of the past. The latest generation of student revolutionaries use the Israeli action in Gaza as their starting point but their real gripe is with global capitalism. They know as little about the realities of life in Isreal’s occupied territories as their precursors in the 1968 “events”

Ancient & Modern | 14 February 2009

‘On this day, we come to proclaim an end to the petty grievances and false promises, the recriminations and worn-out dogmas, that for far too long have strangled our politics.’ So said President Obama on his inauguration. ‘On this day, we come to proclaim an end to the petty grievances and false promises, the recriminations and worn-out dogmas, that for far too long have strangled our politics.’ So said President Obama on his inauguration. It is not often that an American President so immediately, so publicly and so thoroughly trashes his predecessor. The Romans had a phrase for it: damnatio memoriae. It applied after the death of anyone considered a