Politics

Read about the latest UK political news, views and analysis.

James Forsyth

Clarke’s comments suggest the Tories are moving towards favouring a ‘bad bank’ 

Ken Clarke’s interview with Patrick Hennessy of The Sunday Telegraph is notable both for Clarke’s continuing message discipline and for his hint that the Tories are moving towards favouring a ‘bad bank’. When pressed on what he would do if David Cameron did call a referendum on Lisbon with the Tories calling for a no vote, Clarke replies:  “”If we have a referendum, I doubt that Central Office [Tory HQ] will be on the phone asking me to campaign on it. I think if the other campaign got hold of me I’d have to say I am not available.” This answer gives almost nothing to anyone trying to write a

Anyone Feel Sorry for Tessa Jowell?

I have already been teased by the readers of this blog for suggesting that it was possible to feel sympathy for Tessa Jowell and her family over the conviction of her solicitor husband David Mills. Now you have the chance to read my thoughts on the Olympics minister at more length in today’s Observer, where I have written a profile of Jowell.  It is easy to understand why the traditional left despises Jowell. For them she is the very essence of the business-worshipping Blairite. Jowell herself would not be entirely unhappy about this. As said told me in an interview in 2006: “Just as we should be proud of our relationship with the trade

Alex Massie

Gordon Brown, Lawrence Oates and Polly Toynbee

Polly Toynbee is always worth reading. Her latest column is no exception. For all that one might disagree with her, indeed even be infuriated by her, there’s always something useful to be gleaned from her columns. Still, there’s a kind of panicked resignation about this latest one and an implied acceptance that Labour are doomed. The only thing that can save them? Massive increases in spending and government debt apparently. Well it’s an idea… I confess that, rather mean-spiritedly, my favourite bit was this: In the dream scenario, Brown ascends the world stage to head a beefed-up IMF, but few imagine the man who wanted it so much can confess

‘I was asked if I would wear Nicole Kidman’s breasts’

Geraldine James, recently notorious as the breast-feeding mother in Little Britain, talks to Tim Walker about her role in Howard Barker’s Victory Geraldine James’s agent telephoned one day and asked if she would care to play an over-protective mother. And he added there was something that she ought to know: it involved breast-feeding and, ah yes, the recipient would be a man in his thirties. The distinguished stage and screen actress has always liked surprising people and that was why, after she had seen the script, she agreed to appear in the ‘Bitty’ sketches in Little Britain — although not, she hastens to add, with her own breasts. ‘Everybody assumes

James Forsyth

Politics | 21 February 2009

James Forsyth reviews the week in politics The worst thing about this week for Gordon Brown is that no one has bothered to dub it his worst week ever. Normally, a few days which saw a Prime Minister receive the succession of blows that Brown has suffered since Saturday would lead to forests being chopped down and extra barrels of newsprint being ordered in. But we have now reached a political moment where it can be revealed that the government is reduced to querying David Cameron’s name when it appears on Number 10 party guest lists, a key government policy adviser defects to the Tories, someone ‘quite close to the

The closet radical

David Cameron’s path towards power has been long and winding, and may twist and turn yet more before the general election. Tony Blair’s march to Number 10 between 1994 and 1997 was relatively linear. Mr Cameron, in contrast, was underdog in his party’s leadership race in 2005, wobbled badly in the summer of 2007, recovered after the election-that-never-was and then faced a resurgent Gordon Brown as the scale of the global downturn became clear last September. In the course of this political rollercoaster ride, it has been easy to lose sight of what ought to be the most important fact in British politics: namely that Mr Cameron is still likely

