Spectator poems
From the magazine

Charlie

Janet Sutherland
EXPLORE THE ISSUE 19 July 2025
issue 19 July 2025

i.m. Charles Ferdinand Smyth, born 9 January 1865 at Stephen’s Green; died February 1871 of rheumatic fever

29 June 1876, Hokitika, South Island, New Zealand – All went in search of the donkey, Dandybear, & found the truant half way on the road to Kaneiri. The children ride on this animal on saddles of home manufacture. I dressed up as Mrs Byrne in the evening to edify the children, but remained in cog. Took them on my knee & sang comic ditties but the innocents did not see through the disguise.
(From the journal of Victor Emmanuel Smyth) 

When little Charlie took sick

he’d wake from sleep and scream

restless at night he tossed in our arms

we had no idea he’d go so soon      he who 

was never done talking      who had

so many questions      whose greatest delight 

was to ‘play in the garden with Papa’

and if Papa wouldn’t, he’d kiss him and say 

‘Do dear Papa’ with such emphasis on the ‘dear’

there was fear for his heart     its painful 

agitation      affected his breathing

a blister was put to it     a blister for the heart

all that fortnight he took just a little light biscuit 

with blackberry jelly and small sips of water

he said ‘Mama I’m sick’  ‘Mama I’m tired’

How do we live in this world with such grief?