The week that was | 20 February 2009

Fraser Nelson continues the Spectator Inquiry into the causes of the recession, and marks a first anniversary that shouldn’t be celebrated. James Forsyth gives his take on the Labour leadership speculation, and says that the London G20 Summit can’t live up to expectations. Peter Hoskin outlines a day of good and bad news for the Tories, and spots the vultures circling above Downing Street. Lisa Hilton laments Italy’s apathetic attitude towards corruption. Daniel Korski analyses Obama’s mini-surge. Martin Bright observes the irresistible rise of the Lib Dems. Clive Davis gives his take on the Allen Stanford case. Alex Massie notes when English is actually British. Melanie Phillips marks a requiem

The Irresistible Rise of the Liberal Democrats

If there is one message Labour and Conservative politicians should take into the next election it is never to underestimate the Liberal Democrats. They always do better than you expect them to, especially in an electoral system where there is no rational reason to vote for them. There have now been two opinion polls this month putting them at 22 per cent, the level they reached at the last general election and a high-water mark in recent times. Could it be that the Liberal Democrats under Clegg and Cable can make a pitch to overtake Labour and become the real opposition to the resurgent Tories? Martin Kettle certainly thinks so

Alex Massie

The Davis Agenda

I suspect Peter is right and that David Davis’s remarks about “the Davis agenda” will raise a few eyebrows. But I find them encouraging. There’s an obvious upside to Davis returning to the front bench at some point since, despite the Tory parties advantageous position in the polls, the party could do with the extra muscle Davis would bring. From the point of view of civil liberties, however, there’s something to be said for Davis prowling the back benches, keeping an eye on a Tory party that may well find it too easy to slide away from the civil libertarian agenda once it’s in power. Davis, then, has an important

Fraser Nelson

The Abu Qatada case shows up the lunacy of the ECHR

It is, of course, lunacy to have £2,500 of taxpayers’ money sent to Abu Qatada as per the instructions of the European Court of Human Rights. But what would a Conservative government do about this? It is crucial to remember that David Cameron’s proposed Bill of Rights would itself enact the ECHR and, therefore, not be much use. As it stands, it’s more of a media decoy – and this need not be so. The UK remains a sovereign country – all it would take is an act of Parliament declaring that the Bill of Rights would outrank any other jurisdiction and that we have our own laws. Not that

Alex Massie

Blue Dog Democrats and RINOs

Ezra Klein asks why the Democratic party doesn’t treat “unreliable” Democrats quite as badly* as the GOP hunts down “Republicans in Name Only” such as Arlen Specter.  There are few consequences to being a Blue Dog Democrat. Labor doesn’t come into your district and fund a challenger who attacks your votes to cut entitlement spending. Business interests are more likely to donate to your campaign. You have a badge of independence from party which is useful both when dealing with the media and when dealing with voters. Your vote matters more because it’s less reliable. And the Democratic Party infrastructure itself is fundamentally sympathetic to your plight: Democrats from marginal

Alex Massie

Rugby League Pipedreams

Here’s today’s nominee for Most Deluded Man in Britain (Non-Government Division): Wigan head coach Brian Noble believes Super League clubs should be buying up rugby union’s big stars. The former GB coach is advocating the scheme in order to bring more British and Irish talent into the sport. “Every club should be given a remit to sign one union home nations player,” Noble told The Super League Show. “Just imagine the national headlines our game would generate for bringing the likes of a Jonny Wilkinson or a Brian O’Driscoll across.” Just imagine! Well that’s all you can do, isn’t it? I can’t think of a single reason why any leading

There is no dignity in this Alzheimer’s parade

In the week that John Suchet made his wife’s dementia public, Carol Sarler questions this revelatory trend. Is it really what the sufferers would have wanted? Her end, when it came, was beyond ghastly. Iris Murdoch, one of our doughtier literary intellects, was reduced to screaming, drooling delirium at one end of her frail body and to defecation without any sense of suitable time or place at the other. All of this we know because, exactly 10 years ago, her husband told us, when he wrote of ‘the lady whom I sat on the loo this morning, wiped her bottom and scrubbed her hands and her brown fingernails’. John Bayley’s

Alex Massie

When English is actually British

George Monbiot raises a complaint one has seen several times lately: Had Heathrow’s third runway been debated only by English MPs, the proposal would have been resoundingly defeated; it was approved by 19 votes, after 67 MPs from the other nations were induced to support the government. They can support such measures without any electoral risk, as their constituents are not directly affected. Except that, in this instance at least, a so-called English issue is actually a British issue. Heathrow’s capacity – indeed the capacity of all the London airports – is a matter of interest north of the border. After all, Heathrow is Scotland’s most important air connection to

Alex Massie

Local Tories

The Conservatives new approach to localism – or subsidiarity – deserves a couple of cheers. It is at least a step in the right direction. Just as well since, allied with Tory education policy and, one might argue, some burnished environmental credentials, this “New Localism” is supposed to be the “Big Idea” animating a renewed, reinvigorated Toryism. So, while today’s announcement is welcome, it’s also imcomplete. Apart from anything else, local accountability requires local financing. There’s not enough in the Tory proposals (yet) to link local councils with local sources of revenue. As the Scottish Parliament has demonstrated, if there’s no link between policy and revenue-raising then more money is

Fraser Nelson

A first anniversary that shouldn’t be celebrated

It’s the anniversary of the Northern Rock nationalisation today, and I’ve just done a discussion on Simon Mayo’s R5 programme arguing why the occasion is not to be celebrated. Rosie Winterton, the pensions minister, was saying nationalisation was a great success. Her argument is worth recording here because it gives a clue why Labour’s poll rating may sink sink further. Look at the pensioners, Winterton said; nationalisation of NR rescued them from losing all their savings. Did it really? Wasn’t the the savings guarantee offered on 9 Oct 07 (which stopped the run on the bank)? Nationalisation – or, as it was called then, “temporary public ownership” – came in

Alex Massie

Marie Antoinette is traduced again

Like King Canute, Marie Antoinette is a much-misunderstood and, generally speaking, a much and unfairly maligned figure. Disappointingly, this time the guilty party is my old boss Iain Martin. For shame. Iain hazards that Peter Mandelson’s suggestion that everyone try and keep their heads in these turbulent times since there is “no value in creating frenzy” is but the latest “Marie Antoinettish” comment from the noble lord. In the first place, Marie Antoinette probably never said “Let them eat cake”. Secondly, if she had she would scarcely have been the first to suggest that the populace switch to brioche in times of shortage. Thirdly, this would have been a perfectly

Alex Massie

Three Terms are Enough

Brother Bright gives some of his reasons for hoping that Labour will prevail at the next election here. As a good man of the left, one would expect no less from him. And he’s right, I think, to suppose that we’d be facing many of the same problems had David Cameron and Georgie Osbourne been running the country these past five years. In that sense, you can undertsand the frustration some of the Prime Minister’s supporters must feel. Not all of this is the PM’s fault, but he’s the only fellow the public can kick. But for those of us who aren’t automatically attached to any party the calculation is

Never Underestimate the Lib Dems

I know we are not supposed to take ComRes polls too seriously but there’s one aspect of the Independent on Sunday poll at the weekend that I really rings true. It may not quite be the case that Lib Dem support is up by seven percentage points and Labour down by seven. But I am convinced that the Lib Dems are not being squeezed in quite the way we are led to believe. The perspective of the Westminster bubble is particularly cruel on Nick Clegg’s merry band. Anyone who has seen the orangey-yellow machine in full flight in local or national elections will know it is a force to be reckoned with.

Can The Government Dig Itself Out ? (2)

From the response to the last post on this subject I get the impression that people around here don’t much care if the government can did itself out or not. Some readers of The Bright Stuff have asked how I can justify wanting Labour to win the next election? But more of that later. First I want to examine the horror of the situation a little. I have finally read the Independent on Sunday’s interview with HBOS whistleblower Paul Moore. Jaw-dropping or what! It’s always wrong to leave the Sindy till last in the weekend reading pile because so often it punches above its weight. It would be one of the